CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
3
Physical Emotional
Debate Score:11
Arguments:9
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Physical (6)
 
 Emotional (3)

Debate Creator

Saurbaby(5581) pic



Which is worse, physical or emotional abuse?

I am aware that this debate has been done before, but I would like to do it again. So get over it :) It's been awhile anyway. 

Physical

Side Score: 8
VS.

Emotional

Side Score: 3
2 points

Emotional abuse is all subjective on whether it causes permanent damage or not. Consider all the artists that were emotionally abused and gone on to create great things for us to pseudo-intellectually masturbate to.

Physical abuse leads to measurable limitations, such as broken limbs or organ/brain damage.

Side: Physical
2 points

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but names will never hurt me."

Side: Physical

Physical abuse usually leads to emotional abuse... alright, lets say your raped, thats physical, but I can assure you, your emotions will be harmed.

Side: Physical
1 point

Physical abuse frequently leaves emotional scars. Emotional abuse does not necessarily leave emotional!

Side: Physical
1 point

This topic is very controversial, and it is difficult to argue, because both physical and psychological violence is unacceptable. However, it may be true that physical obuce is worse. Undoubtedly, there is no physical violence, which would not affect the psychological state of the person. It turns out that the person which experienced physical violence, in addition, experiencing emotional. However, physical pain sooner or later treated, however psychological wounds difficult to heal. Firstly because psychology science itself is not fully studied, and secondly just a few people are willing to share what they have experienced and to tell again and again about the events that caused them pain. Mostly, people which have experienced psychological violence carry the memories of what had happened through all their life. Surely, physical wounds heal, but then again people have experienced physical violence, and will always feel emotional,that is, they feel the pain of a double.

Side: Physical

Getting slapped around is worse than verbal abuse. Also, being punched in the face is horrifying.

Side: Physical

what about emotional abuse? you shouldve made it physical vs emotional abuse, thatd be a more interesting debate, id have to say... verbal abuse though, physical abuse is bad, and there is some serious damage that can be done, but i think verbal abuse ties into emotional abuse, well they both do really... hmm... i think verbal abuse is worse than physical abuse because physical pain comes and goes, it makes you stronger, imo, but verbal abuse, that shit hurts, being told youre not loved by anyone is far damaging than having a broken bone, bones heal, hearts never fully heal, they may seem like they do, but deep down they dont heal all the way...

Side: Emotional
1 point

I actually meant emotionally abusive. I'll fix it. I don't know why I put verbal.... I'm tired. It's like four in the morning here. lol

Side: Emotional

lol ok :P well in that case, emotional abuse is far far worse than physical abuse, they both have psychological damaging effects but im pretty sure attacking someones emotions is a more "effective" way of abusing someone, i mean dont get me wrong, physical abuse is damaging and can have permanent effects, but so does emotional abuse and if youre emotionally abused you feel like no one loves you, whereas physical abuse you just build up rage and hatred towards the abuser... i think... idk, it is pretty early lol

Side: Emotional