CreateDebate


Debate Info

51
48
Edward Jacob
Debate Score:99
Arguments:50
Total Votes:128
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Edward (27)
 
 Jacob (23)

Debate Creator

sierraxy(59) pic



The Never Ending Debate; Edward vs Jacob? This is for the Twi-Hearts

Should Bella have made a different choice? The issue we all wish we had; Edward's hair, or Jacob's abs?

Edward

Side Score: 51
VS.

Jacob

Side Score: 48
5 points

Edward is abusive and 117. His relationship with Bella is based entirely on that fact that hes "super fine 10/10" otherwise hes quite two dimensional. I'd rather have someone more down to earth and real than some superhero. Same with Jacob, hes only in there because they wanted someone to not have their shirt on so women would just come to see it for a few hours of abs.

Side: Team STFU
3 points

nope bella made the right choice.... and in any case jacob isn't the only one who has abs, edward too has them... though he doesn't flaunt them. and his hair are really cool..

Side: Edward
2 points

I say Edward :)

I never really liked Jacob, with forcing Bella to kiss him with the threst of suicide- which is just plain wrong. Edward always understands and cares for Bella, where Jacob is selfish. Sure, Jacob may have muscles and the humour, but so does Edward (not much in the movie though.).

Side: Edward
1 point

me too edward is so cute in the movie as well as in the book though what u say is not true, edward does have a sense of humour, he is just a little reserved in the begining of their friendship.

Side: Edward
4 points

Edward is the best thing in twilight and he sure does have a sense of humour.

Side: Edward
2 points

East or West.... EDWARD is the BEST.... i don't care what anyone says EDWARD IS THE BEST, was the BEST and WILL remain the BEST. Jacob is just a guy who likes Bella but he never imprinted on her because he never fell in love with her... and if Bella had chosen him over EDWARD, she would be doing injustice to both, EDWARD would lose the LOVE OF HIS IMMORTAL LIFE and Jacob would Never meet his real love(Bella's daughter, Reneesme). so she would be ruining everyone's life.

and as always EDWARD is the BEST.

Side: Edward

I've only seen the first film, and I thought it was pretty good - at least, better than I had expected.

First, I want to ask a question: If you read the book, you already know the answer; right?

Okay, now that that's settled with: I preferred Edward - necrophilia is way cooler than zoophilia.

Side: Edward
MKIced(2482) Disputed
1 point

"necrophilia is way cooler than zoophilia."

It's bestiality, not zoophilia. haha!

As a side note (and the reason I clicked the debate), why does any of this matter? I'm not directing this at you, of course. I just don't understand the fascination with Twilight. I saw 15 minutes of the first one and thought the acting, story, characters, and even the setting were all terrible. :(

Side: Jacob
TERMINATOR(6762) Disputed
2 points

Are you disputing me about the spelling?

I don't care either, I just wanted to add that joke I heard: Twilight: The Story of a Girl's Choice Between Necrophilia and Bestiality.

However, check out wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoophilia

Side: Edward
1 point

Edward is a protective boyfriend I agree, but really he only wants whats best for Bella. Really, if you think of the circumstances, Edward being a 108 year old Vampire who has never looked at a girl twice, but when he meets Bella, he falls in love. Jacob however, doesn't want whats best for Bella. He never thinks even for a second that maybe she is better off with Edward, but Edward did. And thats the only reason he left. To protect her. Jacob loves Bella, but not as much as Edward does. Edward would do anything for Bella. He loves her more than his own life. Jacob is Bella's best friend. Nothing more. And Jacob needs to accept that. Really, I think that Bella is far better off with Edward. He loves her and even if she did choose Jacob, Edward would never try to hurt them because he could never hurt Bella. He only wants whats best for her.

Aww :)

Side: Edward
1 point

edward is better than jacob... jacob can't be in love with bella coz. he can't take it a fact that bella is in love with edward and he can't be happy with the simple fact that she is happy... with edward. so edward u are the best...

