CreateDebate


Debate Info

56
50
Religion Science
Debate Score:106
Arguments:65
Total Votes:108
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Religion (27)
 
 Science (33)

Debate Creator

Cuaroc(8829) pic



What causes more problems in the world Religion or Science?

Does Religion or Science cause more problems?

Religion

Side Score: 56
VS.

Science

Side Score: 50
7 points

Science fixes problems most of the time were Religion causes majority of wars and terrorism.

Side: Religion
Srom(12206) Clarified
2 points

Science doesn't fix every single problem. Some stuff in science has flaws in it like evolution. I could name the flaws in evoultion. Yes only the Islamic religion causes wars and terrorism

Side: Religion
BenWalters(1513) Disputed
5 points

Yes only the Islamic religion causes wars and terrorism

Do you honestly think that? What do you know of Islamic teachings, of why these people do these acts, of the history of other religions and violence?

Christianity has the crusades to its name, plane bombings, the LRA, and a number of other examples of wars or terrorism. No one's innocent.

Side: Science
Saurbaby(5581) Disputed
4 points

Science doesn't fix every single problem.

Yet. With time I'm sure it will continue to solve all our current problems. Of course, new problems will arise so there will always be problems though. It's just life.

Some stuff in science has flaws in it like evolution.

Evolution not agreeing with your religion, at least according to you, is not a flaw. And does any other part of Science have flaws? One example, that no one really agrees with, does not make a good argument.

Yes only the Islamic religion causes wars and terrorism

If you believe this then you should pay more attention in your history classes and learn something.

Side: Science
Facadeon(510) Disputed
3 points

Evolution Does have fact, though

I know I have posted this up before, but I put it up again because no one seemed to reply.

The argument is about how our bodies are self evidence of Evolution:

Here's the reasons why...

We get Goose Bumps, just like other animals when we and they are cold, frightened, angry or in awe.

Also, Humans have structures in their genetic make-up that were once used to produce enzymes to process vitamin C (it is called L-gulonolactone oxidase). Most other animals have this functioning DNA but at some point in our history, a mutation disabled the gene - whilst leaving remnants as junk DNA. This junk DNA indicates a common ancestry with other species on Earth.

We are also have auriculares muscles in our ears that are used by animals to swivel and manipulate their ears in order to focus their hearing, but humans still have these muscles that we would of once used for the very same reason, but now our ear muscles are feeble, and can only do a wiggle.

We also have a Plantaris Muscle that other animals use by gripping objects with their feet- which is something you could see apes doing using their feet and hands. Humans have this muscle to, but it is so underdeveloped that they are often taken out by doctors for other uses for reconstructing other parts of the body. This muscle is now so unimportant, that Evolution has made 9% of people so far to be born without it.

Aand also, early humans used to eat a lot of plants and they needed to eat them quickly enough to gain a sufficient amount of nutrition every day, for this reason, we had evolved extra teeth (Wisdom Teeth) to do so. But as Evolution made it's selections, our diet had changed, rendering these teeth useless.

Humans also used to have a third eye lid and another set of nostrils, but now there are only remnants left within the eye and nose. Our second pair of nostrils receded back inside the nose and our third transparent eyelids went quite small and non-working.

And also, we have a particular bone in the lower part of the human body called the "Coccyx," and the Coccyx was in fact, a remnant of what was once a human tail. Over time, and with evolution, we lost the need for a tail and had begun walking on ground instead of swinging through trees. But humans haven't lost the need of a Coccyx, because we know use it to support structure for various muscles to support a person when sitting or leaning back.

And lastly, the appendix- it has no use to modern humans and is often removed when it becomes infected, but in the past, it was evolved when we needed it to help procese the cellulose in our once, leaf-rich diet.

And one more thing, our little toe will actually vanish in the future, for future humans, as it has almost no use. It's already being evolved out of us right now. >_>

Side: Science
ChuckHades(3197) Disputed
1 point

Some stuff in science has flaws in it like evolution. I could name the flaws in evoultion.

Go on then. Name them.

Yes only the Islamic religion causes wars and terrorism

If I was a Muslim that didn't already know how ignorant you were, I'd take that as slander. I know you don't know anything about history, but please do research before you open your mouth.

