Should students be able to listen to music in class?
Music help them focusing on their works and ignoring all the noise around them like people talking, laughing, object stuff noise. They hear nothing but music. i love music and it help me focus alot
Yes
Side Score: 635
|
No
Side Score: 446
|
|
|
|
Many people may argue yes, because they find their classes to be dull, and want an alternative to the droning noise of their teachers voice. I don't take such a cynical stance of class, but actually believe that listening to music can help certain individuals to concentrate and work more efficiently - for example, when revising, I find low volume music can help me to work faster and, actually, better. Whenever a teacher allows music in class, I work much better than without it - people are going to concentrate more on their work than speaking to classmates, and get more work done. Of course, I cannot argue that students be allowed to just come into a lesson and start listening to music immediately - first, the teacher must be allowed to do their job (teach the lessons content), and set tasks - but proceeding this, I see no possible harm that can be caused. As soon as a task has been set, students, in my opinion, should be allowed to listen to music (at a suitable noise level, of course). Side: Yes
5
points
Your right, in some cases music can be calming and relaxing, it can relieve stress and sometimes even calm the nerves. But in a class, full of working students, music is not acceptable. (Unless of course it is learning a song for school purposes- National Anthem etc). Side: No
I don't think music is distracting. And if it is, then it is the students choice to keep listening to the music instead of just taking their earbuds out. If the student knows that the music distracts him/her then they shouldn't listen to it while working but they still might. This is purely their choice. Students just as easily could be distracted by something else. And if a student doesn't want to pay attention in class or learn that is also their choice. Nobody can force them (they can try but I'm betting they would fail). Side: Yes
35
points
Of course they should. For some students, music helps them think as they do their work, it can also make them get the work done quicker as they have less distractions (ie: talking to friends). However I'll just point out that the only time I would deem this unacceptable is when the teacher is talking to the class and teaching something. The obvious thing is to stop listening to the music and listen to what the teacher is teaching you. For other things, I feel it is completely okay to listen to music in class, as long as the work is getting done. Side: Yes
5
points
5
points
32
points
29
points
29
points
It should be fine for study sessions or independent work as long as the student has good earbuds that nobody else can hear and be distracted by. Not for tests though. How long would it be before somebody puts the answers on their player and skip studying for the test? Side: Yes
A few points I should mention: Kids should NOT be allowed phones because that would cause more problems with txting and cheating. However, music is different. Music can relax those with nerves during an exam or just provide entertainment while you sludge though all that math. Some wouldn't WANT to listen to music because it may be a distraction to some but I don't think we should not allow something because a few are against it. Side: No
5
points
Listening to music for a while during classes can be helpful for students, for it's power of adjusting mood and refreshing mind and for it is a couse of relaxation after a tough exam or a defficult subject that should help students to be positively active and concentrated :). Side: Yes
some students prefer listening to music as they study, but while learning, i disagree that a student can listen to music and concentrate on chemical problems. it has to be either one of them. i agree that music could be allowed in a few classes, maybe during gym, or art, but during classes that require full attention, i think music would only be a distraction. Side: No
1
point
21
points
17
points
1
point
It has been scientifically proven that students perform better with music on. Of course, let the teacher set the tasks and teach, etc. but once the students get to work, I think they should definitely be allowed to listen to music. It helps people concentrate more, and teachers are always asking for a silent classroom, and if students are listening to music, you would be able to hear a pin drop! Side: Yes
I think that listening to music in the classroom through lessons would help students relax so that they can be more productive .I don't think that listening to music in the classroom will confuse or bother students because there are many types of music and the intended type here is the quiet one, which doesn't make the student annoyed or disturbed. Side: Yes
1
point
2
points
1
point
4
points
2
points
2
points
That is true, many people would agree that music can certainly generate productivity and a good state of mind - but, you can't ignore the fact that this would only work if every person in the class with content with the choice of music! I think the main problem is making everyone satisfied and as teachers, the reaction of the people decides whether it is appropriate to them. Personally, I would like to have music on in the classroom because it can create a less tense/ hushed atmosphere. Side: Yes
1
point
4
points
