CreateDebate


Debate Info

11
8
yes no
Debate Score:19
Arguments:19
Total Votes:19
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 yes (11)
 
 no (8)

Debate Creator

akanksha77(9) pic



Universal brotherhod is more important than patriotism

I have a debate in my school on this topic and i have to speak against the motion. so please help me with your veiws and opinions....InnocentSmileWink

yes

Side Score: 11
VS.

no

Side Score: 8

A resounding YES, the quicker homo sapiens realize that we are but a speck in the chaotic, ever unfolding universe, the quicker, all will realize that we are more alike then different.

The easiest path to unlocking this fundamental concept in all self aware beings on the third circular object, that orbits a small helium/hydrogen nuclear reactor, is for other sentient beings to announce themselves! Then earthlings will have to realize that what used to be an easily understood flat world is but one of 100,000,000,000,000 similarly composed objects!

Side: yes
1 point

Patriotism leads to nationalism that leads to military hubris. The idea of nation is recent in human history - before that it was your tribe or landlord and family. Here's a quote from the link:

"This is the true danger of the rise of nationalism in the United States. One more successful terrorist attack is the only tipping point needed to allow corporate funds, now legal for direct political investment, to push American politics dangerously close to fascist nationalism. The hysteria over mosque building and burqas is just a glint in the eye of the Tea Party’s shameless racist nationalism. "

Supporting Evidence: blog (curtisschweitzer.net)
Side: yes
1 point

If by Universal Brotherhood you mean working together as a species, and by important you mean more beneficial, then yes. Although that concept would appear to be patriotism on a much larger scale, unlike typical patriotism, it is backed by logic. It is logical to want to progress one's own species. That progress can be helped by uniting humanity, and much more so than the typical patriotism.

Side: yes

Full development of the individual requires various social structures.

Patriotism can help advance those social structures only to a certain point, after which it becomes inhibitory.

A non-universal brotherhood is quite distinct from patriotism, and in general a brotherhood is more personal and individual oriented.

Brotherhood on a large scale can advance social structures pass what patriotism can, and thus lead to a more fulfilled and developed individual.

Patriotism is more for the benefit of a limited group as a whole, whereby a brotherhood is more for the good of each individual.

There comes a point where the group benefits do not coincide with the individual benefits so then patriotism acts to crush the individual to protect the group identity. A brotherhood will hibernate till its members interests coincide.

Side: yes
1 point

universal brotherhood is peace among all countries in the world . It is more important. peace is the king of all values.

Peace is what counts. just remember the 2nd world war

Side: yes
1 point

Its widely accepted that the love of humanity is above all religions. May it be Christianity, Islam, Budhism, Hinduism or any religion across the world, each of them has the spirit, sons of the same

father, then why are we fighting to divide ourselves in the false pretension of patriotism, nationalism or many more.

My worthy opponent may boast to say that universal brotherhood is the mirage because every nation must put hand forward for this task, only this can be a reality. But I am sorry to remind my worthy

opponent , can he tell me the name of any country where the great souls did not universalize the oneness factor, to love the humanity and respect every individual. The great souls like Lord Christ,

lord budha, confusius, jarthustra lighted the lamp of humanity through ages. There had been the effort by every country in this direction.

Today, in the globalized world, who can imagine to be untouched from the occurrences world over. It’s like being empty stomach in spite of delicious dishes in the home.

Just think, how all nations are interdepended over one another economically, socially and religiously. Being broken from the bonds how can any nation survive? Can you tell any nation fulfilling all its

requirements by its own. I firmly believe there will be none.

The days of blind nationalism and unguarded patriotism are wrapped in pages of history books, today they mean nothing in reality.

Today in materialistic and utilitarian world we don’t live merely in family, village, country but in the world too. The students prefer to get education in foreign universities, to marry foreign girl, to settle

in foreign land, to visit foreign tourist places. Moreover, everyone wants to become an international icon than being capsized in any particular territory.

Today whole of the world have felt the vitality of universal brotherhood, that’s why many international social, political, religious and economical organizations are constituted to supervise the welfare

of the world and humanity.

In the field of entertainment , many foreigners have become the integral part of Bollywood films whereas many Indians performed in foreign tv serials and other places.

In sport , this interdependency can clearly be observed, the coaches and trainers are mostly foreigners. In IPL you may see how india has divided into many teams having many foreign players in

different sides. In many interviews of these players , how they enjoy the companionship of one another with diversified habits and cultures.

So I wonder how anyone can talk of mere patriotism in this age? Just sit aside and think what are you going to obtain and miss as a patriot and international citizen, the answer you will get by yourself.

