CreateDebate


Debate Info

39
59
Miley Lovers Miley Haters
Debate Score:98
Arguments:34
Total Votes:124
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Miley Lovers (13)
 
 Miley Haters (21)

Debate Creator

MaddyEL pic



That Miley Cyrus should be taken off TV?

Some people think Miley Cyrus is a "bad rolemodel" for kids.  I would like to hear your reaction to this topic.  

Miley Lovers

Side Score: 39
VS.

Miley Haters

Side Score: 59

I'm neither a Miley lover or hater but I don't think she should be taken off of TV. She has her audience and as long as she does, what's the harm? Her sponsers have the say so on whether she stays or goes so let her be.

Side: ambivilent
5 points

Miley Cyrus should NOT be taken off T.V because everyone loves her. If she is taken off T.V, lots of people will be sad. That is why Miley should NOT be taken off T.V

Side: Miley Lovers
MKIced(2483) Disputed
7 points

"If she is taken off T.V, lots of people will be sad."

By "lots of people" do you mean actual people or little girls? Because her only fan base is little girls.

Side: Miley Haters
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
6 points

Miley Cyrus should NOT be taken off T.V because everyone loves her.

Do you have a source? I don't know everyone, but I've never heard of all of them liking anyone.

If she is taken off T.V, lots of people will be sad.

A group of people's emotional state has no bearing on what should or should not be on TV, ex. The Taliban looooove watching Americans get there heads chopped off. If there weren't Americans getting their heads chopped off on tv, "lots of people will be sad." You understand now why that doesn't work?

Here's how you argue something like this.

"A company that owns a TV station has the right to put whatever they like within the law on their station. As no laws are being broken by showing Miley Cyrus on TV, they are allowed to put Miley Cyrus on TV. If an individual feels she is a "bad influence" they likewise have every right to not watch Miley Cyrus on TV."

Side: Miley Haters
xander(438) Disputed
5 points

Obviously not- I think Miley Cyrus has very little talent, and I am saddened by people who do like her.

Side: Miley Haters
artandvanity Disputed
4 points

You can't just generalize a whole population. I know plenty of people who do not care for her. Does that mean everyone doesn't like her?

Side: Miley Haters
4 points

Forgot to write my description, I love miley cyrus and she should definetly not be taken off TV. Miley is beautiful in everyway. Even though she has had some issues out of the TV studio that have got parents worrying. But I think everyone should leave the poor kid alone. All these rumours about friendship, love-life and pregnancy are rubbish. I think everyone who says this is just jelous because they dont have real friends r thheir not overlly satisfied with themselves. Or you might not be able to sing. Who cares? Think about it. If you went to miley and asked her for her aughtograph, do you think she'd say no? definetly not. Just go on youtube and watch her signing aughtographs for needy people and people from different races. Miley is accepting and king. Therefore we should definelty not let people pull Miley offscreen!

Side: Miley Lovers
artandvanity Disputed
4 points

So because she signs autographs for a variety of races means she shouldn't be taken off television? It isn't a matter of race. I don't think she shouldn't be on TV, but it can be very antagonizing for many people who don't wish to see her everyday in the paper, on the news or mentioned in their favourite shows if they don't care for her. Another issue is that her fan base has been taken to the highest level of exposure where propaganda is almost telling you that its cool to like Hannah Montana or Miley Cyrus. For many other deserving artists, they constantly have to battle her large fandom sheep in order to receive recognition. I've heard so many complaints that she can't sing and maybe its true. Ultimately, my opinion is that she really shouldn't be so famous for what she does, its hardly any different from other actresses and musicians.

Side: Miley Haters
4 points

Miley is a very popular pop star with a bright future and her lovers know that but her haters are jealous of her and they should keep their mouth shut!

Side: Miley Lovers
ShiroSama97(77) Disputed
2 points

dofodofo(4) why dont you shut it? this is a debate. people can say their opinions. and if all little girls under the age of 5 didnt watch her, she would be no where. there are some good singers way more beautiful and talented than her. SHE IS ANNOYING. lol a bright future... i know where she is going- hell! and dont say she is a Christian cuz shez not. she thinks she is but she is not.

Side: Miley Haters

If people demand that she remain on TV otherwise she would be off already. And leave her alone, and she will destroy herself.

Side: Miley Lovers
2 points

i think miley cyrus is a good role model for kids. she has great music and a hit TV show. most kids and teenagers look up 2 her. she has a lot of people watching her every move but she handles it very well. people always make a big deal when she makes a little mistake, when are people going 2 realize that everyone makes mistakes. most people that are judging her have done things that are 10 times worse.

