CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
1
Yes free North Ireland No the British should have it
Debate Score:4
Arguments:3
Total Votes:4
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes free North Ireland (2)
 
 No the British should have it (1)

Debate Creator

SlashinatorX(415) pic



Should North Ireland be given back to Ireland?

Right now North Ireland is owned by Britain.

I think it should be given back to Ireland.

Should the British give Ireland it's north back? or should Britain keep it?

Yes free North Ireland

Side Score: 3
VS.

No the British should have it

Side Score: 1
2 points

If we allowed germany to unify, why not Ireland. I am sure that the protestant and catholic can resolve their issues as long as you don't let the english get involved.

Side: Yes free North Ireland

I think it would be best to give Northern Ireland back to Ireland but the British Crown isn't going to let that happen.

Side: Yes free North Ireland
1 point

It's not a simple case of who should 'have' Northern Ireland. And the situation bears no resemblance to the division of Germany.

Britain doesn't particarly want it - it costs the country a lot of money. The majority of people in NI want to be part of Britain. However, this majority was artificially and intentionally created by the border. The majority of people on the island of Ireland do want a united Ireland, so it's hard to judge what the democratic solution is.

There is little chance that the country could be united without a civil war - and an imaginary line on the ground isn't worth dying over, particularly when Northern Irish citizens are already secure in an Irish identity, or a British one, under the present circumstances.

Side: It's not that simple