CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:30
Arguments:27
Total Votes:30
Ended:03/15/12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
  (23)

Debate Creator

nahga(81) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

'The Spirit' ........ What is It?

This is not a question of philosophy. This is a question for those who contend that spirits exist and make up some part of every human being.

If that is truly the case I ask, What is the spirit? I'm not asking what you believe. I am asking for a clear definition, that distinctly explains what the spirit is.

 

 

Add New Argument
3 points

People won't be able to answer this without their beliefs being thrown in, just saying.

But I believe, we can't give a definition without proof, that spirits are simply energy. That's it. And for all life to continue that energy must transfer.

2 points

I am a theist so this is my belief; the word spirit in terms of that third part of man (body, soul, spirit) is an old word. It is “ruach” in Hebrew, spiritus in Latin, Greek it is called pneuma. You still see pneuma used even today like pneumatic, pneumonia all associated with air or wind, breath.

Job 33.4 (KJV)

The Spirit of God hath made me, And the breath of the Almighty hath given me life.

Or

And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul ” (Genesis 2.7 ).

People are made up of three part the body, the soul, and the spirit.

2 points

I follow the Dactrial Mertholeses' holy scriptures.

And on Karsavius 6.1 (DAJ) The great God of Parsius speaks with hushed tones towards Nerebryn in the Desolation of Methoro and declares his soul to be bound to his mortal husk- it's really inspiring.

Also in Sa'Navin 4:14 He explains how the human soul was forged from the Nether Womb of Xzarasius Th'al.

Souls are wonderful things, aren't they?

1 point

Yes very inspiring, but i really enjoy Karsavius 6.2 -4 much deeper in the subject. It relates very well Karsavius 4.26, 27.

You should take time to compare it to Proverbs 26:5 (KJV) you would fine it enlightening.

http://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Proverbs-26-5/

1 point

That Essence that somehow Appears between all the Synapses in the brain that somehow creates a reaction of some kind, that works.

nahga(81) Clarified
1 point

@ Facadeon:

What essence? havent you simply traded one ambiguity for another?

Facadeon(510) Clarified
1 point

It's difficult to describe, but it is there...

"Essence" may be the wrong word to describe it.

1 point

anything that exists, exists not because of our beliefs but in spite of them.

1 point

It's just your brain's awareness of itself. Nothing more. When it stops so does your "spirit."

nahga(81) Disputed
1 point

self awareness emerges from the brain. nothing else is necessary. as you say, our awareness stops when the brain stops.

but what is the spirit?

every time i ask this question, no one can define the spirit as anything they know, or can show to actually exist, and most of the time it is simply defined via equivocation as things known to emerge from the brain.

yet ppl are always talking about spirits.

if it aint just a feel good buzzword, what the hell is it?

iamdavidh(4871) Disputed
3 points

The spirit doesn't exist is what I'm saying. It's not there. It's an illusion, just the brain and whatever synapsis, knowledge, thoughts are rolling around in there.