CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
6
Definitely No, we can't hurt people
Debate Score:13
Arguments:15
Total Votes:13
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Definitely (7)
 
 No, we can't hurt people (6)

Debate Creator

Quocalimar(6470) pic



Should it be legal to hit people for being idiots?

It doesn't have to be a Falcon PAAAAAAAWNCH!!!! It could just be so much as a tap on the noggin when someone says or does somethign just down right idiotic. I don't know how it'd work exactly, but I'm sure our governments could draw some line on what is idiotic, and if anyone drops below that line for a second it'd be your right, no, your civil duty to give them a pop to let them know they're being an idiot. What do you think, legal or not?

A woman getting slapped

Definitely

Side Score: 7
VS.

No, we can't hurt people

Side Score: 6

Sometimes people need a pop! Plus, it'll act a great reminder not to be an idiot, and in the long run it will teach them, with a little physical reinforcement.

Side: Definitely
1 point

I like this plan because you would get popped a lot ;) And since you are volunteering, you won't complain.

Side: Definitely
1 point

I don't think so that I would have time to do anything else :D

Side: Definitely
1 point

Sometimes they really deserve it :P Although I think I would get quite a few slaps with the idiotic things that I come out with sometimes :P

Side: Definitely

To a certain extent, I don't think slapping someone should be grounds for assault charges and prison time.

Side: Definitely
1 point

Yes because people don't have a sense of accountability for what they do/say. If there were consequences they'd think their actions before they go the 'full retard' path.

Side: Definitely
1 point

To teach them that mouth isn't create to say anything you want so think before speak

Side: Definitely
1 point

Well, you must agree that the adjective "idiotic" may have various interpretations. The law you are suggesting is, to me, something as stupid as the woman in the video right below your topic.

Side: No, we can't hurt people

This would probably reduce trolling. ;)

Side: No, we can't hurt people

Basically, this is just a stupid notion, I see huge bureaucrat mess defining what is legally justify to hit someone. Thousands and thousands of pages defining this would be a nightmare.

Side: No, we can't hurt people
1 point

NO it shouldn't! That is abusing him! I'm just going to say, ABSOLUTELY NO!

Side: No, we can't hurt people
1 point

No! However, in this case, he is looking a liitle bit threatining, so it would be justifyable to hit him.

Side: No, we can't hurt people
Quocalimar(6470) Clarified
1 point

lol, you mean the fat person? That's a female.

Side: Definitely
izazovnog(322) Clarified
2 points

Yes, the fat person. Although, I have to admit, she does look like a male.

Side: Definitely

It would be cruel to hit anyone regardless if that person is an idiot.

Side: No, we can't hurt people