CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:124
Arguments:32
Total Votes:158
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Which is the more important focus - 'Service' OR 'Learning'? (31)

Debate Creator

Seth_Tan(133) pic



Which is the more important focus - 'Service' OR 'Learning'?

Please limit to 1 main point per posting.

Add New Argument
6 points

Learning is the more important focus. We need to learn before we serve or else we will have no knowledge on how to serve the correct way.

6 points

I think that both are equally important. It is important to increase our knowledge about the world around us, but it is also necessary to give back the society by doing a service.

5 points

Learning is the more important focus. You can continuously provide service to the people without even know what you are doing so it is as good as pointless to do the service other than the fact that you may help.

5 points

I think learning is more important. You can do all the service you can do, thinking you are doing it right. But if you do it wrong, the service then becomes completely useless . If you learn from your mistakes, then you can perform services effectively.

5 points

Service.

For example, the uneducated are not necessarily knowledgable, and yet they are able capable of serving and helping others. Knowledge does not measure how good, compassionate, or empathic a person you are.

You might argue that learning does not mean that they are smart, it could mean street-smart and practical-wise, but by helping others, others would help you, and that is what would support you through life.

5 points

Both are equally important because service will help others and learning will help yourself

5 points

To me, I feel that learning is a more important focus. Service without any learning value is meaningless. Having nothing learnt is equivalent to being forced to carry out the service without any sincerity in doing so. Although carrying out a service for others is important too, if nothing is learnt while carrying out the service, no matter how much effort is put in to the service, you might never improve on your next service to make it better. In addition to that, although doing a service for others is to provide assistance to them, another point of doing services for others is to put oneself in their shoes to feel for them. This is turn builds our character and when one has a good character, the recipients of the service will feel even better, thus justifying my point on why learning is more important than service. Just sayin.

5 points

Learning is more important. Because in service learning, servicing is what everyone can do but whether he/she will learn from what they saw during service learning is different from everyone. If we learn, we can understand more about people and appreciate more about what i have. thank you welcome

5 points

I feel that both are important. Because with service comes learning, with learning comes service. As we serve others, we will learn along the way. But also, if we learn, only then the service will be good and beneficial. So when both are applied at the same time, then it will reach its full potential to be beneficial for both parties, the one doing service learning and the one receiving the help. Like wise, if they are separated, it would be meaningless as service will only be service and learning will only be learning, not being able to merge together to reach its full potential to help others.

5 points

The more important focus to me is Learning.

Service is definitely important, however, if you just do a service without learning from it, then the service has no meaning. For example, you can visit an Old Folks' Home just for the sake of CCA points and this will be a service accomplished. However, if you do the service without learning anything, or taking anything away from the experience, the service basically has no meaning. You may not have to learn an important life lesson or value; perhaps something as simple as realizing that you are fortunate and should be grateful for everything you have can be a lesson well learnt. Thus, I feel that 'Learning' is the more important focus.

5 points

I think that both are equally as important as both rely on each other. When service is present, learnings comes after and in order to learn, service is required. When both are applied, benefits from both will be at its peak. When there is no service, learning is hard and shallow while when there is no learning, service loses its value. When one is absent, both will cease to work and thus backfire and fail. Therefore there is no point that outweighs the other as both are interlinked and interdependent on each other

4 points

Both are equally important. This is because after the service, we need to learn something. From that, we can gain experience and also do better projects in the future.

4 points

Service is more important as if we just learn about services but do not put it into action, it will be useless.

4 points

Service is more important. You can learn the meaning of Service Learning and reasons why to do it, but if you don't even do any service there is no point. You can do service without knowing what you are doing but still help.

baoziunicorn(5) Disputed
4 points

But if you do service WITHOUT learning how to do it properly, then your efforts are all a waste.

Kevyn(13) Clarified
1 point

You can simply know how to do service and do it correctly but not know WHY you are doing it or knowing it for the wrong purpose.

4 points

To me both service and learning are important,but learning is more important,as we learn through service and we can apply the knowledge and things we have learnt while serving in the future,so learning is more important,because we can apply it in the future.

4 points

Both are equally important. Providing the service for the recipients will help them improve or help their lives. Learning from the experience is also important such that after we do the service, we learn life lessons and how to improve the way we do a service in the future.

However, if it is necessary to select a point, I feel that learning is more important. As it is said earlier, we learn life lessons and how to improve the way we do a service in the future. This experience will allow us to learn important life values (such as compassion, patience, etc.), and will allow us to mature into a better person in whole. We will also learn how to give better services in the future, so that the recipients will gain more benefits, and it would be smoother to run as well.

4 points

I think that 'Learning' is more important because after all that we should learn more about society and ourselves. We cannot change the world, therefore we should learn more to change ourselves which would in turn contribute to society. Also, by learning, we can perform our youth service programmes better by learning on our mistakes we make when we first start out with the youth service programmes.

4 points

Service learning has progressively become popular in schools in the modern era. Service learning, is a modern method that combines traditional classroom teaching with meaningful community service. However, what is the most important aspect? The act of kind and voluntary assistant from us volunteers, or the knowledge behind the act of assistance? I feel that the 'Service' should be more important focus in this meaningful activity. 'Service' is defined as an action of assistance, to help someone in need. Service is important, because this is what instills the values into us. However, learning is just accepting instructions with a dead mind. Service is actively contributing and thinking what you can do for the society and community around you - thinking for the common good. I think that service is what makes us have the mindset to do good for others. 'Service' is a psychological factor, and cannot be forced into one's mind.

4 points

l think both learning and service are important as for learning, it is the afterthoughts and reflections which influences the person to participate in another service program. In the case of service, the receiver end might not care if you learn anything or not, as long as you complete your job.

4 points

The are both equally important. Service is about helping others do something that they cannot do, while learning is about knowing a new knowledge.

3 points

Learning is more important because you have to learn before you are able to provide a better service for other people.

3 points

Comparing Service and Learning, both are equally as important. Learning is so you know the purpose of why you are doing it and service is taking action.

3 points

I think that both are important as service is committing our time for the benefit of others which is essential and learning is for our benefit which is also important

3 points

Learning is more important as doing service blindly will not have a good impact on the beneficiary

2 points

Another reason why learning is more important than service is due to the fact that a number of volunteers sometimes do not even understand the purpose of committing the service, but only for the rewards given. As such, it is not the will to drive them forward, but rather their greed. Following this attitude, the recipients of the service might not receive the best treatment from the service. Just sayin. Again. Hi.

2 points

They're both very important. Either way you look at it, you can't have one without the other. Without knowledge, you cannot serve. Without service, knowledge is pointless. It's hard to decide, all i can say is that they're as equally important.

1 point

Dang, I was going to say exactly that. You beat me by 50 minutes. ;)

1 point

Service is the most important focus, you can have a long list of degrees, and have studied everything there is to know about being a surgeon (example), but doesn't mean you can conduct a surgery. There are plenty of people that work their way from the bottom to the top. Those that have never taken a course in their lives, but with experience and time - can teach you more than any book can. Who do you think writes those books after all? Einstein dropped out of school, everyone called him dumb and said he wouldn't amount to anything - he sure did shove their words up their bean pole. But learning and service come hand and hand, you can't honestly have one without the other - with service you're learning as you progress. With learning, you're preparing for service. Otherwise - both would be useless without the other.