Side: Edward
3 points

If you love smbody, set them free, if they return they were always yours, if they don't they never were!!! Edward set bella free bt Jacob didn't and that why Bella is with Edward and not with Jacob!!!

Side: Edward
1 point

n edward did nt set bella free!!!! he only decided it so dat bella wud be safer considerin jasper. although it did nt work out well!!! n it almost killed both o them.

Side: Edward
1 point

edward has awesome hair

he protects bella

bella chose edward

edward doesn't take his shirt off every five minutes

edward lives forever

edward doesn't imprint on people

edward can read minds, except bella's

edward has an awesome family

edward is a vampire

edward doesn't need rage to trigger his powers, like jacob does.

Side: Edward
1 point

i agree with all of that so people who like jacob he is sooooooo boring and stupid open yur eyes and get this through yur thick heads!

Side: Edward
0 points

Jacob's abs are impressive, but Edward's everlasting love for her is and should be the winner. Sure, he left her, but it killed him to lie about the reason. He was willing to hurt himself insanely just to protect her. Jacob threatened to kill himself if Bella didn't kiss him in Eclipse which is just plain out wrong. He is a friend and nothing more in Bella's mind until Jacob deludes her into thinking she loves him. Edward kills 2 of the vampires trying to kill Bella intentionally while Jacob kills one just because it was on his land. That one vampire (the dude with dreadlocks in the movie, forgot the name) was the only nice vampire in James's coven. He had warned the Cullens and Bella about James and was a vegetarian vampire for almost a year prior to getting killed by Jacob.

Side: Edward
WaffleIron(51) Disputed
1 point

Jacob's love for Bella is also everlasting, whether he imprinted on someone else or not. He loves her based on what he knows about her. They have a long history together. Edward thought she smelled good. I have read the books and seen the films several times, and do not remember any instances in which Edward and Bella bond over any real interests, except for some music. The relationship between Bella and Edward is more juvenile than the one I had with my kindergarten boyfriend. (He at least made me mixtapes and we both enjoyed Disney movies and whales.) They barely know one another and all of a sudden this 17-year old girl is in love with someone with the wisdom and experiences of a 118 year old. That's screwed up. What could he possibly have in common with her. She's built like a 13-year old and has a dull personality. Wait a minute! I just figured it out. They're both dull, whiny, and they deserve one another. I totes get it now! Jacob's better off.

Side: Jacob
4 points

I have a penis and like vagina therefore I would rather die than watch a bunch of prepubescent teens prancing through the forest crying about this and that for 2 hours.

However, if they use my alternate ending, where Frankenstein rises from a grave and strangles both these goobers to death with each hand and rides off into the sunset with a chick who is way hotter than whoever that homely looking love interest chick is, then I'll watch.

Side: Frankenstein
Troy8(2430) Banned
5 points

Do you mean Victor Frankenstein's monster? If so, then I would have to agree with you (just this one time).

Side: Frankenstein
3 points

Twilight is like soccer. They run around for hours, nobody scores, and its fans insist that you just don't understand.

The minimum length for an argument is 50 characters. The purpose of this restriction is to cut down on the amount of dumb jokes, so we can keep the quality of debate and discourse as high as possible.

Side: Twilight Sucks

At least frankenstein is honest that he is nothing but a walking corpse monster hell bent on devouring a young woman... and Honesty is everything in a relationship

Side: Frankenstein
2 points

Who cares? The terribly written books, poorly acted films, and obsessive twi-tard fangirls are all proof of how bad this series sucks.

Side: Twilight Sucks
1 point

Jacob. He has a sense of humour and a cool personality.

Edward is always so dramatic and going on about how vampires how no soul. Brooding just isn't cool.

