CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
2
Allow them to be them! They can't possibly know yet.
Debate Score:9
Arguments:5
Total Votes:9
Ended:11/30/12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Allow them to be them! (3)
 
 They can't possibly know yet. (2)

Debate Creator

JayAr(182) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

U18 Transgender

Should people under the age of majority be allowed to seek gender corrective therapies such as:

Counselling? (Currently allowed for all ages) Just standard therapy to allow them to talk out their emotions and things like that.

Andro/Estrogenic blocking? (10+) Blocking hormones from altering the body in the perceived incorrect ways. Requires 6 months counselling, diagnoses of GID (Gender Identity Disorder), and M.D approval.

Hormone Replacment Therapy? (16+) What it says on the tin...  Requires 6 months counselling, diagnoses of GID (Gender Identity Disorder), and M.D approval.

 

Allow them to be them!

Side Score: 7
Winning Side!
VS.

They can't possibly know yet.

Side Score: 2
4 points

Well, I think that a minor should have to be seeking therapy first in order to ensure that they are not just making an instant decision that would end up being a mistake. But adults should be able to do w/e they want. If the policy of the doctor is for them to seek therapy, go ahead.

But I do believe that state laws should focus on making sure that minors receive therapy first.

Side: Allow them to be them!
2 points

If they really are. And that must be confirmed first. Properly...!

Side: Allow them to be them!

Sure why not, it is up to the individual. Those in question would already have the ability to think for themselves and have an opinion on the matter and formulate their own resolve. Those who say they are not old enough to know are stating that they are unable to think for themselves at that age, which is quite the opposite.

Side: Allow them to be them!
1 point

Underaged yes but not before puberty . No reason why other than before puberty don't really know which gener is dominent. Besides could be both 50-50 and live with that.

Side: They can't possibly know yet.
1 point

Depends on how we define what the age of consent is. If they're old enough to know what sex is, want to take hormone therapy, get implants/remove breasts, and mutilate their genitals, I would think they should be allowed to have sex, as well.

Side: Allow them to be them!