CreateDebate


Debate Info

17
8
A planet. A plutoid.
Debate Score:25
Arguments:15
Total Votes:37
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 A planet. (8)
 
 A plutoid. (7)

Debate Creator

Tamisan(890) pic



What is Pluto?

Are there 8 planets or 9?

Two years ago, Pluto was demoted. Our solar system was declared as only having EIGHT actual planets and numerous "plutoids" or "trans-Neptunian dwarf planet" or "dwarf planet." To this day, experts cannot agree. How do you feel about this conundrum?

Pluto Debate (www.livescience.com)

A planet.

Side Score: 17
VS.

A plutoid.

Side Score: 8

Pluto is still considered a planet albeit a "Dwarf Planet" along with Ceres, an Asteroid which was also reclassified and Eris which was labeled a "scattered disk object" which, in some ways resembles an Asteroid belt. The term Dwarf Planet is a bit of a misnomer since these are not a "subset" of Planets themselves but in a different category altogether. Scientists are still debating the differences and definitions of a Plutoid, Dwarf Planet and Planet!

Side: Pluto is a Dwarf Planet
2 points

Pluto is a Disney character!

It has been a planet for years and years...so, all of a sudden it isn't a planet???

What is that all about?

I think it is still a planet.

Who knows what is making it have a different orbit. It could be heavier on one side...could have been hit by asteroids who knows what goes on out there. We have not seen it all.

Earth is very lucky, that it has been a long time since it has been really hit.

~Sharon~

The Baby Boomer Queen

Side: drawf or not it is a planet

I don't want to hurt Pluto's feelings.

Having said that, what the difference between a mountain and hill? A rock, a boulder and a pebble? I mean, at what point do they stop being one and become the other?

Side: A planet.
2 points

yes, pluto is, as we define a planet now, too small. however, it is of historic importance and i think affection to leave pluto as the smallest planet. if we wish to add new objects as other small planets, such as charon, that causes no problems.

let's leave pluto a bit of dignity! :P

Side: drawf or not it is a planet
pvtNobody(645) Disputed
1 point

They named dwarf planets after it! Think of the terms "plutoid" and "plutonium" as a severance package. Suddenly Pluto is more than the smallest planet, it's foremost among the plutoids.

Side: A plutoid.
2 points

Once a planet, always a planet.

Thats my philosify for everything. ...for everything .......

Side: A planet.
1 point

Pluto was discovered in 1930 by an astronomer from the United States. An astronomer is a person who studies stars and other objects in space.

We are one the best cheap web hosting service in world. Please try my website: http://www.webicalsolutions.com/virtual-web-hosting.html

Side: A planet.
2 points

In 2006, the International Astronomical Union (IAU) issued a formal definition of planet, one that led to Pluto's boot from planethood.

The IAU provided three criteria an object must meet to reach planet status:

A planet is a celestial body that

1. It orbits around the sun.

2. It has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape, and

3. It has cleared the neighborhood around its orbit.

Supporting Evidence: The Storied History of the Word 'Planet' (www.space.com)
Side: IAU definition
1 point

Pluto is a dwarf planet, not a planet. It seems that there is not much of a difference, but astronomically speaking, there is. Pluto is too small to be a planet. Charon, it's moon, is gravitationally locked to the dwarf planet. This means that the same sides face each other all the time.

Side: A plutoid.

He's a Disney character, duh!

Side: A plutoid.
-1 points

Sure, Pluto's really a planet if theser are really people.

Side: dwarf
-1 points

Wow, voted down for that one? Someone's out to get me I think. Anyway more little people. -why Pluto should be a planet.

Side: little people
-3 points
altarion(1955) Disputed
2 points

So just because Pluto decides to be a little different from the rest of the solar system and not conform to the other planet's orbital ways it doesn't get to be a planet? That is low!

Side: ROFLMFAO
0 points

It is ture though too. a comet is a dirty snowball. last I checked Plut was described as such too.

Side: comet