CreateDebate


Debate Info

35
17
Yes No
Debate Score:52
Arguments:49
Total Votes:56
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (32)
 
 No (17)

Debate Creator

Elvira(3446) pic



Should the Swastika be redeemed of its Nazi connotations?

The Swastika and some other symbols have been seen as taboo since their use in the nazi regime. The Swastika is used by Neo-Nazi/ white supremacy groups, as well as newer alterations of old symbols such as the 777 triskelion. A recent news story detailed a topshop hoodie design being withdrawn because of a rune on it being used for the SS.

Is it really necessary to continue to demonise these symbols? 

Yes

Side Score: 35
VS.

No

Side Score: 17
1 point

The swastika is a positive symbol in many eastern religions. The name swastika is even a positive thing, the name is actually three Sanskrit words su- meaning good, Asti- meaning to be, and Ka-meaning one's soul, so. All together it means well being of the soul. It stands for peace, good will, good luck, and originated in the Bronze Age as a symbol representing the sun thus symbolizing life itself.

Side: Yes

Yes. The swastika is a Hindu religious symbol that Hitler stole from the Hindus. just like black people are taking nigga back, Hindus should take the swastika back.

Side: Yes

It's also in the Buddhist and Jain religions.

Side: Yes

Awesome. Who had it first? .

Side: Yes
1 point

Well technically black people never owned "nigga" the word is a perversion (altered version) of "nigger" wich is a perversion (altered version) of "negro" the scientific name for the black genome. But other than that yes I agree with you.

Side: Yes

You do have a point. Euro's were calling a Niggers first. And know were trying to steal it by making it NIGGA. I'm black myself. For some reason NIGGER is racist but NIGGA is not.

Side: Yes

Thanks K. I agree. I have a debate re N Word. You want? .

Side: Yes

I believe it should be redeemed and reclaimed- not because of its positive connotations, but specifically because of its negative connotations- to dilute them into complete obscurity.

Adopt it as a logo for kosher foods, or ethnic hair products, even as a gay pride symbol. Let all groups who were oppressed by the nazis use it in their own way. Render that symbol meaningless to any skinhead that would strap it to his arm.

Side: Yes
1 point

Oh man, if we turned the swastika into a gay symbol it would be like the neo Nazis all wearing little rainbows. Hahahaha.

Side: Yes
1 point

Well given the actions and attitudes of some gay rights activists lately it could almost fit the role with its current connotations.

Side: Yes
1 point

In European countries swastika is banned as a symbol of hate group, racism etc...

Side: Yes

Hitler just used it because it's southern Asian. Hitler though he was Aryan, (Southern Asians). The Swastika is a symbol of Jainism. Hitler made it look bad. If Stalin was to use the cross for his crimes, would people forgive that sign, YES. So why not do it with Buddhism. Plus Buddhism cause more peace than it does hate. Hitler it made them look really bad.

Side: Yes
1 point

no.

Side: No

I don't really think it matters...

Side: No