CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
0
Yes, the good outweighs bad No, it's gross and unnatural
Debate Score:3
Arguments:3
Total Votes:3
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, the good outweighs bad (3)

Debate Creator

zombee(1026) pic



Tissue Engineered Meat

Tissue engineering has progressed to a point where small amounts of meat can be grown from a single animal muscle cell. Although it may be a decade or more before we can expect this medium to be streamlined and tweaked to a level suitable for commercial mass production, some scientists say tissue engineered meat is the inevitable future of food production.

The upsides of this would be numerous: producers can control what goes into the meat, and there has been some speculation about making meat healthier by doing things like replacing Omega 6, a fatty acid, with Omega 3, which is better for us. Millions of animals every year would be spared from enduring a short, horrible life to feed us. The meat would not be contanimated by things like feces and dirt, an unavoidable part of modern meat production. The space and resources required to produce meat would be cut drastically and hopefully, so would the cost.

On the other hand, lots of people have a gut reaction of disgust and aversion when presented with the idea of meat grown in a lab. It certainly does not look like the meat we are used to, and the process of creating it is far from appetizing. Although it is genetically identical to 'naturally grown' meat, there have been no long term studies carried out and it is concievable consumers might experience unforseen side effects from eating tissue engineered meat.

If the technology was available today to put a tissue engineered steak on your plate, would you eat it? What if it didn't taste quite exactly the same, would the benefits be worth it? Do you agree with producers altering the chemical makeup of meat? Should lab-grown meat be given a different name so people know when they are buying foods that contain it, at a restaurant for example?

Yes, the good outweighs bad

Side Score: 3
VS.

No, it's gross and unnatural

Side Score: 0
1 point

I think i would eat it under two conditions; it can't come out of a toothpaste tube and they have to engineer taste to go along with it.

This could potentially solve a lot of world issues if it was more efficient to manufacture than beef.

People that only buy "all natural" food are retarded. Humans are extremely unique on this planet, so anything we do isn't going to be natural so there is no point in making it a big deal. If we can do it better than nature, why not?

Side: Yes, the good outweighs bad

As a vegan, I know the dangers, implications, and (my own) moral hazards of meat-eating. Tissue-engineered meat may not be ideal, but it's better than slaughtering sentient creatures!

Side: Yes, the good outweighs bad

One of the reasons my wife married me is because I'll eat whatever she puts in front of my face ;)

Side: Yes, the good outweighs bad
No arguments found. Add one!