CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
4
Agree Sour Puss
Debate Score:6
Arguments:4
Total Votes:7
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Agree (1)
 
 Sour Puss (3)

Debate Creator

ObiWan(14) pic



They're your tests, humans. Do them on yourselves, not other animals.

Agree

Side Score: 2
VS.

Sour Puss

Side Score: 4
No arguments found. Add one!
2 points

Can you honestly state that you have never used a cosmetic product or treated an ailment with a medicine which was not tested on animals.

Do you really carry out an ''in-depth'' check on all medicines you take and all products you use to ensure they were never tested on animals?

IF YOU'RE SO CONCERNED ABOUT THE WELFARE OF ANIMALS WHY DON'T YOU PRESENT YOURSELF A HUMAN ALTERNATIVE?

Side: Sour Puss
0 points

Many peoples' lives have been saved by animal testing, & we aren't going to do tests on human children if we think it might kill them or seriously hurt them.

Sometimes in real life you have to make hard choices. In this case, human or animal. Any sane person will rank the human higher & do the test. Life isn't fair. It's just life.

Side: Sour Puss
Rothschild(56) Disputed
2 points

@OmegaPansexual

Many peoples' lives have been saved by animal testing

And many animals lives have bean ended by animal testing.

we aren't going to do tests on human children if we think it might kill them or seriously hurt them.

That's why we just kill other mammals children, right.

Sometimes in real life you have to make hard choices.

Sometimes in life you have to make hard dicks ejaculate into your mouth.

In this case, human or animal. Any sane person will rank the human higher

What logical objective basis do you have for this? It's only because it's the same species as you. What makes other sentient beings less valuable? Is it their lack of cognitive complexity? Does this mean that retards can have less moral value than animals as long as they are more stupid? Aren't there chimps that are as intelligent elementary schoolers? Should we do testing on retards who are dumber than chimps instead? If an extraterrestrial species that was so advanced we would be like rats to them came to our solar system would they be justified in doing experiments on us? Hmmm? HMMMMMM????????

You'r argument is not logically sound or morally consistent. If you analyse it, the basis of your argument boils down to:

Number One: I am a human therefor humans are the most important species

Number Two: We are the most important because we are the most cognitively advanced even though we are also the most full of superstitious nonsense and 90% of the average humans thought process revolves around pure self importance and subjectivity.

Number Three: You are a disease that thinks it is the greatest thing in all of creation when all you do is poison the eco system and make up social constructs that fuck up natural selection.

Side: Agree
OmegaPan(710) Disputed
1 point

What makes other sentient beings less valuable? Is it their lack of cognitive complexity? Does this mean that retards can have less moral value than animals as long as they are more stupid? Aren't there chimps that are as intelligent elementary schoolers? Should we do testing on retards who are dumber than chimps instead? If an extraterrestrial species that was so advanced we would be like rats to them came to our solar system would they be justified in doing experiments on us? Hmmm? HMMMMMM????????

Yes.

Side: Sour Puss