Over emphasizing patriotism means we are again treading back to the age of brutality and duel, only fight all around to show ownership of particular territory and property. Do you want another world

war like situation? Are you not fed up of the immeasurable losses in two consecutive world wars. Don’t you realize that these world war have put indelible spot in the history of human beings?

I don’t understand what’s wrong in hugging universal brotherhood. It’s like the tree giving sweet fruits and

shades for other and preserves nothing for itself and like the rivers providing water for others not for itself.

Who can forget the historical moment not only in Indian history but the history of the world, when Swami Vivekanand powerfully

lectured in Newyork conference of religions in 1893.

I am confident with my side and firmly tell that its unstoppable natural force, no power can be hindrance in its way. It will prosper , prosper and prosper.

Side: yes

Universal Brotherhood promotes peace where Patriotism can promote war.

Side: yes
Atrag(5666) Disputed
1 point

Urg you cunt. I thought this was a recent debate. I was about this post. Wtf is your problem?

Side: no
1 point

if we think for a moment we should observe that Islam taught us that all men are brothers . if we only think about patriotism what about our other brothers? don't they deserve the same respect

Side: yes
1 point

when a country is attacked by foreigners then no doubt we have to save ourselves but if we have assistance of other countries it will be more easy to protect ourselves also less lives will be taken

Side: yes
1 point

i cant believe you were so helpless that u started taking your mothers help! but i didnt say that patriotism is not important i'm just saying universal brotherhood is more impotant.i dont understand why u still cant see the importance of universal brotherhood. just talking about mothers isn't gonna do anything ,.

Side: yes

Patriotism is more important because we desperately need some form of population control ;)

Side: No

Neither brotherhood or patriotism seem all that great, individualism is much more appealing, but patriotism is much more important because it unites a group of people with similar beliefs.

Side: No
casper3912(1581) Disputed
1 point

Isn't what is needed more than uniting a group of similar beliefs, is a way to unite people of dissimilar ones?

People of similar beliefs are more likely to get along and help each other develop positively(with in the confines of their beliefs), well people of dissimilar beliefs are more likely to not get along, but ultimately cause even greater development, perhaps in a negative/destructive fashion. The greater growth potential of disagreement is attractive, but it carries higher risks of destruction. A system which lowers that risk would allow for greater growth than one which reinforces similar beliefs.

Side: yes
1 point

Universal Brotherhood is Patriotism on a much larger scale. So no, it's not more important because it's just as idiotic as generic patriotism.

PrayerFails sort of had it right in that Individualism is the most important. Those who accept the system will only be slaves to those who created the system.

Side: No
1 point

I think patriotism is more important in my views if person cant have any feeling About his own motherland then what for they live there if everyone think bout one thing their thinking mathes then they have common brotherhood feeling so i think our nation comes first.both of these Attched with one Another. i love my nation .jai hind.

N MY OPINIAN A LOVE FOR THE COUNTRY A FEELING OF SACRIFICE FOR THE COUNTRY IS MUST IMPORTANT FOR THE TOTAL SOCIAL,ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT OF INDIA. SO TO SECURE THE FUTURE OF OUR COUNTRY PATRIODISM IS MUST IMPORTANT BECAUSE NO WILL COME TO SEE US WHEN WE WILL BE IN THREAT. BECAUSE OF UNIVERSAL BROTHERHOOD ONLY THE YOUTH OF OUR COUNTRY IS NOT OBEYING THEIR CULTURE AND BECAUSE OF THIS ONLY OUR COUNTRY HAD TO FACE THE IMPRISONMENT OF 200 YEARS

Side: No
1 point

For universal brotherhood, there should be brotherhood at country level! And in India, the there is not national brotherhood, and that can be achieved by patriotism, and universal brotherhood can only be useful if it occurs globally and that is definitely impossible!So patriotic way is better!

Side: No
1 point

WHENEVER A COUNTRY IS ATTACKED BY A FOREIGN COUNTRY, ALL IT'S MEN-WOMEN, OLD-CHILDREN, UNITE IN ORDER TO PROTECT THEIR COUNTRY. IT MEANS PATRIOTISM ONLY GIVES BIRTH TO BROTHERHOOD.AND I THINK THERE IS NO NEED OF TELLING THAT WHO IS MORE VALUABLE IN A CHILD AND A MOTHER ?????

Side: No
1 point

ya, i agree with those who say that patriotism is more valuable, because....... the first & the foremost thing is the nation....... in which u r presently living.... the nation that provided a place to live in..... is valuable.... take the case of ur mother, its the probable thing that you will support or think of ur mother first then of all other mothers........ just think over it guyzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: No