CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
2
It only abides USA's advice. Pivotal in resolving disputes
Debate Score:3
Arguments:4
Total Votes:3
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 It only abides USA's advice. (1)
 
 Pivotal in resolving disputes (2)

Debate Creator

Amritangshu(892) pic



This is a private debate. See the FAQ for more info.

Challenge Debate: The role of UN is undefined,what does it really do?

Amritangshu(892)

It only abides USA's advice.

Side Score: 1
VS.
flewk(1193)

Pivotal in resolving disputes

Side Score: 2

The role and the power of UN can certainly be scrutinized especially when you see this organization is failing in virtually every attempt it's been making-Yemen Crisis,ISIS and BOKO HARAM ravaging;it took it almost 40 years to pronounce 'Apartheid' a social crime;Hardly any significant sanctions were imposed on Russia after Crimea-annexation.No resolving of Kashmir dispute in India,No help is reached out to the helpless in Ethiopia,what does it really do?An organization with a respectable name only!

Side: It only abides USA's advice.
flewk(1193) Clarified
1 point

You are talking about the execution as I have already mentioned. The role of the UN is defined by its charter as I have already mentioned.

Side: It only abides USA's advice.
1 point

The role of the UN is defined in its charter. Its purpose has changed over time.

Perhaps you are hinting at the poor execution rather than the actual charter?

Side: Pivotal in resolving disputes
1 point

Also, the UN does not just follow the US. The security council permanent members include China and Russia. Don't really have to explain those. France has never been a staunch ally of the US. Only UK supports the US.

Also, I have no idea why you think the UN is suppose to be "pivotal in resolving disputes".

Its charter even says it only promotes and encourages co-operation. Nothing about forcing countries to drop disputes.

Side: Pivotal in resolving disputes