CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
0
Push Them Leave It
Debate Score:3
Arguments:2
Total Votes:3
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Push Them (2)

Debate Creator

Nomoturtle(857) pic



Trolley Problem

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOpf6KcWYyw

Push Them

Side Score: 3
VS.

Leave It

Side Score: 0

Push that fat person.

Push them very, very hard.

Push them now.

Side: Push Them
1 point

First scenario

The guy pushes the fat guy off the bridge, five lives are saved and he goes to prison for murder, and maybe gets a lighter sentence because of the intention to save lives. i.e for the greater good

Second scenario

Now lets say the pusher believes in fate. In his view the five guys are on the railway line at that time on that day to die, it is their fate. If the fat guy is pushed off the bridge the pusher will interfere with the fate of the five guys and the fat guy. So he leaves it and looks the other way

Third scenario

The pusher rushes up to the fat guy and tells him that the train is going to kill the five guys unless something drastic happens, so the fat guy jumps and saves the day.

I'll stick with the last one because :-

The fat guy gets a posthumous award

The pusher is saved from jail

The five guys live to await their fate on another day

Side: Push Them
No arguments found. Add one!