Plus, Edward has no respect for Bella at all - it he did he would have respected her choice to become a vampire and not treat her like a child with his "I know what's best" attitude. He once delibrately broke her car just so she won't go see Jacob; the guy who helped Bella when she needed it the most. He also pressurized Bella when it came to marriage and college. Marriage is meant to be a partnership and if she doesn't want to marry him, he should accept that.

Side: Jacob
1 point

okay, i like edward in the books but robert pattinson looks like a druggie really so jacob all the way for me

Side: Jacob
1 point

He's warm, both in personality and body temperature. Automatically, that's a huge plus, seeing as how humans are warm blooded. Also, you'd be able to have living children with him. Plus, he's a mechanic. He's extremely loyal, and never talks down to Bella. He only wants what's best for her. He would never commit suicide because Bella left him. (Edward wanted to die if Bella wouldn't be with him. Man up.) He's much ore strong-willed than Edward in that way.

Side: Jacob
Azze(107) Banned
0 points

okay dont get me wrong the books and the movies suck nards!! terrible (the chick is pathetic)! but nonetheless-jacob is so much better for her. first of all he has never hurt her, second he is WAY better looking, third he is her best friend which is what i think a "life mate" should be. i dont see how she picked edward except for what she can get out of him. not saying she is like that but seriously, how can she choose him. makes no sense?

Side: Jacob
Satakshi(95) Disputed
0 points

first of all...the book is great!!! and the 'chick; is not awful at all...i think Bella is wonderful!!! AND JACOB IS SUCH AN IDIOT!!! if you have read the last book,you will know that he ends up with Bella's daughter!!! so Edward is WAY BETTER!!!

Side: Edward
swtspiceN3Gi(33) Disputed
2 points

I know Lots Of people hate the Jacob and renesmee Imprinting thing,.... But i think that Jacob ending up with bella's daughter is kind of cool. Jacob also deserves Something good!I never really liked Jacob but hes just any other guy in love!

Side: Edward
Azze(107) Disputed Banned
0 points

Bella is SO pathetic! She literally NEEDS Edward in order to survive. Dude if you need a guy that much to the point where you can barely breathe and someone needs to find you in the freezing ass woods and someone needs to find you and then the next few months are absolutely nothing to you, you really need a reality check. Jacob brought her back from her sulking pathetic ways. He made it so she could "survive." And yeah he gets with the daughter, BFD! What is you point. Yeah it's a happy ending, DUH it's a chick book what do you expect. I am just saying that it is just flat out sad. And if you believe that a girl should react that way to a stupid boy leaving then I feel sorry for you and whoever decides to be with you. GOOD DAY, SIR!

Side: Jacob
Azze(107) Banned
0 points

edwards hair??? psh sorry honey but he doesnt have much going for him. he as waaaaaaay better off in harry potter none of that sappy crap

Side: Jacob
lope(143) Disputed
1 point

jacob doesn't have much going on either. jacob should be the one in harry potter.

Side: Edward
sierraxy(59) Disputed
-1 points

FIRST: DON'T CALL ME HONEY.

SECOND: HARRY POTTER SUCKS BALLS

FINALLY: TWILIGHT IS NOT CRAP. IT IS MY FAVORITE MOVIE SERIES

ALSO: I FOUND THAT HAIR OR ABS THING IN A MAGAZINE.

Side: Edward
MKIced(2482) Disputed
1 point

This is your favorite series? God help us all..... If you're watching it for the acting, then you don't know acting. If you're watching for the plot, you haven't seen any other movies. And if you're watching it to see either of the guys half-naked, there are magazines, tabloids, porn, other shows, and other movies where you can get the same or better.

Side: Jacob
Azze(107) Disputed Banned
0 points

ok i wont call you honey. harry potter does not suck balls jack ass you just think twilight is so great because you want a butt buddy like edward. well here's a dose of reality you ain't never going to get someone like that. so have fun in make believe land. oh yeah and FINALLY:twilight series and the fans suck balls

Side: Jacob