CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
5
Physical. Mental.
Debate Score:14
Arguments:11
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Physical. (6)
 
 Mental. (5)

Debate Creator

Shadow29(148) pic



Which is worse, mental or physical torture?

I appreciate every response to this and hope this question is to your taste.

:) 

Physical.

Side Score: 9
VS.

Mental.

Side Score: 5

Physical torture would have severe both physical and mental affects where as mental torture would only affect you mentally.

Side: Physical.
2 points

Physical torture is mentally torturing.

For example: Rape.

Side: Physical.

Pretty much exactly. Physical torture "works" because of the mental effect on the victim undergoing it. Mental torture can exist independently of physical torture, but mental torture always accompanies physical torture.

While some forms of mental torture may be worse than some forms of physical torture, physical torture is the worse of the two overall.

Side: Physical.
1 point

Physical torture can cause mental issues as well as physical for example it can cause trauma, paranoia and emotional damage. Physical torture can sometimes be a double wammy of both physical and mental so I'd say that makes this the worst of two.

Side: Physical.
1 point

I've been contemplating this for a while, actually. Technically, they're both "mental", but I'd rather be physically than mentally tortured (as stated above) physical leads to mental.

Side: Physical.
1 point

I don't want to post graphic images; they will give the faint-hearted members nightmares.

Side: Physical.
1 point

This is kinda hard to tell as both end up affecting the person mentally.

Side: Mental.

Emotions such as joy and happiness come from the mind. Mental torture could impair the development of these emotions.

Side: Mental.

I have had both, and the mental was worse. .

Side: Mental.
1 point

Physical torture is easier to discover, and thus easier to treat. However in the moment, it may also be more effective in getting information. Mental torture however can lead to problems later down the road, may never be noticed, and may never be treated.

Side: Mental.
1 point

The badness associated with physical torture presupposes mental suffering. Physical torture isn't really torture if it doesn't result in suffering in the mind.

Side: Mental.