CreateDebate


Debate Info

16
23
Murder & bury them. Inhuman.
Debate Score:39
Arguments:29
Total Votes:46
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Murder & bury them. (13)
 
 Inhuman. (12)

Debate Creator

Antrim(1297) pic



The Catholic Church has new way of dealing with unmarried mothers and their offspring.

The graves of over 800 children,( a figure which is increasing)  with the age at death ranging from 35 foetal weeks to 2-3 years old. 
The Home for unmarried mothers and their babies in Tuam, County Galway, Ireland  was run by 'caring and compassionate Roman Catholic Nuns''. 
The babies and toddlers were known as the Devil's Children', and were not allowed to mix with with good Christian children.
What would the outcry be if this horror was carried out by Muslims? 

Murder & bury them.

Side Score: 16
VS.

Inhuman.

Side Score: 23
2 points

I read something recently about this nightmare and thought the gruesome details give strong support to 'abortion on demand' by the mother.

What those little innocents must have suffered in this hellhole of death doesn't bear thinking about, all in the name of the Christian religion.

Child abuse in Catholic homes was covered up and sanctioned by senior clergy, including the Pope for decades.

And we criticise Islam.

Side: Murder & bury them.
Cartman(18192) Disputed
3 points

We criticize Islam because they are even worse than Catholics. The abuse done by Catholics is nothing next to the Muslim countries in the middle east.

Side: Inhuman.
Antrim(1297) Disputed
1 point

You're undoubtedly correct in your assertion that the inhuman atrocities carried out in Muslim countries are worse than the barbarity of the Catholic Church but you should be mindful of the Biblical proverb of 'remove the plank from your own eye before you criticise someone else for the spec of dust in theirs'.

Your attempt to diminish this, and many other, dreadful horrors perpetrated by the Roman Catholic Church on defenseless children is akin to the trendy pastime of comparing every act of murderous brutality with the savagery of the Nazis during WW2.

Few, if any nation could equal the inhumanity of the Germans but that doesn't lessen the severity of other atrocities.

Side: Murder & bury them.

I will give you a thumbs up for finally speaking out against Muslims.

Side: Inhuman.
FromWithin(7720) Disputed
0 points

You total monsterous hypocrite. It's the likes of you and the Democrat Party that supports killing viable late term unborn babies for any reason up to birth and you have the nerve to judge others?

Your so called pious outrage is absolutely PATHETIC!

Picture a new born Baby being drawn and quartered, and then look in the mirror at what you support when you vote for Democrats who keep it legal to have no restriction abortions up to birth.

HYPOCRITE!

Side: Inhuman.
Cocopops(345) Disputed
1 point

If you'd fully 'read the thread', you would have noted that there were clearly abortions carried out at this Roman Catholic establishment.

Those who were born were branded as ''the Devil's children' and were not allowed to interact with other 'good Christian' youngsters.

When read in it's entirety the published article clearly illustrates that those who survived, until 2-3, were the ''UNLUCKY'' ones.

You are trying to make the self-defeating argument that the children mentioned in this shocking revelation were better off living a life of torturous misery before their untimely death at the ripe old age of 2 or 3 years old.

Side: Murder & bury them.
1 point

It certainly takes a lot of dedication to consistently act like an idiot for so long without ever slipping up.

Side: Murder & bury them.

I agree.

Most Roman Catholics and Muslims VOTE for PRO-ABORTION Law Makers...

This tells You much about what You need to know.

These organizations are led by leaders who SUPPORT PRO-ABORTION Law Makers. They are majority Liberal Democrat voters. The Catholislamic organizations are willing to promote lawmakers in order to make themselves wealthy and promote their growth.

Side: Murder & bury them.
4 points

Why am I not surprised?

Here's a little more about it.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/03/mass-grave-of-babies-and-children-found- at-tuam-orphanage-in-ireland

The only mitigating factor I'll mention is probably some of the clients who went to that facility had some idea in advance what it was and how it operated but still chose it. That's just some though. I'm sure there are many others who were forced into this by family or society, or even simply duped.

It's just one more example of religion being adamant their way is the right way and then turning around and committing the type of attrocities they would freak over if a different religion did them or especially if someone not religious at all did.

Side: Inhuman.
FromWithin(7720) Disputed
1 point

YOU TOTAL MONSTEROUS PIOUS HYPOCRITE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You support much worse every time you vote for these no restriction abortion Democrats!

Side: Murder & bury them.
Cuaroc(8826) Clarified
3 points

You heard it here first folks. According to FromWithin organisms with no brainwaves are more important than children.

Side: Murder & bury them.
Grenache(6103) Disputed
2 points

Luckily in both columns your single argument has already been dealt with. But what fascinates me is how your anger is triggered by US instead of by a church which would do this.

Side: Inhuman.
2 points

In many ways this spine chilling horror in a home run by Roman Catholic Nuns equals any of the atrocities carried out by Muslim religious zealots.

But, in common with all child abuse cases the Roman Catholic Church, in alliance with the Irish Government, will wring their hands and then produce a whitewashed report, if indeed there is any inquiry at all.

Side: Inhuman.
2 points

As a former Catholic born and reared in the Irish Repubic I'm only to aware of the outrageous behaviour of this ghastly organisation , I have witnessed first hand the barbaric cruelty perpetrated on the vulnerable and weakest members of society by this church where once they in league with the government ruled the country with a fist of iron .

The one thing noticeable about the country is when I was a youth the churches were packed now that's not the case as they're hard pushed to get a decent crowd into most .

Incidentally we are are still only at the tip of iceberg regarding this case watch as more follow

Side: Inhuman.
2 points

Just another example of the radical teachings of religion twisting peoples minds! For centuries religions (not just Catholics), have spawned members that kill "in the name of GOD!". THEY, and their belief in a god, have killed FAR more than those "horrible Atheists" have ever aborted! By the way, many of those who work with abortionists are NOT Atheists, they come from many religions! They are concerned with humanity far more thoughtfully than those with a one track mind! This post fits perfectly with the observances of Titus Lucretius Carus' statements: "So potent was religion in persuading to evil dreams." and "Such are the heights of wickedness to which men are driven by religion." In this and SOOOO many cases, this cannot be denied!

Side: Inhuman.
0 points

First of all, am not surprised because it's in ireland.

Secondly, am not surprised because it's catholic.

A group of people taking orders from a mortal man, sun of adam, same sinful blood as adam's acting as an intermediary between man and christ.....

When christ purposefuly left us the holy spirit.....

I wonder if the catholics have the book of revelation in their bibles.

And you better forget about the muslim issue, people are afraid to talk about muslims and they direct their bullshit towards christians because they think christians are sissys.....

Side: Inhuman.
Antrim(1297) Disputed
1 point

You must be new to this site if you think I'm reluctant to criticize Muslim terrorists and the barbaric Sharia laws of the Islamic faith.

However, Muslim atrocities can be aired under the appropriate heading.

Side: Murder & bury them.
jeffreyone(1349) Clarified
0 points

You must be new to this site if you think I'm reluctant to criticize Muslim terrorists and the barbaric Sharia laws of the Islamic faith.

Ok.

But i meant it in general.

You're like 0.078% here.

And also if that is true, i know soon enough....

They will grab you, like a promo......iphone 8

Side: Murder & bury them.