CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
3
yes, it is a good review no, more family time is better
Debate Score:6
Arguments:4
Total Votes:6
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 yes, it is a good review (2)
 
 no, more family time is better (2)

Debate Creator

eblackmon(5) pic



Should there be homework assigned in elementary school?

This issue has been in the news lately starting with a teacher's posting on Facebook.  She posted that she would not be giving homework to her third graders this year.  Instead she hopes that they will get exercise, prepare andeat dinner with their family and read for pleasure each night.

yes, it is a good review

Side Score: 3
VS.

no, more family time is better

Side Score: 3
2 points

They should be writing 10 page term papers, typed double spaced, with full references. That should make us finally competitive internationally with the genius foreign kids!

Side: yes, it is a good review
1 point

It's best to get into the habit of these things early on. I rarely ever completed homework until University because I saw it as pointless and I received quite the shock when I had to actually start doing it.

Side: yes, it is a good review
2 points

I honestly think at that young an age, having family time and building up that familial relationship is highly important. Kids SHOULD be going outside to play, that's the best way to learn, it's a hands on approach to the world around them and a starting point for rules. Parents can do a lot to make play time entertaining and educating.

Side: no, more family time is better
1 point

The problem with homework is that it adds a lot of stress to a child during their formative years, which can be not only detrimental, but can have real health implications. Furthermore, compulsory homework can strain relations between teachers and students, harming any kind of possible mentorship that children may have with their teachers. This can leave to disenfranchisement and when kids get behind, they are far more likely to be afraid of approaching their teachers. Furthermore, increasing teacher's workloads can reduce their available time to consult the children about ensuring they understand the coursework.

As an example, Finland has no homework. It has a 93% graduation rate for high school student, compared to Canada's 78% and America's 75%. Finland also has the highest college attendance rates in Europe, with two thirds of students attending college. Finland also dominates in test scores, being first in the world.

It would be unfair, however, to not mention that Finland also has various other policies in place, such as keeping test amounts to a minimum, lower density classrooms, and also the requirement for teachers to have a master's degree. However, it should be reminded that some of these things are more affordable due to the fact that teachers are not spending two or three extra hours a day marking homework.

In conclusion, homework can negatively affect not only students, but teachers, reducing education rates and making school time less efficient.

Side: no, more family time is better