CreateDebate is a social debate community built around ideas, discussion and democracy.
If this is your first time checking out a debate, here are some quick tips to help get you started:
Arguments with the highest score are displayed first.
Argument replies (both in favor and in opposition) are displayed below the original argument.
To follow along, you may find it helpful to show and hide the replies displayed below each argument.
To vote for an argument, use these icons:
You have the power to cast exactly one vote (either up or down) for each argument.
Once you vote, the icon will become grayed out and the argument's score will change.
Yes, you can change your vote.
Debate scores, side scores and tag scores are automatically calculated by an algorithm that primarily takes argument scores into account.
All scores are updated in real-time.
To learn more about the CreateDebate scoring system, check out the FAQ.
When you are ready to voice your opinion, use the Add Argument button to create an argument.
If you would like to address an existing argument, use the Support and Dispute link within that argument to create a new reply.
That's all fine and good, but what they should know is no matter what they do to themselves surgically, they can't change their chromosomes that determined their true sexual gender. But really, who cares is what I want to know.
They definitely know that. That's why they tend to identify as 'trans women' instead of 'women.'
The point is that gender identify and biological sex are, to some people, different.
And to your question: who cares?
Well, there are lots of very important reasons to care. Most notably, this study tells us that 41% of all transgender people will attempt suicide, compared to 4.6% of general population. And if they live in a world that doesn't accept them, doesn't support them, doesn't understand them, doesn't try to help them and actively works against them, that isn't going to change.
Have you ever heard of intersexuality? There are people born female bodied but with XY chromosomes and male with XX chromosomes. What goes on in someone's body on the cellular level isn't likely to bother them anyway.
Umm, I think what you're describing as 'intersexuals' is what is more commonly known as hermaphrodites where there are abnormalities in the genitalia at birth. These people are not transgendered in the manner of what has become customarily thought of in today's norms such as the person in your video who surgically altered theirs, or Bruce/Caitlyn Jenner who was born with normal genitalia for his sex but prefers now to self-identify as a woman while leaving the family jewels intact.
Actually, he is not correct, so no need to admit he is, but whatevs... Intersex people were previously referred to as hermaphrodites, but the term has fallen out of favor as it is considered to be misleading and stigmatizing.
My bad, I forgot not only are you delusional in the attributes you ascribe to me, but also the supposed superior brain power you mistakenly think you possess. Do us both a favor, and fuck off, asshole.
Whether you accept her as female or not, the fact is she's visually female. So therefore if a man is attracted to her it's a heterosexual female. Like she said in the video gay men would never be attracted to her. I can say that with certainty as I am gay myself.
So if it I'm attracted to it and it looks like a female, then it's a female?
Gotcha.
Like she said in the video gay men would never be attracted to her.
Shut up. "She says it so it's true. Drrrr"
I can say that with certainty as I am gay myself.
Well, I'm half gay. How can you differentiate whether it's my lust for women or lust for men that would cause me to lust for her?
Do you even understand the hormonal reactions which cause someone to lust?
What about, the fact that a man can love penises, be disgusted by the rest of the male figure, but absolutely loves the female figure, but not vaginas?
A transgender male would describe someone who transitions female to male.
No but if you are attracted to someone who has a woman's aesthetic then that isn't gay. Gay men are attracted to people who look male.
I am a gay. I am not attracted to trans women. Nor are the many other gay men I know. So I can verify it is true. So you should shut up.
Carmen has both a female figure and a vagina. Gay men want someone with a male figure and a penis. Neither of which she has. She may have had them years ago but not anymore.
No one looks at her and thinks "that's a man". So therefore someone who looks at her lustfully is not a gay male.
I have never ever heard of a gay man dating or sleeping with a trans woman. Show me one example of a totally homosexual male, not bisexual or pansexual, who dates and sleeps with trans women, then I can take your moronic argument that liking a trans woman is gay seriously. I am gay because I like men. I don't want someone with tits and a vagina.
I actually am gay unlike you so I can say what gay men are and are not attracted to. We are not attracted to trans women.
You still have no adressed my point that in order for a man liking a TS male to female to be gay, a man liking a female to male TS must be straight, even though they look like this
It is entirely relevant because in order for a man liking a Male to female to be gay, he must therefore be straight for liking a female to male. You can't have it both ways.
