Debate Stats:

Debate Score:18
Arguments:7
Total Votes:29
Ends:Never
Graph Updates Live
install flash for graphs
Yes No

Debate Creator:

kirstie1126(187) pic

Are you trying to figure out how this debate works? Show Quick Tips

Should women be allowed to be Catholic priests?
Is the Catholic Church behind the times?


Yes
Side Score:
11
VS.
No
Side Score:
7
Add New Argument
Add New Argument
– MyPic DebateMan(378) Vote Up Vote Down
4
points 

Women should be allowed to be priests. Jesus never specifically said that women should not be priests, although he did choose only men as his 12 apostles. The Catholic Church is struggling to recruit new priests, and many of the existing priests are getting much older and losing touch with their parishioners.

Allowing women to be priests could inject some new energy in to the Catholic Church and help it to promote it's goal of growth and conversion of new members.

Posted 78 days ago
– MyPic Bluefish7(43) Vote Up Vote Down
2
points 

Women can be just as effective pastors as men.

Posted 80 days ago
– MyPic Tamisan(410) Vote Up Vote Down
2
points 

Seven reasons why women can and should receive Holy Orders:

1. One priesthood in Christ

Through baptism women and men share equally in the new priesthood of Christ. This includes openness to Holy Orders.

2. Empowered to preside

At the Last Supper Jesus empowered both women and men. Both can be ordained to preside at the Eucharist.

3. Cultural bias

The Church’s practice of not ordaining women as priests was based on a three-fold prejudice against women. This affected the judgment of Church leaders.

4. Women have been deacons

Until at least the ninth century the Church gave women the full sacramental ordination of deacons. This proves women can be ordained.

5. The ability for women to be ordained has been present in the Church’s latent Tradition.

One example is the age-long devotion to Mary as priest. It shows that, according to the ‘sense of the faithful’, in Mary the ban against women has already been overcome.

6. The wider Church accepts women priests

After serious study and prayer other Christian Churches now ordain women as priests. Though not everything other churches do can be accepted by the Catholic Church, this converging consensus by believing Christians confirms that ordaining women is according to the mind of Christ.

7. Women too are, in fact, called to be priests

The fact that many responsible Catholic women discern in themselves a vocation to the priesthood is a sign of the Holy Spirit you cannot ignore.

Conclusion:

There are no valid arguments against women priests, and many truly Catholic arguments in favour.

Posted 78 days ago
Supporting Evidence: Women priests movement (www.womenpriests.org)
– MyPic joecavalry(1330) Vote Up Vote Down
1
point  

Yes, that way when they molest the choir boys it would be a little more normal. Ok, take that with a grain of salt.

Posted 76 days ago
– MyPic heelspider(82) Vote Up Vote Down
0
points 

No. And we could solve a lot of problems by keeping men from being Catholic priests too. I say, only dogs, eunuchs, and hermaphrodites should be allowed to be priest.

Posted 80 days ago
– MyPic geoff(619) Vote Up Vote Down
-1
points 

Not unless they give up their foreskins.

Posted 78 days ago


About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Newsletter Archive
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Sharing Tools
Send Beta Invites
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Legal Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Creative Commons

©2008 CreateDebate, LLC All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.