CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:84
Arguments:29
Total Votes:94
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 What is the best type of Girl Scout cookie? (29)

Debate Creator

DebateMan(471) pic



What is the best type of Girl Scout cookie?

Inquiring minds want to know
Add New Argument
6 points
Thin Mints are proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.
5 points

HECK YES thin mints are DANK ! c[x

tagalongs are pretty good too, but then again so is a reeses cup.

3 points
Thin mints all the way. All the delicious minty goodness sandwiched between layers of velvety chocolate.
2 points
Thin Mints by a mile according to this source:
Supporting Evidence: From Girl Scouts of America (www.infoplease.com)
jeff(48) Disputed
2 points
That is not by "a mile"! 25% to 19% for Samoas? Also that data source is from 2005. Although Thin Mints out of the freezer vs. samoas at room-temp, that's a tougher decision.
1 point
That is correct. Thin Mints dominate!
5 points
Somoas..... they are pretty much heaven!!
3 points
I concur. The mixture of the chewy coconut with caramel and the crunchy cookie covered in chocolate is perfecto!
1 point
UH, SAMOAS! I would die for that recipe. Tag-a-longs are a close second, because chocolate and peanut butter dominate together. Thin mints get my bronze medal.
KLRPILR(41) Disputed
-2 points
5 points
I bought three boxes this weekend (Thin Mints, Do-Si-Dos & Tagalongs). After trying all of them I must say that the Tagalongs were the best. Here are my findings... Thin Mints: Although these are the common favorite, they don't compare to their delicious cousin, The Grasshopper. Do-Si-Dos: These are filled with the great taste of Peanut Butter, but they are dryer than the Arizona desert in July. If you don't accompany these cookies with a glass of milk, you are in for a world of hurt. Tagalongs: These delectable little treats combine Peanut Butter and Chocolate with a tasty cookie crunch. These are the best of the three by far. Here is a description direct from the website. "Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties: These are round cookies with a layer of peanut butter on top, and covered in chocolate. These cookies come in a red box. Little Brownie Bakers calls them Tagalongs" For more information visit: http://www.girlscoutcookies.org/
Time2Golf(288) Disputed
3 points
Tagalongs are a homeless man's version of a Reese's Peanut Butter cup. Why have this POS cookie when you can go to a grocery store and pickup a Reese's cup whenever you want?
2 points
James, I had some Tagalongs last night and agree that the peanut butter/chocolate combo is delicious. But I still think Samoas are the best.
2 points
I love tagalongs. I usually buy more Thin Mints than any other kind of cookie because those tend to be the favorite if I bring them to my office. However, the peanut butter and chocolate is a much more decadent combination than mint and chocolate. Still, my toss-up would be between Tagalongs and Samoas for the best. The only problem with Samoas is that the caramel and coconut get stuck in your teeth.
3 points
Further proof: I just put out a box of tagalongs in my office kitchen less than an hour ago and they are completely gone.
1 point
I must be dumb...which one is a tagalong?
1 point
For more infomation on cookie type and description visit: http://www.girlscoutsaz.org/site/c.kkI1KgMZIxF/b.894993/
4 points

SAMOAS for sure!!!

2 points
Samoas are the best thing ever!
2 points
Samoas #1 Stunna, try all the ice creams and tell me otherwise. Find them at your local grocery.
2 points
While Thin Mints are the OG of the girl scout cookies, the Somoa put in work and has become the new Kingpin. Bow down...
7 points
Samoas, and here's why: Girl Scout cookies are a once a year treat. As spoken of above, the thin mint is a lesser version of the grasshopper that you can get all year round. The Tagalong, though second in my book is oh so similar yet lacking in comparison to any and all reeses products. This leaves the Samoa coming through as the once a year perfection of heavenly flavors
Supporting Evidence: Reeses Products (www.hersheys.com)
2 points
I could not agree more Katie...well said. Now all i can think about is having a girl scout cookie.
1 point
I could not agree more Katie...well said. Now all i can think about is having a girl scout cookie.
Hells yah. Points for you.
1 point
Great argument Katie! I completely agree... I could eat a whole box of Samoas, although that wouldn't be good for the biggest loser competition.
2 points

Samoas for sure, Hey, it's unique, gotta love that. Delicious Stuff, Too.

I eat mints all the time. I don't get the big deal with 'em.

2 points

Definitely samoas. It's pretty lame though because a different company makes the Girl Scout cookies now so they had to change the name =(