Debate Info

install flash for graphs
Yes, we need to police them More bureaucracy? Not a help.
Debate Score:15
Arguments:6
Total Votes:15
Show More Stats

Debate Creator

Selric(61) pic



Should we create a watchdog agency to police UN peacekeepers and global aid workers?

Qui custodiat?

NewsMax article on STC report (www.newsmax.com)

Yes, we need to police them

Side Score: 3
VS.

More bureaucracy? Not a help.

Side Score: 12
Vote Up Vote Down
3 points

The STC report outlines something that has been known and "addressed" as far back as December 2002. A coalition of global aid agencies met in New York in 2002 to draw up guidelines and prevention programs for just this sort of abuse; a larger group reaffirmed their commitment to the guidelines and prevention programs as recently as late 2006. Demonstrably, it has not helped.

Sex crimes are notoriously underreported, and when one throws in the fact that the abusers ARE the enforcers and the protectors, it follows that the victims not only won't report the problem, they have no one to report it to. The creation of a global watchdog agency to police the aid and peacekeeping forces gives a point of contact for the victims, and helps ensure that consequences are swift in coming to the perpetrators of such outrages.

542 days ago
Vote Up Vote Down
3 points

The addition of yet another agency in the global mix siphons off funds that are needed elsewhere and provides no real benefit. While the provision of an ombudsman for the victims is necessary, it would better to have existing law enforcement coordinate the watchdog efforts rather than trying to set up an oversight group. Placing another level of bureaucracy into the mix is of limited help to the victims and may in fact embolden the abusers, since they will not be under the jurisdiction of the locale where they are stationed.

Additionally, one wonders precisely where the staff for this new agency will come from. Global resources for effective policing are already stretched thin and many countries are forced to use their militaries to supplement their civilian policing structures. Thus, the very groups which currently supply the people that are accused of these atrocities will be the groups tapped to provide the oversight. This seems to me to be a case of setting the fox to watch the henhouse, with the caveat here that the hens in question stand an excellent chance of being abused...

542 days ago
- Loudacris(899) Supported
Vote Up Vote Down
4 points

Large bureaucracies are notoriously bad at policing themselves. An ideal solution would be to make UN funds available to NGOs to coordinate the watchdog effort. Today, with the power of information, if allegations come to light then that will cause an outcry, which would require the UN peacekeepers to clean up their act.

542 days ago
- Tamisan(866) Supported
Vote Up Vote Down
3 points

Who polices the police? The problem is in the selection and accountability. More management never solved anything.

542 days ago
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

I think the reason things are going as they are now is because there's already too much government between the people and the UN already.

542 days ago
Vote Up Vote Down
1 point  

more bureaucracy means less accountability, less communications, less effectiveness and more expense and confusion. NO THANK YOU! Just reorganize the existing organization - reduce the levels of chain-of-command, audit everything, to name few....

542 days ago
Popular Debates in World: Do you think it was a good idea to make the "mini Gitmo" in Illinois? Why is this still going on in America? Obama Wins Nobel Peace Prize... Do you think he deserved to win?


bottomAd


About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons



©2009 CreateDebate, LLC All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.