CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
4
Good Bad
Debate Score:8
Arguments:9
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Good (4)
 
 Bad (4)

Debate Creator

TheEccentric(3382) pic



Trade Unions: Good or Bad?

Good

Side Score: 4
VS.

Bad

Side Score: 4
1 point

Good because workers have rights. .

Side: Good
1 point

You mean "Good because they allow workers to take the piss"?

What about all of the disruption they cause? If a worker doesn't like the way an employer treats them then no one's forcing them to work for them. They are power hungry socialist organisations who will never be content with just decent rights and conditions to work in.

Side: Bad
1 point

The original philosophy to have a voice to improve workers conditions and pay was admirable however they lost their ideals and became all powerful such that they became a law unto themselves

I will always believe in workers rights to negotiate pay and conditions and the unions still have a useful role as the mediator.

Side: Good
flewk(1193) Clarified
1 point

It is not just about mediation. Unions have a louder voice than an individual. While there are many examples of corrupt unions, there are far more examples of unions actually fighting for the workers.

Side: Good
0 points

It all depends what you believe the lesser evil to be.

My take is that trade unions are created to fight corporations.

Side: Good

They are bad because they really over the top with workers' rights and allow striking. They are far too demanding. Striking has crippled nations many times and has proven to be counterproductive. Public sector workers striking wreaks havoc for everyone and is selfish.

I wish someone like Thatcher was still around to crush the unions like how she did.

Side: Bad
1 point

Public sector unions work directly against the interests of the public, and should be banned.

Private sector unions have killed jobs and ruined the auto industry in the US.

Side: Bad
1 point

And sometimes management at a company gets too greedy and ends up driving a company into the ground, too.

The majority of businesses are fine and the majority of unions are fine.

Side: Good
1 point

They are to commerce and industry what the iceberg was to the Titanic. They're obsolete, self serving organisations which have been the cause of 100s of 1000s of jobs going to foreign countries.God curse these narrow minded low lives.

Side: Bad