CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
2
Sensible Policy Not Sensible Policy
Debate Score:5
Arguments:2
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Sensible Policy (1)
 
 Not Sensible Policy (1)

Debate Creator

xMathFanx(1722) pic



University Policy on Sexual Violence

University Policy on Sexual Violence

Sensible Policy

Side Score: 3
VS.

Not Sensible Policy

Side Score: 2
3 points

University Policy on Sexual Violence

Standard US University Policy regarding 'sexual violence' of present typically is as follows:

(A) If a female is intoxicated and sexual activity occurs--proper consent was necessarily not given.

(B ) Proper consent is necessary for sexual activity, failure to meet such a standard would qualify as either Sexual Assault or Rape (depending upon specifically what occurred)

(C) If both the male and female are intoxicated while sexual activity occurred--only the male is guilty of Sexual Assault or Rape

(D) If the male is intoxicated and the female is sober (i.e. not intoxicated), than no Sexual Violence occurred

(E) 'Intoxication' for females may include level of alcohol intake of 1 beer or above

(F) Accusations of Sexual Violence are not required to be reported to the Police in order for the University to step in. That is, a female may report the incident to the particular department responsible for Sexual Violence at the University exclusively

(E) A University hearing/trial will occur, where typically a committee of Professors will be the 'jury' for the case, and hear both sides of the 'story'. i.e. the male and female will be given the opportunity to present their perspective, while teachers typically asks questions about the students Sexual history, ect. ect. in order to gain further insight into what may have occurred

(F) The committee will make a 'judgement', and, if found guilty, the student would be subject to suspension or dismissal

(E) If found 'not guilty', no punishment is enacted on the accuser

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you deem this policy sensible?

Side: Sensible Policy
2 points

University Policy on Sexual Violence

Standard US University Policy regarding 'sexual violence' of present typically is as follows:

(A) If a female is intoxicated and sexual activity occurs--proper consent was necessarily not given.

(B ) Proper consent is necessary for sexual activity, failure to meet such a standard would qualify as either Sexual Assault or Rape (depending upon specifically what occurred)

(C) If both the male and female are intoxicated while sexual activity occurred--only the male is guilty of Sexual Assault or Rape

(D) If the male is intoxicated and the female is sober (i.e. not intoxicated), than no Sexual Violence occurred

(E) 'Intoxication' for females may include level of alcohol intake of 1 beer or above

(F) Accusations of Sexual Violence are not required to be reported to the Police in order for the University to step in. That is, a female may report the incident to the particular department responsible for Sexual Violence at the University exclusively

(E) A University hearing/trial will occur, where typically a committee of Professors will be the 'jury' for the case, and hear both sides of the 'story'. i.e. the male and female will be given the opportunity to present their perspective, while teachers typically asks questions about the students Sexual history, ect. ect. in order to gain further insight into what may have occurred

(F) The committee will make a 'judgement', and, if found guilty, the student would be subject to suspension or dismissal

(E) If found 'not guilty', no punishment is enacted on the accuser

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you deem this policy sensible?

Side: Not Sensible Policy