CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
29
Twilight Harry Potter
Debate Score:38
Arguments:21
Total Votes:56
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Twilight (6)
 
 Harry Potter (15)

Debate Creator

hihellohi123(28) pic



Which series is better- Twilight or Harry Potter?

Which is better? I personally think that Twilight is better...

Twilight

Side Score: 9
VS.

Harry Potter

Side Score: 29

Idk they both are good but The Lord of the rings is better than both lolz.

Side: Twilight
-1 points

Oh yeah! Twilight is better simply because it not only is about scary vampires and wolves, but is also centered around love which pulls at every readers heart strings and makes every reader feel for Bella and Edward. Harry Potter however, is just a silly fan fiction about wizards and muggles, and I can argue this because I have read the first book. It's not bad, but I wasn't necessarily dying to find out what happened next, so I didn't read the next one, because I didn't care for what would happen next in the series. Twilight is better.

Side: Twilight
holly2d(52) Disputed
1 point

You thought the "Vampires" were scary? Haha.

Now, you think Harry Potter ISN'T about love? That was the whole point of the series! The power of love and friendship and family. You cannot have ANY valid arguments if you've only read the first book.

Side: Harry Potter
-4 points
1 point

realy i don't see what is so wrong with this argument. Like really i didn't bash anyone... and really if you have seen the movies they can't act at all but the book is amazing and i could never think that harry potter could compare becuz you have to think to much to bring together what is happening and there a too many charactors.

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

stop down voting this nothing is wrong with what i said now your just downvoting it just cuz you see other people have

Side: Twilight
4 points

I thought this debate was a joke. No offense to any Twilight lovers, but seriously? I've read quite a bit into each series (as much as I loath to admit) and the winner is blatantly obvious, even despite the fact that I'm a fan of neither. Reading through Twilight, I really just wanted to get it over with (I'm one of those people who bought it just to find out what the craze was about); it honestly felt like I was reading one of those cheesy fanfiction stories. The authors idea of 'love' is based solely on lust; for a woman in her forties, this is pathetic. Not only that, but I wanted to kill almost every single lead character in the story- especially angsty, self-pitying 'oh, my life is so hard!' Bella, and the obsessive, overly controlling dick named Edward. If you want a good 'vampire' romance novel, I'd suggest giving "Let the Right One In" a try; it's a million times better, focuses on more than just appearances, and actually reaches a realistic emotional level. Now, Harry Potter might have started out for a younger audience, but the books themselves actually grew up along with the people who were reading them. The writing style is definitely more sophisticated, the characters are likable (sometimes even relate-able), and the plots are a lot more complex than what they would initially appear to be. That's my opinion anyway; I won't down you for yours.

Side: Harry Potter
3 points

Harry Potter is children's literature which can also be enjoyed by more mature audiences, as it is written in an elegant and developed style. Twilight - which I haven't read past the first several chapters of the first book because I couldn't stand to read more - is purely children's/teen's fiction. It sounds unmistakably childish when read by someone used to reading quality adult fiction.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

even though i i will NEVER pick up a harry potter book to read EVER i was born in 1998 so i was born during HARRY'S movie take over ...I FELL IN LOVE.. <3 AND I WANNA GO BEAT DOWN ANY ONE WHO SAYS IT HAS TO END EVER ( AHRRY POTTER SERIES)!

Side: Harry Potter
TheHallow1(78) Disputed
2 points

"i was born in 1998 so i was born during HARRY'S movie take over"

Not during. Before. The first Harry Potter film was released in 2001.

Side: Harry Potter
2 points

Twilight sucks. Period. Does she even relize the vampire is a pervert? He has 100 high school diplomas! She is in love with a pedefile, and an old man.

He sparkles in the sun! How gay is that?

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

Harry Potter fore sure! Twilight is cheesy and boring... Harry potter is much better

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

Sorry, but clearly (my opinion) Harry Potter is better.

Seven books of action, intensity, great storyline = amazing!

Four books of a little to much romance, lots of drama, etc = Bleh

Side: Harry Potter

Twilight has a good thing going for itself but Harry Potter takes the cake on this one any day of the week

Side: Twilight
1 point

Harry pOTTER Obviously

It has More adventure

It has More Imagination

it has More Characters (For making a spoof)

Its Books Are written in a better way than Twilight

Side: Harry Potter

harry potter is the best because Harry isn't a glittery fag or a hairy stereroid junkie! Harry has his wand and he aint afraid to use it.

Side: Harry Potter
1 point

I've read all the Twilight books(Unfortunately) and all the Harry Potter books... Harry Potter touched my heart and will stay with me forever. Twilight will be a black smudge on my soul that I will always regret.

Side: Harry Potter

Harry Potter is more charming and I like the Hogwarts School and all that wizardry. Twilight was boring to me.

Side: Harry Potter