CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
6
Agree Dissagree
Debate Score:8
Arguments:7
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Agree (2)
 
 Dissagree (5)

Debate Creator

Delta(1348) pic



Video games contribute to youth violence

Agree

Side Score: 2
VS.

Dissagree

Side Score: 6

Yes, because when they see all of the action in fighting games, it gets them all riled up and excited and when they see how awesome these things are, they want to get out and try it themselves. Specifically fighting games.

Side: Agree
1 point

I think so, if the game is violent in nature, kid are very impressionable.

Side: Agree
1 point

I don't really think it contributes to violence. It all depends on the game that you play and who the person is playing it. I know I have play violent video games but I am not a violent person.

Side: Dissagree

I don't really think it contributes to violence. It all depends on the game that you play and who the person is playing it. I know I have play violent video games but I am not a violent person.

Hey check it out....I'm agreeing with Srom!

Side: Dissagree
0 points

To clarify I'm agreeing with you, but I have to do this:

I don't really think it contributes to violence.

So far so good.

It all depends on the game that you play and who the person is playing it.

So if it depends on factors, regardless of what those factors are, then you are contradicting your opening statement. Your opening statement would be. "Yes, for some people it does and these are the factors."

I know I have play violent video games but I am not a violent person.

And this would be a descent example (despite that singular experiences are generally not a great supporting argument for any type of broad point). If you were to continue with "But for some with violent tendencies violent video games may contribute to acting out on those impulses."

This actually would have been and excellently stated argument on <--------- That side.

Had that been the case I'd have argued that simply:

1. I don't believe that media is a trigger for violence, but that violent people will become violent eventually based on one thing or another. Violent Amish would become so without video games, they may then in retrospect (or those around them may in retrospect) come up with some reasoning behind it, but I believe it would not change the end result.

2. Should it be the case that violence in any media truly did contribute to increased violence (I completely accept that as a possibility and should proof be provided I'd be forced to change my stance there) I still do not feel that a character flaw in some is reason enough to deprive a vast majority in this case.

Side: Dissagree
1 point

Propaganda. Mainly by FOX. If a child - or even an adult - is mentally well then no, a video game will not affect them. But if they have mental health issues it could definitely affect them.

Side: Dissagree
1 point

I don't believe it has anything to do with the video games. The problem is, you get idiotic parents who don't teach their children from right or wrong, and when the kids do something bad, they find a way to blame it on something else other then their inability to raise their children. I played violent games like Grand Theft Auto since I was 8 years old, my parents always told me what was right or wrong and I have never committed a crime in my life. Therefore the parents should grow a pair and realize their own faults....

Side: Dissagree