CreateDebate


Debate Info

18
3
Legal Illegal
Debate Score:21
Arguments:9
Total Votes:26
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Legal (6)
 
 Illegal (3)

Debate Creator

Lucasban(105) pic



Selling the Moon

That guy who is selling it. (www.space.com)

Legal

Side Score: 18
VS.

Illegal

Side Score: 3
4 points

If anyone's dumb enough to believe they're buying pieces of the moon, then they deserve to be conned. I could try to sell rooms in the white house to people, but I don't own the white house, so buying a room from me would be meaningless. I suspect when people finally get to the moon it'll be like the land rush again, where people just set up a house and if they survive there for a few years, then they'll legally own it.

Side: Legal

I couldn't have said it better myself. You get an up vote.

NOTE: I rarely vote.

Side: Legal
3 points

If we can sell stars, then why shouldn't we be able to sell the moon? The only difference is that it's closer to our planet. In my opinion, no one deserves the right to say they "own" to moon, but if someone wants to be suckered out of money by someone who claims that he can sell you a piece of public property then that is your problem.

Side: Legal
3 points

DING DING DING we have a winner.

Side: this is stupid
3 points

The answers given here (legal and illegal) are slightly misleading. I hardly think that what he is doing is actually illegal. It says in the article (and I have heard this previously) that he has gone down all legal means of attaining ownership of the moon, and not a single challange has been made. What he's doing is legal, but it certainly won't be officially recognised by any government.

Side: Legal
1 point

all i can say from that story is... I Love Capitalism.

Side: Legal
1 point

It may be nearby but how about biyng the sun. It does not really men anything pus ony the ricj would be dumb enough. if there is life out there they may find it funny or go to war if we said Mine!

Side: not ours
0 points

No government will recognize this, he is just duping a bunch of people.

Side: Dupe

Better not. The aliens living in their towers and domes up there will not be happy when people start showing up with moving rockets and trailers.

Side: Illegal