I take it you've never heard of the Crusades? Or the inquisitions? Or the destruction of Paganism? Or the Irish conflicts? Or the witch hunts?

To name a few...

Side: Science
Cuaroc(8829) Disputed
1 point

Science doesn't fix every single problem.

I never said it did all I said is most of the time it fixes problems.

Side: Science
Facadeon(510) Disputed
1 point

1. Islam is a part of Religion. (It has a large part in fact, and Islam is not the only religion that causes wars and terrorism [Yes, Christianity does it too] know your facts dude.)

2. Science will actually save the whole human race. You know spaceships and teleporters- that's what science can give us. Since our Sun is dying, and we will all die with it, technology will move us out of Earth through space travel, so we can populate other worlds.

3. Evolution has fact. We have wisdom teeth, remnants of third eyeballs and forth nostrils, tails and wasteful appendixes that came with Evolution- as said in the theory of "Stupid Design."

Read these:

http://listverse.com/2008/02/19/top-15-misconceptions-about-evolution/

http://listverse.com/2009/01/05/top-10-signs-of-evolution-in-modern-man/

That's right, I'm a fan of reading Listverse. :D

Side: Science
6 points

I am outraged by this debate!

Science does not cause problems. It cannot, as by its very nature, science solves problems.

How one can consider knowledge to be generally harmful is beyond me. If the creator of this debate means the socio-political ramifications of scientific knowledge, that cannot be attributed to science itself.

PFFT! Science harmful.... -shakes head-

Side: Religion
1 point

Actually I was thinking the same and was going to post religion but I think the point the fellow was trying to make was stuff like weapons and nuclear bombs. I have not taken sides yet actually.

Side: Science
Facadeon(510) Clarified
3 points

There's no denying that science will eventually save the human race from extinction though.

Because what can we do to survive when the sun dies?

Science is the only answer. Within a span of a few billion years, we would already have time to leave this planet- and leave this solar system, to populate other worlds, and science is gonna get us there.

Side: Religion
4 points

Medicine.

Have you heard of the bubonic plague?

How about small pox?

The bubonic plague killed two thirds of the European population, and it is still around today. But thanks to science, that won't happen again. Same with small pox and all the other big viruses.

Also, it is a well known fact that the Sun won't be hanging around for all of eternity- it's gonna die in a billion years or so, and we humans are gonna suffer from it- as in, we are all gonna die and the human race will cease to exist.

But, there is hope.

With science, we can create and invent ways to cope with this. We could use space travel to populate other worlds, possibly find a way to keep the sun alive. Within a period of time of a billion years, the human race would of already achieved and advanced so much that we would be safe and well away when the sun finally dies. We would of mastered the galaxy- met other alien races. We could be on top of the universe with science.

That's the thing about science- it could actually save all of mankind from extinction.

It's just that sometimes, religion doesn't help.

Side: Religion
3 points

Religion is just blind faith and hope

Science is just cold hearted truth

Both suck.

But I think religion promotes more hate filled killing than science.

Science and progress has made us so lazy and made us take everything for granted. But I know I owe science a great deal of respect when compared to religion.

Side: Religion
2 points

This is equivalent to asking:

"Which hurts more? A chainsaw to the testicles, or a cuddle?"

I don't even think I need to explain it.

Side: Religion
3 points

A chainsaw to the testicles

More like an arrow to the knee...

Side: Religion

A cuddle XD Those testicles do not have to be attached.

Side: Religion
2 points

Is there really even a question about this? Even a religious person would have to agree... unless they're so whacked they're beyond help.

Side: Religion
2 points

Everyone thinks that they're god or whatever is the one that exists and it makes other religions mad and want to argue. Therefore, nuclear missiles are pointed down each other's throats. Science on the other hand is universal and cannot be debated

Side: Religion
2 points

Ha! This is absolutely a no brainer. Religion! Why? What wars have been created over Science? How many people, in the name of science have died in comparison to that of religion? Ever since the dawn of mankind people have been dying for, and because of religion. Religion is the most corrupt, problamatic thing on this earth, if you ask me... although this isn't just a matter of opinion here, there are numbers to prove it.

