CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:92
Arguments:55
Total Votes:94
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 What punishment does a man deserve who rapes a lady?! (55)

Debate Creator

92nida(1411) pic



What punishment does a man deserve who rapes a lady?!

To sexually abuse a Woman is the most pathetic act a human body part plays, to tear her down completely of the choice she has a right to make.

If men just had such uncontrollable urges.. They might as well pay for sex! Forced sex is undisputably the worst ever Sin! 

And the law has to pay them right!

Add New Argument
6 points

Rape is usually not about the sex, it's about control. But as for the punishment he should spend many years in prison and have his balls squeezed in a vice grip three times a day.

5 points

LOL! Well I can't top that so I won't even try !

2 points

That or castration, or lock him up where Bubba can do the same to him as he did to the woman.

4 points

Now that would make more sense to me "castration" .

2 points

Well then, Bubba needs to control him often in prison. LOL.

Banana_Slug(845) Disputed
1 point

In Islamic Countries it's pretty common hobby and it's questionable how much should be the raped women punished :D

4 points

Put him through the most agonizing experience of his life before castrating him and laughing along with his victims as he chokes on his own cock. Just before he dies, shove a rifle up his ass and fire at the very last second and the last thing he sees will be his victims looking down at him, laughing victoriously :) Gosh, did I really just write that? Wow, I must be posessed or something.

2 points

hahahahahahahahahaha you read my thoughts, you cheater .

2 points

Nah, its just that great minds think alike ;) Serves him right the bastard .

2 points

Bwhahaha! Works for me! great post Billie !

92nida(1411) Disputed
1 point

I dunno if your were possessed.. But,what you were is 'Right.' A man ought to taste that element of his body which he has used to satisfy his sexual desire.

garry77777(1796) Disputed
1 point

i think killing a man for commiting rape is too much. I admit he should punished but the laws we have are enough. I barely condone the death penalty for sexual abuse of children, let alone the rape of a fully grown woman who has a much better chance of recovering.

3 points

I say if a man decides they want to rape a woman and take away her rights of consentual sex then, the state should get the man caturated and take away their rites of pleasure. If they're going to invade a woman's body, then they shouldn't be allowed to use "it" at all.

Let them free, minus their penis. I'm sure that will convince rapists to keep it to themselves.

3 points

Let me start by saying I don't condone rape. Just let start with that.

I think the man should be sent to therapy, a man who doesn't have self-control to not do it needs HELP. He should do prison for awhile and be monitored after, but these men need help more than punishment.

2 points

After reading post after post that said something along the lines of "screw him in the worst way I can think of", it was very refreshing to see someone show compassion, not only for the victim but also for the offender.

It's very hard to figure out how to humanely deal with criminals while still effectively preventing crime, and I really can't say how well your suggestion of prison + therapy might work. But I see it as at least a step in the right direction.

1 point

It's true though. I've never been close to these people, offender or victim, but I can't see why they should be so strongly punishment for something they can't help. Especially those who start an early interest and no one is paying enough attention to help them before they go through with it.

I agree with this very strongly, in our society there should be a level of compassion and understanding for people who have problems, and if someone rapes hes clearly got problems, i admit some people are sick (e.g. repeat offenders) and need to be kept locked up. After reading some of the extreme comments on this page i was very happy to find yours, as usual you demonstrate a capacity for understanding well beyond your years.

92nida(1411) Disputed
1 point

Rapes... Like you said are not in the shades of white and black only. The context severely differs. Not just from person to person, but also from one culture to another. Rape can have extreme results such as Suicide in certain cultures. In U.S maybe, a lady can walk with not as much of a difference. And the man committing this crime is most often well aware of the aftereffects. Similarly.. There might be certain rapist in the society who face difficulties of such kind. Mental issues or family ethics.. A lot. But, not all Men face such issues. They are well informed. It is only how one loses their self control of which they are completely in charge. Yes, compassion is essential. But, you cannot walk on it. Because a lot of them take this for an excuse. Rape is sometimes used as a weapon to get back on an offense made by a girl.

1 point

This made me laugh, because you usually seem to not believe me.

Thank you.

92nida(1411) Disputed
1 point

That is a beautiful approach. You are right that such men ought to be mentored. But, if we are just talking about a young boy, a little guy just venturing into puberty. He,definitely with no argument is in need of a lot of help. But,men? Married Men or grown up matured adults perform something so dirty. In spite of complete knowledge of it's results they cannot just be forgiven and said you need therapy. Yes they do. But as Sane human beings they have to realize the mistake. And your probably not informed about the unreported rapes because Men just use woman.. Throw them into the garbage, kill them and lead a normal life. Most of the Men are well aware of what they are doing.

Saurbaby(5581) Disputed
1 point

That's not true. These men with problems can have completely normal lives. They have problems, but they are well aware that if they live how they want to then they will be made outcasts. So they hide it as much as possible. They don't have the self-control to stop their insane urges, but they have the sense to hide it as much as possible to seem normal.

2 points

if a man rapes a lady, there is a possible chance that they can do it again. That is why i believe that they deserve to go to jail. If it was 100 percent possible that they wouldn't do it again, then don't put them in jail.

I don't care for justice because that is crap. It is wrong to put someone is jail for a long time. Nobody has the right to ruin someone life like that. And that does not mean i support rapists.

I hate how people say "let them go to jail and get raped." I think that is wrong and satanic to say. I guess i see the good in all people. I want to help everybody including the ciminal.

I think God would do it too. :) Life was meant to be happy. That is what God intended. I know that without unhappiness, there is no happiness. That does make sense on some level. But isn't that life better than this.