This is up to your prospective. If I was the student I would be ecstatic at this idea. However, on the teachers side, it would be pestered by this vexing activity in the classroom. On the students side I can find arguments supporting this detail, 2 against it. I will first and foremost start with the points supporting music in the classroom from the students prospective. Firstly, music helps you concentrate. Each individual taste for music means that they won't get annoyed by what song is playing and diverge from school work or listening to the teacher just to change the song. Secondly, it would exit you for school. Most students will get up in the morning with a sense of, 'Dang it, school...", or somewhere along those lines. However, with music it could be more like,"Yeah, I know what I'm going to listen to in science!" That point brings me to the downfall of having music in a classroom from a students prospective. Firstly, to a student working hard in school to achieve something great, such as strait A's, these would be annoying having them working on there working listening to their teacher while everyone else in zoning-out. Lastly, (the last point on the students behalf) it may be hard to hear the teacher. Now I realize this is a weak point, and I realize it could be easily fixed by having a volume that you have to be at. However, it is a fair point in this argument considering this whole debate could be over by just asking your theater for permission for you, and/or your classmates. Now I will talk on behalf of the teachers. I have, for the teacher, come up with 2 upsides and 2 downsides. Firstly, on the upside, students will be more engaged on you depending on the student. For brilliant students who like to talk to their friends, it would pull their attention away from their friends, and, hopefully, back on you, helping them succeed. Secondly, they may learn something about music, like how it is structured, and what instruments are used in what songs (the more knowledge the better ;).) Now to the downsides, if I were a teacher, of music in class. First of all, most students don't listen to classical or music that is scientifically proven to help students learn, they mostly listen to modern music which can easily diverge them to dancing or singing catchy melodies as modern songs often do. Finally, there could be stolen mp3's or iPod's causing fights and overall, total chaos. In conclusion, I believe that music should be listened to in classrooms with caution, however only do it with your teacher, and fellow classmates, approval. (Thank You For Reading This Lengthy Argument!) Side: Yes
3
points
Music has a positive effect on the brain. By allowing students to listen to music in class, they are likely to be less bored and more productive. Obviously, don't let them listen to music WHILE the teacher is speaking; only while the teacher is not talking. It CAN be a distraction if abused, but with proper moderation it can turn out to be a great success. Side: Yes
2
points
I think so, but only during work time. I'm in high school and my teachers all let us listen to music when they aren't talking. By listening to music, that makes kids not talk to each other, resulting in a better learning environment. It will make kids more focused, too. With having something that you like and that is familiar to you, it makes that class seem a little bit easier and takes some stress off of your back. Side: Yes
1
point
1
point
1
point
1
point
1
point
|
Recent studies proved that people produce effectively and happily when they listen to music. I myself like this idea. However, the case of getting students to listen to music IN THE CLASSROOM is completely irrelevant. Students should be busy all the time listening to the teacher, listening to each other or even speaking to each other. Therefore, it is illogical to allow students listen to music DURING CLASSES. Side: No
2
points
Students would only be able to listen to music during work time. I don't understand why everyone thinks that it would be the entire class, even when the teacher is talking. At my school, we are only allowed to have one earbud in so then if the teacher has an announcement we can hear it. It works, too. Side: Yes
2
points
Listening to music in class has really helped me focus more and actually understand what I'm learning about. Due to the fact that classrooms tend to get extremely noisy and busy, listening to music (with earphones/headphones) can create a peaceful atmosphere, something that all students need. In addition, the reason students talk to other students in class is because they are bored, but with music, that boredom is reduced, so students pay more attention to their work. And with most people listening to music, there is also a peaceful atmosphere for the teacher. Also, teachers are more like a guide in my class, not an instructor. So we are more independent and are able to use are creativity and study in ways that are effective for us, because everyone is different. This way of teaching is extremely useful. Side: Yes
Studies don't prove anything. They provide evidence that supports or doesn't support a hypothesis. I've done a lot of research in this area, and how people respond to music depends on a lot of things such as a degree of extroversion, familiarity of the music, volume of the music, the type of task being performed while listening to music, emotional state, whether or not the music has lyrics, how fast the music things, and that is just the tip of the iceberg. And I'm not sure why you say it is illogical for students to listen to music in class. Sometimes students have to work on something independently. Take for example a free writing assignment. Sometimes, students will instructed to respond to a prompt and write for 25-30 minutes. During this time they will not be talking to one another, nor will the teacher be talking. So it's not illogical in the least. Side: Yes
I think that if listening to music helps someone while they're taking a test or studying than they should do it. But if someone gets distracted by it than they shouldn't. If music was allowed during school some students could do a lot better. And it wouldn't distract others if they have head phones on. Just like gum, it is not allowed in some schools but people haves said that it can help someone do better on an exam. It could be allowed only during tests and it would help. Side: No
