CreateDebate


Debate Info

0
16
DNA is SCIENCE, after all excon is a LIAR, LIAR, LIAR
Debate Score:16
Arguments:1
Total Votes:16
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 excon is a LIAR, LIAR, LIAR (1)

Debate Creator

excon(18261) pic



The state of Israel is using DNA to determine who's Jewish and who's not

Hello liars, science deniers, and Jew haters:  

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5034383

excon

DNA is SCIENCE, after all

Side Score: 0
VS.

excon is a LIAR, LIAR, LIAR

Side Score: 16
No arguments found. Add one!
16 points

Your article is another demonstrably false piece of Israeli propaganda, which is based ENTIRELY on the "Jewish gene" I debunked last night (i.e. before you posted this). You don't ever read the things anybody else posts because you are just so pathetically desperate to deny reality. You simply cherry-pick articles which draw different conclusions and dump them without investigating any further. From your article:-

The Cohanim Modal Haplotype (CMH), the Jewish genetic marker that has received the most attention, was first publicized in the journal Nature in a study that identified six differences in the DNA sequence of male Jews that identified as Cohens or Cohanim (Jewish priests).47 Some scientists think that the Cohanim signature could represent the inheritance of over 100 generations from the founder of the patrilineal genetic line.48 The signature is traced to a date over 3000 years ago, in accordance with the oral tradition that the Cohens maintain a line of patrilineal descent from Aaron, the first Jewish priest

But before you even posted this trash, it was fully explained to you that the Cohanim Haplotype is not exclusive to Jews and appears frequently among many other Middle Eastern groups. Here is the information you ignored:-

The closest thing to a “Jewish gene” is an element on the Y chromosome of males that has been passed down at least for several millenia in the male line of the Cohanim family, and whose presence in a man’s genome is evidence of descent from the priestly class. The frequency of this “CMH” (Cohanim Modal Haplotype) is around 50 percent among the members of the Cohen line. This haplotype is by no means exclusive to the Jews. It is found in some other Middle Eastern groups in frequencies of around 20 percent.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5034383/

Furthermore, you pathetic retard, it has already been explained that you have no genetic relationship to the Cohen line because your DNA is derived from Greek and Iranian pagans (i.e. Ashkenazi), not the original tribes of Israel where this bloodline originated. Once again:-

Most of the world's modern Jewish population, as well as the Yiddish language, come from Turkey and not other parts of the Middle East, according to a new study.

Dr Eran Elhaik of the University of Sheffield used a computer modelling system to convert Ashkenazi Jewish DNA - the Jewish communities historically located in Europe - data into geographical information, which revealed that 90 percent of Ashkenazi Jews descend from the Greeks, Iranians and others who colonised northern Anatolia (now northern Turkey) more than 2,000 years ago before converting to Judaism.

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/most-jews-descended-ancient-turkey-new-study-2107639949

In summary, the article you have linked credits the Cohanim Haplotype as being a "Jewish gene", despite the facts showing that it is NOT exclusive to Jews, nor does every Jew have this gene. In fact, the gene only appears in around half of the actual direct family line it is hypothesised to come from in the first place, which means you could be a direct descendent of the Cohen line, an orthodox Jew, and STILL be refused immigration to Israel on the grounds that you do not have "Jewish DNA".

The proof is really in the pudding, since the only people you have thus far found who believe the utter fabrications of reality you are proliferating are ISRAELI JEWS. You went to an ISRAELI company for a "DNA test" and now you are telling us we should accept the ISRAELI STATE's opinion about whether being Jewish is a genetic phenomena: A STATE WHOSE ENTIRE EXISTENCE IS PREDICATED ON THERE BEING A GENETIC BASIS FOR JEWISHNESS.

You are pathetic, excon. A horrible, science-denying fascist and a fake Jew who does not listen to anything else except what he wants to believe.

Side: excon is a LIAR, LIAR, LIAR