CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:28
Arguments:13
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Which NFL team had the best draft? (13)

Debate Creator

Loudacris(914) pic



Which NFL team had the best draft?

Please try not to be overly fan-biased!
CBS Sportsline Draft Grades (www.sportsline.com)

Add New Argument
5 points

The REDSKINS had an awesome draft. Malcolm Kelly, Devin Thomas, and Fred Davis are going to have immediate big play impacts for our offense, and I love the late pickup of one of the most prolific passers in NCAA history (Colt Brennan). I can't wait to start singing "Hail to the Redskins" again soon.

Supporting Evidence: Draft Review (seattlepi.nwsource.com)
3 points

who the hell knows? Ask me in 5 years. The Falcons hopefully. Woeful as they are, they are my team

2 points

The Chiefs

The Chiefs had a great draft. First of all, Dorsey fell all the way to the 5th pick, which was a steal. Most of the mock drafts that I saw before the draft had Dorsey going #1. Also, they scooped up Jamaal Charles. He was an awesome RB at Texas.

Sportsline.com gave the Chiefs the only A+ grade on the annual draft scorecard.

2 points

How bout them Cowboys baby? Felix Jones is going to be takin it to the house all year!

2 points

The Cowboys baby. Watch out NFC East!!!

1 point

The New York Football Giants.

First off, the Giants had no glaring holes so anyone they add is just making a Super Bowl winning team even better. But the fact that they added the top safety in the draft in Kenny Phillips to the best defense in the league makes the Giants D downright scary next season.

Plus, NY backpage writers are going to have a field day for the next 10 years with the Manning-Manningham duo. Can't you just see it now......"Manning to Manningham to Repeat Champs!"

1 point

Mario Manningham was a good pick. Though, as a Penn State fan, I will always hate him for catching a touchdown pass with 1 second left on the clock to hand the Nittany Lions their only loss of the 2005 season. I am still so pissed about that.

1 point

Unfortunately the Giants did have a good draft. Looks like the NFC East will shape up to be the toughest division once again this year as them, the Skins, and the Cowboys all had solid drafts.

1 point

Can only say KC, Eagles were a no show again this year and I think in the 2008-9 season too.

3 points

I know my efficiency is going to get slammed for this...but:

E-A-G-L-E-S EAGLES!!!

go birds!

- hopefully they'll get my man TEBOW in '09!! (or PERCY HARVIN)

2 points

Yep, Eagles once again had a non-impact draft. It seems to be what they aim for. Never terrible, never good. Hence, continue to make playoffs, but no championships.

0 points

Hail to the Redskins, Hail victory

Braves on the warpath, FIGHT for ole DC!

Run and pass and score we want a lot more.

Beat em, swamp em, touchdown let the points soar.

Fight on, fight on til you have won.

Sons of WASHINGTON!!

RAH RAH RAH