29
points
it is possible for some specific students to listen to music while doing a free assignment. but while in school when the teacher is teaching, i think it would help to concentrate only on the teachers voice instead of eminem, or avril or whoever you listen to. also that is one reason why the teachers constantly try and ask you to stop blabbering with your friends. because you need to listen to what they have to say. Side: No
1
point
27
points
1
point
1
point
You wouldn't listen to music when the teacher was talking. I don't understand why you would even think that is what this is about. You would listen to it during work time. And if the teacher does have to say something, then if you are wearing just one earbud then you can hear it just fine. That's the rule at my school- one earbud only- and we can always hear if the teacher has to say scomething Side: Yes
1
point
1
point
17
points
1
point
Music makes kids focus. When listening to music you tend to flow with the drum beat, so when its a fast beat, you go faster. If you are listening to a fast song that means that you can get more work done. For example, I was listening to a fast song when I wrote this and it took about 10 seconds. Side: Yes
17
points
, I think kids should be allowed to listen to music in class because it helps kids concentrate. It also could solve the problem of kids talking in class. While listening to music they wouldn't be able to hear their friends talking as well and it would block out background noise Side: Yes
According to the American Music Conference (AMC), music won"t rot your mind -- in fact, it"s actually good for your thinking-cap. The AMC has cited research that has shown that studying and creating music may help improve your capacity to learn other subjects and get better grades overall.<< (This is copied and pasted from yahoo! sorry...) Side: Yes
14
points
13
points
12
points
7
points
2
points
6
points
About you're point on bad influences new music causes. 1. Not all kids listen to new music these days and not all music has a bad storyline or meaning. Lots of music is poetic and beautiful, even some rap songs (which I consider to mostly be a guy screaming swear words in no tone over loud horrible music). Side: Yes
2
points
2
points
Yes, for me personally the right music can make such a positive difference in my studies. Although I have seen a lot of kids taking advantage of the possibility that has been given to them. Kids will copy some notes down from their notes. Of course during a lesson, it really doesn't make a difference but alto of people also say that during a TEST, some music would help them to concentrate. It would be possible for the teacher to control the students so that they can't touch their electronic device at all. But they could also record the test answers and then listen to that. And also if students could listen to music during a test, the teachers would have so many new things to observe, it would be a bad utilization of teachers resources. All that together, it just wouldn't be reasonable. And i am sure that music makes a big difference for only a few students in class Side: No
2
points
I didn't say during a test; I certainly wouldn't agree with that, and your also forgetting that there are moderators and invigilators involved. About the playing of music on in normal lessons could potentially be a device ultimately controlled by the teacher. However, I appreciate that this way may not work for everyone; there has to be an element of trust. If I were the teacher, I would allow people to listen to their own music but after giving the pupil's their freedom of choice, I would assess whether it made them lose focus or gain focus and make a reasonable judgement. Therefore, anyone who violates/ takes advantage of this privilege will be reminded of the many people in the world who don't get a chance for a proper education or risk their lives every day to travel to school in very remote areas. This is a reality. Abusers will automatically lose that privilege if they abuse it's fair, right? That is their choice. As for listening to the teacher - the lesson isn't constituted by merely the teacher talking all the time, so during work time you can be flexible and allow the pupils to listen to their music if they want to. I think that could work. Side: No
1
point
Music is very enjoyable, but it just isn't practical to allow students to listen to music- wait, scratch that. Music is a fun treat, and can be used during recesses, or maybe for fun activities or parties in the classroom, or maybe even if the teacher just feel like putting it on. However, if students were always listening to music, inappropriate context is obviously a concern. It may not be a big deal for 12th graders, but what about 1st graders? If one child in a classroom is exposed to language or other, well, things…….other first graders could pick it up and soon all of the parents will be angry that their child knows such bad language and context! I'm not saying that music is a bad thing- in fact, its a great thing! Songs can be used to help certain students learn, but the fact that the title just said "music" can mean any type of music, so because of that I am against it. If teachers specifically say at certain times that it is okay, than its okay. But I would be careful about that decision if made…... Side: No
1
point
1
point
Okay, but I don't think a first grade teacher that barely let's you say, "I hate you," is gonna let some innocent 1st graders listen to music with curse words in it. Just a thought. Oh and I don't know if they mean singularly, as in everyone bring in their iPods and ear buds, and keep the volume on low and one ear bud in, or group as in she chooses the music, but the second option would be bad for some, but the first option is great for those who like music. Side: Yes
|