I want to die and go to heaven. But i am going to let life kill him, instead of my own actions. :) Death is looking more beautiful everyday.

Billie(790) Disputed
4 points

if a man rapes a lady, there is a possible chance that they can do it again. That is why i believe that they deserve to go to jail. If it was 100 percent possible that they wouldn't do it again, then don't put them in jail.

If they don't serve time, what is their punishment to be? Roam the streets again? How will you know that they won't rape again, it is very easy for him to say "sure, I realize it was wrong and I won't do it again" but he is most likely going to out there and repeat the act again knowing he will get away with it. They need a punishment and a sense of right and wrong and to be kept off the streets.

I don't care for justice because that is crap. It is wrong to put someone is jail for a long time. Nobody has the right to ruin someone life like that. And that does not mean i support rapists.

Jail is not ruining someones life if they have already raped/murdered and ruined someone Else's life plus their family and friends.

I hate how people say "let them go to jail and get raped." I think that is wrong and satanic to say. I guess i see the good in all people. I want to help everybody including the ciminal.

I know that sounds awful, and I don't agree with people that say that. Although, if it was the rape victim saying that, I would not dare to shut her up as she has that right due to what he has done to her and her life. The fact that you see good in all people has some definite positives and is something that many are unable to do, including myself. But I do think that you need to have a greater understanding of the evil that exists in the minds of rapists, child molesters, pedophiles and the likes. You cannot say that these people are all good; they have streaks of evil in them that cannot be passed by unnoticed. There are programmes that aim to help/cure pedophiles, rapists etc which is often part of their prison sentence - this sounds like something you would excel in and not many people can manage this kind of work but you sound like a perfect candidate.

I think God would do it too. :) Life was meant to be happy. That is what God intended. I know that without unhappiness, there is no happiness. That does make sense on some level. But isn't that life better than this.

I am not sure what you are referring to exactly when you state that "God would do it too", so please do elaborate if you respond to this.

I want to die and go to heaven. But i am going to let life kill him, instead of my own actions. :) Death is looking more beautiful everyday.

I know what its like to want to pass on, but I am not sure who you are referring to when you say "I am going to let life kill him"? Why is death looking more beautiful every day?

92nida(1411) Disputed
1 point

If a man rapes a lady.. All he is doing is invading into that part of her body that she likes to save for someone she believes in. He forces his way, emotionless trying to satisfy his thirst. There is no 100 percent guarantee available that he wont do it again. When an ordinary man with a normal life with a completely stable brain is raping a girl what explanation does he have to defend himself?! He has ruined a life and a person's Right. Showered her with emotional distress.. And he ought to be punished. I understand.. Your reference to 'Everyone makes mistakes'.. And I agree that every human being is born with good as well as bad instincts. But, he let the bad over power.. ''So we are going to appreciate him for all the good that he has done, we will applaud him for it even give him a standing ovation.. But, we will pay him for his wrongs and make him realize.. make him feel the guilt for the injustice he did so thoughtlessly on that girl.''*

If life is meant to be happy.. Lets not forget the girls side of the story.

I really appreciate your chivalric approach towards this. but not every one has the greatness of God. So I'm gonna be a human. Hate him. And punish him.

Billie(790) Disputed
2 points

I really appreciate your chivalric approach towards this. but not every one has the greatness of God. So I'm gonna be a human. Hate him. And punish him.

Whilst I agree with the rest of your post, this I disagree with. He does not have the "greatness of God". He is just another of those people who support evil things then excuse them by saying it is what God would want - this is something that I despise. If he truly "had the greatness of God", he would have read at least a page of the bible and would not be in agreement with incest, rape and child molestation. Believe me, he does not have God in his heart, believe me on that one.

P.S. thanks for the ally request, I will accept.

2 points

he should b half buried in land and his nails should b plugged from his hand he should have a horrible death

92nida(1411) Disputed
1 point

Thanks Bozo! Love ya!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.....................!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Even though I do agree, I thought of something. Some women actually do stuff that can make them vulnreble. They do stuff that can maybe suggest something.

Now that I am done with that. They should get the punishment that Prometheus had where an eagle came and ate his liver every day. Except the man gets his penis and testicles eaten everyday.

92nida(1411) Disputed
1 point

If Women make themselves seen and indirectly ask for it.. It's not rape after all! A rape is called one when an innocent life has to pay for maybe looking good and arousing the rapist. Or wearing something of her choice that happens to be revealing and it obviously catches his eye and he decides to rape her.

garry77777(1796) Disputed
1 point

You're describing a very black and white situation, there are many cases where the women may have tempted the man(or tempts him regularly), and in doing so provoked him, im not trying to justify it, its still wrong but those situations need to be considered separate from the ones you are describing.

1 point

Only 3 in 100 rape cases leads to convictions

Women need to come out anytime a piece of shit man rapes

We need a legal system that does not re-victimize victims but supports victims and we need higher conviction rates

1st time offender: therapy, 6-10 years prison time with no chance of parole. When they come out all of their moments should be GPS tracked in case of reoffending

2nd time offender: full removal of the weapon they used against their victim, their dick needs to be chopped off completely. Men who rape are not real men thus they should not have the apparatus that real men have. Prison time and being placed in a cell with bubba and a tattoo across their face saying rapist ( to fully shame the perp)

3rd time offender: this is only if the perp is actually given a chance to be among people after offending twice. If the ratshit re-offends for the third time, I believe the victims should kill the bastard any way they choose. Why keep ratshits alive when they'll only keep reoffending and be a burden on all of society. This allows money to be saved to be used for educational campaigns for children especially boys about how vile the crime of rape is.