CreateDebate


Debate Info

14
9
Yay Nay
Debate Score:23
Arguments:12
Total Votes:24
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yay (7)
 
 Nay (5)

Debate Creator

DaWolfman(3324) pic



Should parents be allowed to educate their children at home?

Yay

Side Score: 14
VS.

Nay

Side Score: 9
3 points

Parents are responsible for ensuring that their children’s education is carried out well - there is no logic that necessarily requires them to surrender that responsibility to the state. If they feel that the child would be best educated at home, by them or by another, that is their right. It is of course a crucial check within such a system that those teaching are vetted by the state to some extent to ensure their suitability. Such a system has worked for some of our most able achievers and will continue to do so. Some exceptions might slip through such a system, but that doesn’t mean the system is wrong - and it’s hardly as if state education has never failed. Moreover, this is a debate about whose claim to the right to guide a child is greater, the state’s or parents’. We stand firmly on behalf of the parents. Freedom of choice should exist in this arena, given all the responsibilities a parent assumes in bringing up a child: refusing parents the right to educate their children at home is an affront to a family’s liberty.

As long as the student is passing the standardized tests that their respective states require, then their parents are obviously capable as teachers and it should not pose any problems.

Side: Yay
2 points

If the kid is passing, then it really shouldn't even be disputable.

Side: Yay
2 points

Yeah. There are a lot of really crappy schools out there that I've been to. They don't stick to the state curriculum, with all the noise from th other kids, school's not a good environment for learning, and on report cards, teachers give a lot of misleading information to mak it seem like a student is at the required standard when he is in fact above of below it.

Besides, parents are smart people. Most adults when to school them selves, and it is pretty easy for parents to go on the internet, find the curriculum and teach it to their kids, even if they're teaching themselves as they go.

What I think is the best option is to homeschool them for the elementry years and send them to school around middle school age. That way, if the parents didn't teach that well, there's still a chance for them to catch up and make friends before high school.

Side: Yay
1 point

"Parents should be able to choose where their children get the greatest education. Our government does not know each individual student and what is best for everyone is not always in the same nutshell. Education is extremely important and homeschooling is the best. Parents who pick homeschooling have picked the finest possible option for their kids to succeed. It is a great choice because students get an individualized education with safety and convenience.

Parents who choose to homeschool are giving their children a more individualized one-on-one education. Disruptions are greatly diminished with one student compared to thirty students to one teacher ratio. In school, there is wasted time for troublemakers, lunch, and changing classes Students can also get ahead and excel unlike in brick and mortar school where the class is at the same speed for all students. Homeschool provides a greater way to learn with fewer distractions too.

Above all, parents should choose homeschooling because it helps with the safety issues of constant bullying, violence, and drug trafficking that is happening in public schools today .Furthermore, I think there is an issue with safety because most public schools do not have a metal detector. Presently, there is no accountability of the things students bring to school. They could bring guns, knives and anything they want into the school as long as it’s concealed. All it takes is one person to bring a gun and pull their finger back to end a child’s life.

Commuting to and from school, school clothing fashion, and ridged schedules are very annoying and tiresome parts of everyday school. “BEEEEEEP, BEEEEEEP, BEEEEEEP,” goes the loud alarm clock that wakes kids up every morning and leaves them feeling groggy and tired to start their day at school. Parents should be able to choose not put their children through these everyday torturous rituals. .Also, kids have more flexible time in the day to participate in activities such as sports, acting, singing, hiking, and traveling. Ultimately, participating in many extracurricular activities with school can help a child become a well-rounded person.

Arguably, many children do go to public school because their parents think it is the right choice and attended public school when they were growing up. Most kids survive going to public school, but should they survive or succeed? Understandably, some parents work during school hours and do not have a choice. If a parent can choose, then school at home is a more individualized, safer and more convenient choice."

Lol this was my essay topic. Teacher if you see this I'm not plagiarizing I'm just posting my essay here :P

Side: Yay
3 points

No.

1. Even if one's parents are each say a mathematician, and the other an English Rhode Scholar, with only two teachers there will be gaps in a child's education by the time they graduate High School regardless how many text books the parents invest in.

2. Social interaction is one of the primary benefits of school. Home schooled individuals cannot help but be socially awkward later in life. I've never met one who was otherwise.

3. Psychologically I believe it damages a child, making them less willing and less prepared to at some point live without their parents.

All three reasons may not apply to every home schooled person, but I am willing to bet at least one does to every home schooled person. It is a bad idea and should not be allowed.

Side: nay
brycer2012(1002) Disputed
2 points

Home schooled children score higher on standardized tests than children in a traditional school.

Side: Yay
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
2 points

I was only able to find articles and statistics from people who home school their children. Do you have an independent source?

Also, imo even that would not sway me to believe it is a better way to educate a child.

Obviously if a parent home schools, they take an interest in their child's education. While their scores would naturally be higher compared to the general public, I would guess that if the test scores were somehow compared to kids in public school, whose parents took an interest in their education, the kids in public school would do better.

It would seem this would be a matter of poor parenting bringing down the test scores of public schools, making for an unfair comparison.

Side: nay
arataii(95) Disputed
2 points

I happen to be homeschooled and none of those three things apply to me as far as I know.

1. my parents do not teach me, I teach myself and I have gotten along just fine since I happen to be in the national honors society for scoring over the 90 percentile.

2. over half my friends are public schooled and they all think I'm public schooled by the way I socially interact.

3. my parents have made me take responsibility of myself by making me pay for everything like, clothes, a car, car insurance and college. I have about 4 different jobs so I can pay for my expenses. I feel FULLY prepared to leave my parents and be on my own and I plan to move out as soon as I'm 18.

Also, there are many different ways to homeschool, the homeschool program I'm enrolled in has 850 students and has a building and part-time teachers that teach various classes like, Chemistry, Biology, Spanish, Art and Writing. They also offer Mocktrial and Drama, nothing is mandatory though. Homeschool students I know dual-enroll with the public highschool and also take classes or sports there. Students in my homeschool program also have the option of taking college courses. Not all homeschoolers are stuck at home all day twiddling their thumbs. There are many different options with homeschooling.

Side: Yay
shelbyjmee(1) Disputed
2 points

But people who "educate themsleves" have gaps in their education surely..

Side: nay

Children can't get the total education experience with being home schooled.

Side: Nay