You can keep having the audacity to tell me, an actual homosexual male, who homosexual males are attracted to if you like but it's dumb. I am gay. I know who I'm attracted to and it's not someone with tits and a vagina. Nor are any other gay men I know. Bisexual men maybe will be but that's an entirely different thing. Just the knowledge that her vagina once was a penis isn't going to make me interested in her. Ask any of my gay friends if they want to sleep with or date a trans woman and they will say "no, I'm gay because I like MEN".
I have not been telling you that gay men are attracted to women. I've simply pointed out the absurdities and inconsistencies that arise from the "reasoning" you've presented .
You're the idiot for thinking gay men like vagina and tits. We don't, we like cock and flat, toned chests.
Dykes don't look male, they just look like tomboyish women. They also have boobs and a vagina therefore I'm not interested in them. The same reason why I'm not interested in male to female transsexuals. I want a MAN. Not someone who used to be a man. So do all the other gay men I know.
Since we are making up our own definitions, I say, no it isn't.
Well, actually TheEccentric is correct on this one. The convention is that with Transgender male or transgender female, the titular gender is the 'destination' so to speak.
You seem to have confused 'answering a simple question' with 'unsolicited displays of petulance'. Perhaps for you ProPathos would have been a more apt moniker.
Basically, when you die, you collapse in on yourself.
After that, tiny microbes called "Legumes", ingest your remains and then the micropes disperse.
During the dispersal process, the Legumes become one with your organs and then excel to the highest plane of existence, to redistribute your remains accordingly.
Basically, when you die, you collapse in on yourself.
After that, tiny microbes called "Legumes", ingest your remains and then the micropes disperse.
During the dispersal process, the Legumes become one with your organs and then excel to the highest plane of existence, to redistribute your remains accordingly.
Yeah, even though I'm gay so therefore am exclusively attracted to masculine looking people with penises, I'm still gonna shag someone with tits and a vagina.
Another point. If it is gay for a man to like Male to Female transsexuals, it must therefore be straight for a man to like female to male transsexuals, even though they look like this:
Yeah, even though I'm gay so therefore am exclusively attracted to masculine looking people with penises, I'm still gonna shag someone with tits and a vagina.
As I've implied many times, that doesn't make any sense.
Well then.. I guess there is probably three types of heterosexuality: hetrosexual-cisgender, hetrosexual-bigender and hetrosexual-transgender. We have never had to define it like this until recent years but I would image that most men are the first - they are only attracted to women that are not transexuals.
Yep keep calling on your imaginary friend God for support in fighting the evil transgenders and homosexuals who threaten to destroy the world with their pride parades and rainbow flags.
Someone clearly does have a mental disorder, and I don't think it's the woman in the video, I think it's the people I'm debating who talk to a fictitious white bearded man in the sky who controls everything
Appearing before you just don't meet a friend yet nor defiance. In fact if you have a friend among girls and are at peace with the choices you have made stop to receive each girl like a object of fear. There's something wrong with your mentality if you don't think he attractive for me or not , I just communicate with you walking naked into a giant bear's cave.
What God wants people who call themselves "transgender" to know:
A little poetic license characterizing God's will in accordance to His holy word translated into English, the King James Bible (I know saying the Bible in English is the King James Bible is enough to make a lot of people mad, but I'm just getting started here, please be patient).
"I, God, want all the "transgender" people to know I love them even though they have mutilated themselves or intend to mutilate themselves in rebellion against my plan for them to come into existence as the man or woman they were at the moment they were conceived. Even though you have sinned against me in despising your gender and body, and defiled yourself in perverted desires against my design of nature, I still gave my Son to be the propitiation for your sins and you can be saved from Hell if you will believe from your heart that He is risen from the dead, and receive Him as your Savior. If you really will believe on Him, repentance of your sins will be involved and you will agree with me regarding your errors and mistakes and willful indulgences in perversion, and you will have joy knowing your sins are forgiven and you are going to heaven and will have a new body similar to the angels yet physical the same as Jesus who you will know by the nail holes in his hands and feet and the hole in his side from the spear which pierced His heart. Then maybe you will have time teach transgressors the way of life to know me for real, and I'm sure you will want to stop taking all the meds or injections which change your appearance and let your natural appearance return, and get rid of the long hair if you were a man when conceived and let your hair grow if you were a woman when conceived. You can't un-mutilate your body and will have to wait for a new body in heaven, but you can be right in your heart towards me and walk in confidence of having my peace which I offer through the blood of my Son who paid for your sin so you don't have to pay in Hell and we can be at peace and you can be with me forever in the Kingdom of Heaven".
