CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
13
Black world White world
Debate Score:19
Arguments:17
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Black world (4)
 
 White world (7)

Debate Creator

minimurph83(194) pic



What if blacks and whites never met

Where would black people be if our worlds never came together?

Would the black world be just advanced as the white world?

Black world

Side Score: 6
VS.

White world

Side Score: 13
2 points

I guess that if you look at the parts of Africa where there has been a limited exposure to European (white) influence you would see how things would be.

Side: Black world

I think they would still be in the hunter and gatherer stage like many are today.

------------------------------------------------------------------

Side: Black world
1 point

There is no "black world" nor "white world." In the whole history of humans, blacks and whites were present together at the same time. God made us equal. "We were able to enslave the black people and take advantage of the resources that surrounded them which they failed to do." True but, it was probably because the whites were more populated.

Side: Black world
Saintnow(3684) Clarified Banned
1 point

What would we do without Oreo cookies? This is an unimaginable darkness on the earth.

Side: Black world
minimurph83(194) Disputed
1 point

We are and were more intelligent, and I'm speaking hypothetically, and we were not made by god or equal!

Side: White world
smilinbobs(590) Disputed
1 point

Let's be honest about history most black slaves were captured and enslaved by other black tribes. They would have been slaves or killed any way by enemy black tribes.

Side: White world
1 point

What would we do without Oreo cookies? This is an unimaginable darkness on the earth.

Side: Black world
Grenache(6053) Disputed
1 point

I was about to stick up for you and say you shouldn't have been banned for your comment. But then I saw you cut and pasted the exact same thing in two places under the same chain (which I've seen you do before) which in fact proves it wasn't an actual argument but a deliberate attempt at disruption.

I still wouldn't have banned you myself, but the moderator had more right to on this debate than you yourself have demonstrated in your bans.

Side: White world
minimurph83(194) Clarified
2 points

I only banned saintnow because he has a bad habit of banning me when he loses an argument, and his input was childish.

Side: Black world
3 points

I feel if our worlds never came together the blacks would be far less advanced than the white world, the only reason blacks have achieved anything is because they have been given a platform in a white formed world.

We were far more advanced, hence the reason we were able to enslave the black people and take advantage of the resources that surrounded them which they failed to do.

Side: White world

To the sane and realistic that is a rhetorical question as we all know that if the scenario to which you refer was factual the blacks, if they survived mother nature's ''NATURAL SELECTION'' process, would still be running around fighting each other with spears and clubs whilst negotiating the waterways of Africa in dugout canoes. Almost every discovery or invention made for the benefit and advancement of mankind has been by whites. A brief summery of these inventions include, the computer, the internet, the radio, television, the telephone, radar, X-rays, the telescope, the microscope, spectacles, the internal combustion engine, the diesel engine, the jet engine, motorised transport, the aeroplane, space going rockets, modern building techniques and materials, ocean going liners, submarines, penicillin, anesthetics almost all life saving and pain relieving drugs, surgical operating procedures, effective forms of government including national health services, national defence, state education and so forth. the list is endless. Had the backward black boys been denied access to all of the aforementioned as well as not being able to point their begging bowls westward to the whiteman's advanced societies and nature's ''NATURAL SELECTION'' had been allowed to run it's course the blacks would almost certainly be an extinct species.

Side: White world
minimurph83(194) Clarified
2 points

Blacks come from the most mineral rich country on the planet Africa but failed to utilise what was around them, yet the white race is to blame for inequality and why blacks have suffered, only the inferior are in a position to suffer.

Your argument was very well put Winklepicker!

Side: Black world
1 point

This is all hypothetical, of course.

If you lump the knowledge and skills of the North Africans in, including the Egyptians and the Moors, then I think the Black isolated world would be well advanced in mathematics, astronomy, sailing, masonry, farming, and government. And that's not bad. But the White isolated world also would have all those things I just listed and you could add to it the world of science. I think the edge would still go to the Whites. Probably the only drawback is both our music and dancing would be waaaayyyyy lamer.

But I agree with others who stated there really is just one race anyway, the human race, and also that mixed races have ALWAYS existed together.

Side: White world
minimurph83(194) Clarified
2 points

There has been some advanced society's in north Africa, but they failed to thrive and advance, due to being inbreeded (Egyptians) tribalistic nature, and corruption, where as the white North advanced steadily and prosperously.

Side: Black world
Winklepicker(1021) Clarified
1 point

What were all those things YOU just listed? I'm not sure if you're referring to my list as being hypothetical, but if you are may I point out that there is nothing hypothetical about the list of factual inventions/ discoveries made by white men. The Egyptian civilization was one of the greatest of all times and was well advanced in mathematics and construction, ( the building of the pyramids) but ran out of steam before being able to impart their knowledge to other nations as the Romans and Greek civilizations did. For instance we still don't know for sure how the ancient Egyptians built the Pyramids. I would strongly disagree about there being only one race. Multiculturalism simply doesn't work, ( Angela merkel and David Cameron both stated this glaring truth independently of each other 2/3 years ago, although everyone including the dogs in the street knew this 60 years ago) ) and where the races are bunched together, continues to cause violent and indeed deadly civil disorder. Africa remains largely a backward continent of a bunch of underdeveloped, almost retarded nations hopelessly trying to achieve the impossible goal of living as intellectual equals in the world of whiteman's of technology. The black-man's music is primitive and doesn't compare in anyway with the works of the great masters such as Bach,Verdi, Mozart, Wagner, Rossini, Beethoven and endless others. Their bongo drums are eclipsed by sophisticated western instruments such as the piano, the violin, the viola, the cello, the glockenspiel, the French horn, and even the humble mouth organ. No, left to fend for themselves ''THE BONGO''would have perished generations ago and would be viewed with amusement by students of anthropology.

Side: Black world
Grenache(6053) Clarified
2 points

Calm down. I just meant the "if blacks and whites never met" is hypothetical. Geez.

Hey, we voted on the same side. I just don't score Black society as low as you did.

Side: Black world