Debate Info

18
9
British Comedy American Comedy
Debate Score:27
Arguments:24
Total Votes:27
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 British Comedy (13)
 
 American Comedy (9)

Debate Creator

Axmeister(4016) pic



Which is better, British Comedy or American Comedy?

Apparently there is a difference between the two. Anyway, this is a lighthearted debate and I hope no-one gets too passionate about it. Please provide samples of what you consider some of the best of British/American comedy. Hopefully we end up with a collection of funny clips.

British Comedy

Side Score: 18
VS.

American Comedy

Side Score: 9
2 points

This guy is one of the best.

Consumer Corner

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
2 points

By a country mile, British comedy is the best in the world.

Python

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
2 points

Another great pair, while it could be said that a lot of their comedy revolves aropund stereotypes, the stereotypes mainly mock silly prejudices.

Harry and Paul

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
2 points

Monty Python, Blackadder, Harry Enfield, Kathy Burke, Rik Myall, Lee Evans, Russell Howard, Michael McIntyre, Ruth Jones, Russell Brand, Eddie Izzard, Lee Mack, Freddie Starr. BOOM.

285 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

British comedy is and has always been much, much better than american comedy. We had Monty python, Lee Evans , Jack Dee and many many many more.

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
2 points

Monty Python is brilliant - the Life of Brian and Quest for the Holy Grail are two of the best flims I have ever seen. Here's Brian trying to tell the mob he's not actually the Messiah... Which he's not (I feel I ought to add that).

Life of Brian

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

Haha. Monty Python is awesome. Here's like one of the best scenes in the entire film "Monty Python and the Holy Grail."

Best scene. ;)

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

Care to provide a clip of one of their sketches? (you do this by clicking on "Add Link or Embed Video" when writing an argument.)

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

Doctor Who has wins it for me. It has some very humorous moments, all the while still keeping a serious note overall. ;)

A humorous scene in "Doctor Who."

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

= P it looks like Monty Python is winning it for us Brits.

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

What about a bit of Derek and Clive these guys were genius

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
TheAshman(1544) Clarified
1 point  

I could'nt get the link to work I was going to put on At The Races which I've always thought was hilarious but check out any Derek and Clive and as long as your not squeamish you should find it funny to say they were'nt PC is an understatement

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

American comedy gets a bit tiring, what with all the indistinguishable sitcoms that all have the same plot, with the exclusion of Big Bang Theory, which is brilliant. However, American stand up is awesome, you guys had George Carlin, and the modern version of Carlin, Louis CK.

British sitcoms are better, which is why America keeps stealing them (the office, the inbetweeners). Also, British comedy movies are the bestest thing evarrr, Monty Python FTW!

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

I like a lot of stuff coming out of Britain like Peepshow and the IT Crowd, but nothing beats Tim and Eric, which is American.

Tim and Eric Awesome Show Great Job

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
1 point  

I didn't really get it, is it just random stuff?

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
1 point  

It's post-comedy.

Adult Swim type indy stuff.

Acid trip, but we're not on acid.

Moar

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
1 point  

Peepshow is good mainly for its cringe value, the IT crowd is okay, you should check out limmy's show:

Laptop

287 days ago | Side: American Comedy
1 point  

I like both there are differences but that's just because of the difference's between the Countries and Cultures, what I dont like is when you get one country remaking anothers comedy it hardly ever seems to work (OK there are exceptions like the US Office seems to be a hit but for every one that works theres loads that fail)

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
1 point  

The American remakes of British comodies has caused a lot of annoyance over here in Britain.

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
1 point  

I'm gonna try to help American Comedy...

"The Big Bang Theory."

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
ricedaragh(2467) Clarified
1 point  

Maybe it is a cultural difference, but I find The Big Bang Theory to be particularly unfunny, the jokes as with a lot of mainstream American comedy are obvious and I find I can tell them coming a mile off.

Outside of the obvious jokes, the story lines gravitate towards who is having sex with who, it seems the formula is way too noticeable, it's dumbed down TV and not in the funny sense, more in the condescending sense.

The comedy world is ruled by the Brits, while quality drama is definitely ruled by the Americans, some shows, such as the wire that I've watched have been the best I've ever seen.

288 days ago | Side: British Comedy
1 point  

One thing that concerns me about American comodies is that they feed off stereotypes. Quite a lot of the humour in the Big Bang Theory gravitates around how they are scientists, atheists and "nerds".

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
1 point  

oops, accidental double-post.

288 days ago | Side: American Comedy
Popular Debates: The burden of proof is on the one making the claim. Is it okay to eat weed? Can a stupid painting be worth $43.8 million?



About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons



©2013 TidyLife, Inc. All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Debate Forum | Big shout-outs to The Bloggess and Andy Cohen.