How is changing the state that something is in against God's will? If it is then we are going against God's plan when we convert things into different forms in our daily lives. Like when we convert wheat to flour. If simply changing something was against God then we all are committing crimes against God.
God doesn't even exist anyway so I don't even know why I bother responding to this argument. Only morons still believe that in the 21st century societal values and how people are treated should be defined by religion. Your imaginary friend God does not get to define how gay or transgendered people should be treated.
After reading the requested definition, I have concluded that if I was about 2 feet shorter than a pig, then a splendiforus eclipse would ascend to the depths of the equator, which, divided by the sub quadrant of an elephants left buttock, will then complete the paradox of religion.
Is there a difference to you between transgender and transsexual? I feel like one is before and one is for after surgery. Are we supposed to treat both those people the same?
And, I thought it was a little annoying that she said that guys would be lucky to be with her. If you aren't attracted to transgenders it is just like not being attracted to the same sex.
Transgender is an umbrella term for all gender non-conforming people including transsexuals. Transsexual specifically refers to someone who is born male but transitions to female or born female but transitions to male. However transgender also includes gender fluid and non-binary people who are not transsexuals.
So all transsexuals are transgender but not all transgenders are transsexual. But they often mean the same thing and are almost interchangeable.
Not all transsexual people choose to have the surgery on their genitals. This is because not all of them feel that what's between their legs defines them. These trans women are known as being "non-op". However Carmen who is the trans woman in the video is post-op.
A guy having sex with her wouldn't know that she was trans unless she told them. Post op trans vaginas are fully functioning and have the appearance of a natural born vagina. Plus her face and body are feminine so the guy would not clock her as trans. Plenty of men who are not explicitly into trans women would look at a photo of her without knowing she's trans and find her attractive.
How can you make the transition without getting surgery on your genitals? Is that dressing, cutting your hair, etc. like the gender you are transitioning to?
A guy having sex with her wouldn't know that she was trans unless she told them. Post op trans vaginas are fully functioning and have the appearance of a natural born vagina. Plus her face and body are feminine so the guy would not clock her as trans. Plenty of men who are not explicitly into trans women would look at a photo of her without knowing she's trans and find her attractive.
It becomes a gray area. It is plastic surgery. If you meet someone with breast implants or a nose job they can look attractive, but the attractiveness is artificially created. The idea that the beauty is man made can be disappointing.
It's not about surgery, it's about hormones. It's the hormones that feminize your face and your body. An operation to reassign your genitalia has no impact on the way you look, other than what's between your legs. HRT is what transitioning is mainly about other than clothes and hair and stuff. For trans women with particularly masculine face structures HRT may not be enough so they may want to get facial feminization surgery. However the majority of trans women do not, they just take hormones and if they feel necessary have the operation on their genitals.
There are plenty of beautiful natural trans girls who never have cosmetic surgery and just take hormones.
So, are we supposed to treat the transgenders who haven't done anything to transition to the gender they identify with the same as those who have at least tried to transition?
I don't think we do have to no. If you say you feel like a woman trapped in a male body, yet you still live as a male, you can expect to be continued to be treated as a male. However if you misgender someone who is clearly presenting as female then that is just being rude.
Anybody who changed their at-birth sex later on, via a combo of surgery and hormone therapy is a Transexual. And they are also Transgender because even before the OP they considered themselves to be a different sex than their birth sex.
So you don't have to be a Transexual, that is, have the surgery and hormones, to be a transgender.
Thus...the video title is misleading.
She is more than just a transgender, she began as one and became a Transexual. The process thus fulfilling her earlier feelings of what she really was. Despite the fact he was born with a dick.
You would never know she was born a male. She passes 110% and I'm sure is more attractive than any woman you have ever been with. She has almost no testosterone floating around because she is post op and no longer has testicles. Even pre-op trans women don't have testosterone because they block it off with estrogen and antiandrogens.
It's a man who has mutilated themselves and takes a lot of pills and/or hormones trying to appear to be a woman....it's insanity, and to expect people to believe it is normal is one more loop down the spiral of insanity in sin which leads to Hell.
If the guy feels misunderstood or disrespected because I refuse to call him "her", or "she", or "girl", or "woman", that's not my problem. When men do everything they can to weaken the muscles which highlight their skeletal differences from women, it shows...... if they have managed to change their appearance to fool people into thinking they are women, they will give themselves away by acting weird because they are weird and weird people act weird.
