CreateDebate


Debate Info

12
41
The O'reilly Factor The Colbert Report
Debate Score:53
Arguments:16
Total Votes:65
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 The O'reilly Factor (2)
 
 The Colbert Report (14)

Debate Creator

RevFred(351) pic



What is the better source for news?

The O'reilly Factor

Side Score: 12
VS.

The Colbert Report

Side Score: 41
3 points

Come on Colbert tells anything with a punchline not really caring about the story.Oreilly does give both sides of normal stories.Some stories are to stupid to even here the "other side" of the debate.

Side: The O'reilly Factor
RevFred(351) Disputed
1 point

1. Colbert only adds punchlines to current news stories.

2. There is no evidence to believe Colbert doesn't care about his stories.

3. How stupid the other side of the argument is, should be for the audience to decide. Bill constantly yells over the other side of the argument. Colbert acts as if he's for one side of the argument, while pointing out aspects that he truly agrees with.

Side: The Colbert Report
2 points

The Colbert Report is a comedy show, while whether one agrees with bill orielly or not, it's an actual news program.

Side: The O'reilly Factor
RevFred(351) Disputed
1 point

Yea, those are their labels. But, which one is the better source for news was the question. It's based purely on opinion. I, personally, would rather get all the news that mattered most to me from colbert. I don't care about O'Riellys topics.

Side: The Colbert Report
4 points

Based purely on how much I care about the subjects they bring up, I would say the Colbert Report. 90% of the issues Bill brings up are wastes of my time. If wanted to know how the latest white girl to get kidnapped is doing, I would go down to the basement and ask them.

Side: The Colbert Report
4 points

Not only is Colbert one of the funniest people to ever walk the planet, but he also makes you think on another level. His antics are so off the wall that you end up thinking about the news story that he brings up. O'Reilly is just a bully that pushes people around until they agree with him. Plus I don't trust anyone that is actually a part of the press. See this debate for more on that topic.

Colbert's O'Reilly rant
Side: The Colbert Report

Somehow Colbert ends up being the more objective of the two.

Side: The Colbert Report
2 points

Proof of how much traditional news has digressed into entertainment, when entertainment contains more news.

Side: The Colbert Report

Don't forget propaganda... Entertaining propaganda.

Side: The Colbert Report
1 point

Probably because his points of view are so satirical that no rational person would accept them as their own, which forces them to actually think about the issue.

Side: The Colbert Report
2 points

With the Colbert Report, I am informed and entertained, while O'Reilly's show tends to be manipulative and biased, and whenever someone opposes Bill, the guest and Bill just start screaming at each other.

Side: The Colbert Report
2 points

That sums it up.

Side: The Colbert Report
2 points

DO IT LIVE.

Bill O'Reilly is too excitable and extremely biased. Colbert has the best poker face in the Entertainment business, and his take on the daily news is always fresh.

Side: The Colbert Report