Side: Religion
2 points

I'm pretty sure this view has popped up more than once in this debate segment. I believe that Religion has caused more wars and more separation between individuals than Science. Science is also a belief system but it is a lot more private and reserved. People are prideful of their religion and therefore it is visible and in clear view of people who can disagree with it. I actually witness a very defining argument of religion between two people in a public area. This person was pushed and shoved because of his belief and it caused a whole disturbance in the areas surrounding. Not to mention we are a lot more judgmental of others when it comes to religion. We believe that our religion is the right one, and therefore grow a sort of hierarchy towards it. It's no hesitation in these factors when it comes to my views.

Side: Religion

Science might build a gun or a bomb, but it's religion that convinces you to take it up and use it against your fellow man. In gods name, of course.

Side: Religion
1 point

You mean extremism? Most religions with extremists condemn the acts of the extremism.

Side: Science
1 point

But not all religions condemn extremism and extremists can find valid support for their beliefs in scripture and religious teachings. That'll make them religious extremists, then. Don't see how this does anything to nullify my point.

Side: Religion

I can't recall a war every being fought over science.

Side: Religion
1 point

Religion has cause a lot more wars and mass genocide than Science has. That shouldn't even be a debate.

Side: Religion
2 points

Science has changed the world massively over the last few thousand years. It's advanced society in almost every way that anything's been advanced. It's helped every single person in the world.

But, without it, we'd still be a primitive race, and have a tiny, backward population. Life would be much, much worse, but there would be much less problems than is currently faced by the 7 billion people of today.

Obviously, there would be much much less benefits (both in real and relative terms), but this debate isn't over which has helped more, just what's caused more problems.

Side: Science
Huzaifa(3) Disputed
2 points

Technology is indirectly responsible for the meaningless lives we are living today. We forget about caring for our peers and are just engrossed in materialistic things. I sometimes feel that we have lost some of the pleasures of life that technology can’t easily replace.

Side: Religion
ChuckHades(3197) Disputed
2 points

Uhh.... why are you on this side then ?

Side: Religion
BenWalters(1513) Clarified
1 point

I believe that science has caused more benefits, and more problems. Religion has caused a higher ratio of problems to benefits, but both to a lesser degree. However, it's simply asking what has caused more problems.

Side: Religion
2 points

Science created the atomic bomb, the deadliest weapon in the world.

Side: Science
Cuaroc(8829) Disputed
2 points

But the atomic bomb was devoloped to help end World War two.

Side: Religion
Troy8(2433) Disputed
2 points

Yes but it still caused the cold war and various other nuclear weapon problems.

Side: Science
2 points

With science, you can blow stuff up. Religon can only create mobs.

Side: Science
1 point

I would also like to point the the delusion that religion is the problem in the world. Religion is supposed to teach us caring, loving for others and inner self reflection. So we ask why it causes problems in the world? It is in fact the cause of exploitation of religion that is causing problems. I think people should not make blunt comments on any matter without looking at it at different perspectives.

Side: Science
1 point

Well religion has caused religious leaders in the past to kill off those who didn't share the faith, sacrifices, genocides practically. Science has created technology thats created bombs, guns, tactical weapons, and genocide as well. However religion has healed broken hearts, turned peoples lifes around, fed the poor. Science has given people a way to breathe, gave them a heart beat, faster communication for more efficent and rapid emergency responses. Neither one of them causes more problems than the other as they dont solve problems any more than the other. The fact is they both have relatively equal effects on society on both pros and cons.

Side: Science
1 point

Science and Religion are not that different in terms of forces in our world. Both of them consistently do huge amounts of good to make human life better. However, they are also both used by unscrupulous people to take advantage of others and gain power.

Since the first man tied a rock to a stick science has been used to kill people. Religion has not been that different.

Bottom line... tools are only as good or evil as the person who wields it.

Side: Science
1 point

Science has caused a lot of troubles too. We can obviously think to the atomic bomb which is can still destroy the entire planet but paradoxically we have never felt so powerful thanks to the knowledge, the science. Because of this feeling of power (which is in my opinion fake) we don't hesitate to behave as if no one could punish us, and maybe become more and more violent (the XXth century became more and more atheist and though it was extremely violent and deadly).

Side: Science