CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:7
Arguments:7
Total Votes:7
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Think this deserves an 'A'? Do you like it? (7)

Debate Creator

DaWolfman(3324) pic



Think this deserves an 'A'? Do you like it?

I was supposed to write a poem that was fairly dark/scary for one of my classes. Let me know what you guys think.

Room 23.

I stare into what feels like night,

You see I am a bit of a phobic

When there is a lack of light

When I am concealed in utter darkness I begin to perspirate

Though I try with all of my might

Try to calm myself from the nightmare knowing I can not fight fate

As being in a nightmare to me is an easy task

You see my nightmare wears no mask

While I lay hollowly screaming whilst dreaming

Of nothing that I can fight, only fear

Walking blindly into a pitch black hell

Feeling the devil wanting to buy the only thing

That I have to sell

All these blank images, of nothing but the color black

Feeling myself caught in the midst of a smokestack

 Merely due to what I can not see

As all I want to be is free of the fear of

What I am unable to visualize

What I can not see is likewise to a blind mans eyes

I could hypothesize why I fear the way I do

However all I could tell you would be nothing but lies

I want my imagination to only fade

As this vertigo I am in only edges me closer to my grave

My fears convert me into darkness’s slave

See I scream only mentally and in my minds eye I can see I am crazy

Fearing to be awake, whilst it is night

And finding myself in darkness nothing to shine bright

As dreaming nightmares through the night into daylight

Is better to weather than any late night fright

To be awake realizing that reality is not fake, feeling real pain

Comprehending that I am not sane

My imagination is what makes me prone to fear

This is why I adhere to what I find to be unclear

As my heart quickens I jeer as nothing matters there is nothing to fear.

I will forget this however after the men in white put me down

As after they put me down I will be unable to frown

They say I am unsound that I am lost and will never be found

However as the medication fades I see clearly how close I am to the brink of sanity

They don’t want this you see, they want me to remain crazy

It puts money in their pocket as I scribble insanities that I covet

My illness deserves no credit to none but me you see I forfeit

Until I awaken once more, to there pounding of my door.

I will remain here in my room forever reserved.

Here with those that I hear but do not see

the others that are disturbed.

 

Add New Argument
1 point

Well it fucking rhymes doesn't it?

Side: Why the fuck not
DaWolfman(3324) Disputed
1 point

That really doesn't help me at all ...

Just because it rhymes doesn't mean it deserves an A, and whether or not you like it is a little hard to tell considering you had a 6 word response. That only told me what I already knew, it rhymes.

Side: Not what I was looking for

College or high school level?

Either way, you should ensure that you're keeping with rhythmic limitation.

eg. the pickled peer is delicious, even tasty to a goon

Peanuts are castaways, like sad backlot toons

The lonely woman bares herself, bosom to the moon

In line with the rhythmic limitation, your meter begins to skew after the first few rhymes. You should fix that. You're also a bit too abstract. Write about the more concrete aspects of your experience. While listeners/readers might be able to intuitively understand this notion of nothingness that pervades your poem, they'll struggle to visualize it and get a visceral experience from it. Even in nonsense poetry, you'll get concrete wording. Consider the Jabberwocky, by Lewis Carol.

Side: Not what I was looking for
1 point

High school level

The lines don't really match up with how I read it either, and where I put my stresses. It is a spoken word poem, but thanks for the input mate. I'll revise!

Side: thanks

Do you want the opinion of a friend, or an honest opinion?

Friendly opinion:

It was terrific.

Honest opinion:

Some lines I felt were too long, as were some of the words. Some lines were used syllables that were too difficult to properly enunciate in a manner suitable for poetry.

Try to calm myself from the nightmare knowing I can not fight fate

Should be rewritten as

'Try to calm myself from the nightmare

Fate I know I can not fight.'

I rarely read modern poems, thus I cannot judge it properly from a modern person's opinion.

If you care regardless of your grade, why not try submitting it to a magazine. Find out what they think - they are most likely to give it a proper appraisal.

Side: A minus
1 point

Thanks mate, just to let you know it is a spoken word poem. So it comes out sounding a little bit like a rap, with parts that are fast paced and others that have heavy pronunciations on the endings of others.

I appreciate the criticism, and what did you think? Your honest opinion doesn't tell me what you thought =P

Side: A minus

it is very good I can tell you put your feelings into it and a good poem always shows some of the authors feelings and it is awsome

Side: A minus