CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:10
Arguments:6
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 What are humans doing right? Wrong? (6)

Debate Creator

zombee(1026) pic



What are humans doing right? Wrong?

Think about the trends humanity has been following since the birth of the species until today: population growth, increased urbanization, advances in science and technology, globalization, and whatever else occurs to you. Consider all the positive and negative consequences of those.

 

In what arenas do you think humans are generally improving or maintaining? What aspects do you think are suffering or backsliding? If we continue the general trends of history, where will we  go?

Add New Argument
2 points

I believe people as a collective have fell to immorality. The principals that govern the nations have allowed people to become desensitized by constant showing of sex, drugs, foul language, mistreatment by parents, a complete lack of parenting and many other things. you can't look at a television and not see these things on free basic cable, it's on our computers and for so many in our hearts. so I believe humans are completely lacking in the department of showing our fellow man love and compassion. two very important fundamentals for a productive society as well as proper role models to guide our children which are our future.

2 points

In what arenas do you think humans are generally improving or maintaining? What aspects do you think are suffering or backsliding? If we continue the general trends of history, where will we go?

Since the end of the Dark Ages, humanity has continuously, but slowly, become more and more peaceful, less savage as a whole, and our technological capability has been getting exponentially better.

As for things that we suffer at, I believe it is our tendency to delude and fool ourselves. The fact that we can be consumed by classic sins like greed and wrath and such even today has led us to have poverty all over the world, a terrible economic system worldwide, and poorly defined ability to peaceably assemble.

On the last note, continue general threads of history? I don't really think we've been doing that. Every year since the end of the Dark Ages has consistently grown very slightly away from excessive violence, harm, and greed. The more our technological prosperity increases, the faster we continue to move away from the trends of the past.

All in all, I believe humanity is doing well in relation to our bloody history. One thing that gives me hope is the fact that nothing so far has drastically hindered our technological progress. It gives me lots of hope.

It gives me so much hope, that I'm actually an optimist over the idea that the Singularity is coming.

2 points

The trend that occurs to me is one of increasing use of recordings. Particularly those that are stored outside our bodies via symbolic expression. At some point early on we recognized that we could increase the scope and reliability of our memory by making markings to represent events we witnessed. This practice greatly affected our prowess as hunters and increased the accuracy of our ability to predict seasonal changes and can reasonably be considered a primary factor in our transition from hunter/gatherers to successful agriculturalists and farmers. It's foundational to civilization itself, I think. So many of our greatest achievements rely on our ability to communicate using symbols it's positively staggering.

Ironically as Goethe so eloquently noted there is no strength that cannot become a weakness (and fortunately vice versa). This truth is showing itself today in that we are facing a crises because we have forgotten how to cultivate things such as, curiosity, a deep reverence for life, playfulness and laughter, humility, or even a sense that our effort should be towards more important things than immediate comfort. We really really have an unhealthy aversion, ie. hate to admit a misunderstanding. holy crap it's late...if no one votes on this I'll edit and finish my response later. :)

symbolic communication

2 points

Ok let me try this again....

The first thing that popped into my mind was increasing use of recordings. Particularly those that are stored outside our bodies via symbolic expression. At some point early on we recognized that we could increase the scope and reliability of our memory by making markings to represent events we witnessed and ideas that occur to us. This practice greatly affected our ability to predict seasonal changes and can reasonably be considered a primary factor in our transition from hunter/gatherers to successful agriculturalists and farmers. It's foundational to civilization itself, I think (It's at the very least, greatly impacted science and religion). So many of our greatest achievements rely on our ability to create records and communicate using symbols it's positively staggering, but where we are going wrong with it can be summed up in one word. Bureaucracy.

People have been learning from one another via symbolic communication since the beginning of recorded history. The earliest record keepers secured for themselves great advantage over those whose ability to create, keep and accurately interpret records was underdeveloped by comparison. In the interests of preserving that advantage the practice of secrecy and hiding the truth began it's advance.

Over time a division between classes of people began to manifest itself, and the private information handed down within the literate class allowed them to firmly establish themselves in positions of authority (or for those clever enough, in positions protected by authority). In many cases the great thirst for understanding was substituted by a thirst for power over others and/or luxury and these instances became effective roadblocks to greater discoveries and the overall advancement of humanity. Today it's clear to many that when information is freely shared it has the opposite effect, but secrecy still very much has a strangle hold on humanity.

It's easy to stand in awe of our fabulous complex accomplishments, but with a simple shift in perception can see that humanity's achievements are as those of an idiot savant. We can map the human genome, Fly to the moon, create life saving vaccines, formulate compelling theories about the nature of reality, etc.. but as yet we can't figure out how to resolve our differences without killing a whole lot of poor people, we can't stop knowingly poisoning our environment, we can't overcome hate, we can't even feed ourselves.

Our pride is legendary and largely of an unhealthy sort. It turns our strengths into weaknesses. We act like it's a given that generations to follow will be able to take what we leave them and do something admirable with it, but unless we can show them how to value things worthy of valuing, all our great intellectual achievements , all our magnificence might disappear.

If we focus our attention more towards health matters, we can turn earth into a paradise, and we may have a chance at outliving this planet.

If I were to list what we're doing right...

We are learning that our wellness depends on the wellness of other living beings. We are transitioning from a culture of secrecy to one of openness. We are transitioning from an authoritative paradigm to a negotiative one. We are transitioning from a prideful posture to one of humility. We are learning the value of broader human dignity.

If I were to list what we're doing wrong...

We have placed comfort as our top priority. We are refusing to transition from a culture of secrecy to one of openness. We are refusing to transition from an authoritative paradigm to a negotiative one. We are refusing to transition from a prideful posture to one of humility. We view other classes of people as fundamentally superior/inferior.

I think the only limitations that are put on humans are the ones we put on ourselves. I think we are capable of knowing, doing and understanding everything and anything and perhaps we will someday. I don't think (as a whole)anything the human race does is either "wrong" or "right", "good" or "bad".

Technology is definitely something that humans are doing right. To be adversarial, nuclear weapons are something that humans are doing wrong.