All this lunacy of normallizing unnatural abnormal things. It's funny how all these disorders, dysfunctions, abnormal orientations etc. are constantly pushed on us as something we should accept as normal, but when it comes to pedophiles who have attractions to children, it all of a sudden becomes monsterous for such attractions.
It amazes me the double standards from those on the Left. If we are all suppose accept normalcy on the say so of anyone, then we MUST do the same for the pedophiles who simply have attractions for children but would never abuse them. Can you grasp what is happening in this nation? We can no longer discern anything as being natural or unnaturall because of sick arrogant activists forcing their will on everyone in this nation.
Can you see where this slippery slope is leading this twisted lost nation? It is becoming so twisted that no one can simply state the obvious!
We must spend all our time fighting these Democrats & LBGT activists on the Left, who are pushing these ludicrous PC agendas while our nations says nothing while our children are being abandoned by their fathers by the millions!
Can you believe the sick priorities from the Left?
but when it comes to pedophiles who have attractions to children, it all of a sudden becomes monsterous for such attractions.
Well if you want to raise awareness for yourself and others like you the first step is to do it yourself and not rely on political parties to do it for you.
It's funny how all these disorders, dysfunctions, abnormal orientations etc. are constantly pushed on us as something we should accept as normal, but when it comes to pedophiles who have attractions to children, it all of a sudden becomes monsterous for such attractions.
Because a pedophile acting upon his sexual urges is actively hurting someone who does not have the ability to consent. Who is being hurt here?
If we are all suppose accept normalcy on the say so of anyone, then we MUST do the same for the pedophiles who simply have attractions for children but would never abuse them.
What is wrong with having a sexual urge towards children and not acting on it?
And fi you mean those who act on it with good intentions, well, as I said before, children can not give sexual consent. Which is why it's not ok.
Your question...... What is wrong with having sexual urges and attractions for children if they do not act on it?
You just said it all! In one smple comment you supported everything I have ever said about the slippery slope and the loss of man's ability to discern right from wrong, abnormal from normal, unnatural from natural.
Tell me, is there anything wrong with someone who has a desire to kill Jews, or kill Christians, or kill Gays, or kill Blacks..... as long as they do not act on it? Do you think there is something wrong with those people? Yes, there is something wrong with people with unnatural, abnormal, inhuman desires. They have issues! They have disorderrs, they have dysfunction. QUIT BEING SO BLINDLY POLITICALLY CORRECT AND STATE THE OBVIOUS.
Do we treate all people with respect as long as they do not harm others? Yes we do. Does that mean we bend over backwards as a nation to sanction any strange sexual orientation or disorder as being normal and worthy of forcing every stae to change their laws? NO!
What ever happened to common sense and the wisdom to call it like it is? Political correctness has created people who think like you and think like the Left. You are fixated on the abnormal unnatural things in this world while caring nothing for the really important things such as the break down in our families and the millions of children abandoned by mothers and fathers.
Your priorities are totally mindless. Like I keep saying, the only possible explanation for such fixations is mankind fighting against God and any notion of moral vlaues, right and wrong, normalcy, etc.
No other reason can explain this PC fixation with weird sex.
These types of debates have supported everything I have ever said about the slippery slope and the loss of man's ability to discern right from wrong, abnormal from normal, unnatural from natural.
Tell me, is there anything wrong with someone who has a desire for children..... as long as they do not act on it? Do you think there is something wrong with those people? Yes, there is something wrong with people with unnatural, abnormal, desires. They have issues! They have disorders, they have dysfunction. QUIT BEING SO BLINDLY POLITICALLY CORRECT AND STATE THE OBVIOUS.
Do we treate all people with respect as long as they do not harm others? Yes we do. Does that mean we bend over backwards as a nation to sanction any strange sexual orientation or disorder as being normal and worthy of forcing every state to change their laws? NO!
What ever happened to common sense and the wisdom to call it like it is? Political correctness has created people who think like you and think like the Left. You are fixated on the abnormal unnatural things in this world while caring nothing for the really important things such as the break down in our families and the millions of children abandoned by mothers and fathers.
Your priorities are totally mindless. Like I keep saying, the only possible explanation for such fixations is mankind fighting against God and any notion of moral vlaues, right and wrong, normalcy, etc.
No other reason can explain this PC fixation with weird sex.