CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
5
He has no comment Cat has his tongue
Debate Score:13
Arguments:13
Total Votes:15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 He has no comment (8)
 
 Cat has his tongue (5)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(28873) pic



The debate Nom is ignoring like the plague


But, Stalin wanted to crush all left-wing parties who were not the Communist party; this led to a civil war amongst the Republican movement in Spain. Orwell got caught up in this and it made him really disgusted with Stalin and the Communist party.

“the Communists stood not upon the extreme Left, but upon the extreme right. In reality this should come as no surprise, because of the tactics of the Communist parties elsewhere.

George Orwell, Homage to Catalonia


https://www.biographyonline.net/socialism-george-orwell/


http://www.george-orwell.org/Homage_to_Catalonia/4.html

He has no comment

Side Score: 8
VS.

Cat has his tongue

Side Score: 5
1 point

“the Communists stood not upon the extreme Left, but upon the extreme right. In reality this should come as no surprise, because of the tactics of the Communist parties elsewhere.”

Brontoraptor has literally cut out the second half of a sentence in order to purposefully misrepresent what Orwell was writing about. You see, Brontoraptor wants you to believe that Orwell was speaking in general terms, when in actual fact he was writing very specifically about Spain. See:-

The only unexpected feature in the Spanish situation — and outside Spain it has caused an immense amount of misunderstanding — is that among the parties on the Government side the Communists stood not upon the extreme Left, but upon the extreme Right.

https://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/o/orwell/ george/o79h/chapter5.html

Side: He has no comment
BrontoLite(44) Disputed
1 point

Pretty stupid Nom. You claim I omit something that I've put in many of my posts, and then the part you say I omit literally still says Communism is far right.

Side: Cat has his tongue
0 points

Poor old broken Nom has no comment because, this one contaminated excuse for a man who is dripping with disease IS THE plague, the black plague, a pandemic of pestilence.

Side: He has no comment
JammyDodger(60) Disputed
1 point

Poor old broken Nom has no comment because, this one contaminated excuse for a man who is dripping with disease IS THE plague, the black plague, a pandemic of pestilence.

Your obsession with "Nom" is borderline pathological and one can only assume your continuous, unrelenting and infantile desperation to goad him emanates from you being subliminally traumatised at his substantively superior level of intelligence.

Side: Cat has his tongue
1 point

Hi Bronto.

I have addressed your Nazi propaganda dozens of times. You just keep repeating it.

Orwell was absolutely right about Stalin though. It's funny how you spent days denying that Stalin was a far right dictator only to change your mind the moment it suits you.

Your credibility vanished the first time you used Nazi propaganda to draw a false link between Communism and Nazism, and nobody has taken you seriously from the moment you made it clear that you get your information from the literal Chief Nazi Minister of Propaganda.

Side: Cat has his tongue
CrapWeasel(530) Disputed
1 point

Your credibility vanished the first time you used Nazi propaganda to draw a false link between Communism and Nazism

It looks like Goebells and Orwell made the same connection.

Side: He has no comment
JammyDodger(60) Disputed
1 point

It looks like Goebells and Orwell made the same connection.

No it doesn't. It looks like Goebbels was trying to pull votes in from the German left (i.e. his job) and Orwell was describing the difference between Stalinism and actual Marxist Communism.

You distort and take everything you can out of context because you are a lying Nazi imbecile who does not even possess the honesty to remain on the same account for longer than two minutes.

Side: Cat has his tongue
1 point

I have addressed your Nazi propaganda dozens of times

I looked through your waterfall because it's short. You've never addressed it. Why'd you lie to us buddy?

Side: He has no comment
JammyDodger(60) Disputed
1 point

I looked through your waterfall because it's short. You've never addressed it. Why'd you lie to us buddy?

Your gambit to pretend this is my first and only account is clearly ridiculous given that you have been calling me Nom all afternoon.

If I am a new member why are you continuously addressing me by the name of an old member?

Nevermind. You're a stupid lying Nazi and that is perfectly obvious by the way you contradict yourself every three minutes.

Side: Cat has his tongue
CrapWeasel(530) Disputed
0 points

Bronto, looks like we have an admittance that Nom is a far right Communist right here.

Side: He has no comment