Side: Miley Lovers
2 points

i also think all the rumors are stupid they take every little small thing she does and turn it into something bad. they made a big deal out of her dating Justin because he was 20. BIG DEAL! I'm a Little younger than her and my bf of over a year is about to turn 20. there is nothing wrong with it. they also made a big deal out of her dancing on the poll unless she was naked or stripping off her clothes then shut up about it. oh and they whole tattoo thing so what if she got a tattoo. she got it for a reason it means something special to her i know people her age who have tattoos, does that make them a bad person. well of course not.

Side: Miley Lovers
2 points

I dont get how u cant LOVE miley she rules the world she is the best singer and actress and dancer

Side: Miley Lovers
ShiroSama97(77) Disputed
1 point

john1123 first of all she does not rule. she rules the minds of kids that prob crap themselves while they are watching her show. and any1 who is smart and doesnt fall for cheap cheesy entertainement would see she stinks. and she does NOT rule the world. God does. and by shaking her fat rolls, lip singing and doing crappy acting... if that means shes the best than yes. she is. she needs to just go away and dont come back. 4ever.

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

exactly. I'm 12 years old and im constantly around kids hat seem to think that disney and nickelodeon stars care about them and think that the produce genuine entertainment. why cant they see that it all coporate bull shit and they are all in it for the money. all the comedy in the shows are cliche's

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

hapninnnnnnn troooppsss b-) weee loveeeeee mileyyyy xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Side: Miley Lovers

I do not particularly love Miley Cyrus, but what reason is there to take her off the air? She's doing no harm

Side: Miley Lovers
1 point

wouldn't say I LOVED her. I'm just saying that she would never be forced off tv. She is a hit on her hit show Hannah Monatannah. Even if it is typical and uninteresting to me.

Side: Miley Lovers

Nah, she's acting completely normal. I don't know why it's such a shock to people that she smokes/drinks/takes nudes. This is normal. Wake up people, this is the 21st century!

Side: Miley Lovers

Miley is still growing up. She is acting as a sassy girl because teens like to be sassy. She's O.K. and she is not harming anyone.

Side: Miley Lovers

I don't think she's a bad role model. All of the hype about Vanity Fair or whatever is just that--hype. Get over it.

I think she should be taken off of television for two reasons:

1. She's annoying as hell.

2. She's not talented and this makes her even more annoying as hell.

Side: Miley Haters
2 points

she doesn't do any good

she speaks through her nose

my parents think she sets a bad example for her little fans who watch hannah montana

she is the worst actress I've ever seen

even her dad doesn't care if she dresses badly

so iI guess she should be taken off t.v.

Side: Miley Haters
2 points

I don't hate her to death, but 3 reasons she should not be on TV.

#1 She sucks at singing.

#2 She has no talents what so ever.

#3 Shes just annoying as crap.

Side: Miley Haters
2 points

I am not a Miley hater but I do like some of her songs. And all my cuisines like her a lot... nd if she's taken off TV it would really break their hearts!!!

Side: Miley Haters
2 points

she is annoying ugly her songs sound like my dog taking a crap after i fed her a laxative and only little kids like her. have you seen her recent videos? shes POLE DANCING. do we want her rotting our young childrens minds? and if you want real awesome music look up the songs twisted transistor by korn, break stuff by limp bizkit, and ANYTHING by killswitch engage. sorry if you dont like screamo but i like it ;)

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

I don't think she should be taken off tv, but I had to comment over here, because I'm definitely a Miley Hater. I have been since before she really made it BIG.

What bothers me about Miley Cyrus is the way she speaks with her entire mouth at every moment. She has to use twice the energy moving her lips to make sentences as any normal person.

And, as pointed out, she's not very talented and her fame far exceeds her talent. So that's always annoying.

But as long as there's a market for her, I'll just keep changing the channel.

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

I work at a summer camp that loves her and she has got to be one of the most fake singers ever. On her cd's she sounds like she is in her twenties, yet when live she sounds like she is twelve. Not only that but her songs are quite awful.

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

I think she is a very pretty girl but if i was a mother i would NOT want my 8 year old watching a 17 year old girl dancing on a stripper pole and thinking thats okay for her to do!! I do not beleive she is a good role model at all simply because she tries to act, dance, and dress to mature for her age!!! To me she looks and acts like a little ho! There is a fine line between trying to grow up a little and growing up to much!!

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

Miley Cyrus is the A WHORE!

i wont be supprised by the time she's 20 she'll have made 100 porno's

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

the show was alright but then every episodes was the same. miley say something hurtful about her friend or family they here it she goes to talk to them and learns somewhat a lesson, or trying to pick between two boys she wants to screw god it got boring

Side: Miley Haters
1 point

I actually liked Miley Cyrus... When she was on Disney. I stopped checking out content related to her when she left and do you think I'd be loving her now? No. Do you think I should be hating her now? No. I've got other things to check out on TV... Well actually, I've got a lot of things to check out on the Internet.

Also, I did like some of Miley's Songs... Mostly those before the Wrecking Ball came and then many things about her got destroyed afterwards.

Side: Miley Haters
-2 points
-3 points