CreateDebate


Debate Info

15
7
Military Social Security and Medicare
Debate Score:22
Arguments:19
Total Votes:22
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Military (13)
 
 Social Security and Medicare (6)

Debate Creator

AbbyNestor(1028) pic



Which should the Government cut spending from?

Which would save the government more money? Which would be a more effective cut?

Military

Side Score: 15
VS.

Social Security and Medicare

Side Score: 7

People rely on those checks for survival. We spend far too much on our military. Our airplane graveyard is crazy. Some of those should still be in service.

Side: Military
1 point

There are countries that depend on our military for survival.

Side: Social Security and Medicare
2 points

Politician's pay.

Side: Military

I agree with lizzie, although I don't necessarily agree with welfare our military spending is absolutely ridiculous and with one precise strike 90% of what makes our military strong would be gone.

But you also have to realize America is not on a lot of peoples good list

Btw you are really cute if that's you in your profile pic... :s

Side: Military

Me or Lizzie?

Side: Military

LOL

you!

Side: Military

woops double post

Side: Military

When the army complains about having too many tanks, that means the defense budget is way too big.

Side: Military

The Army complained about having too many tanks?

Side: Military

Yeah, they have 2,000 M-1 Abrams tanks that are just sitting around, never been used. The Army told Congress that they won't need any more tanks for 3 years, but Congress thinks it's good for business to build new tanks anyway.

Side: Military
1 point

People need to survive. I am on disability and I would be screwed without it.

Side: Military
2 points

You never know when we might get attacked, when that happens (and lately it seems more likely) it's better to have a strong military than happy, healthy citizens. I mean that's just my opinion obviously.

Side: Social Security and Medicare
1 point

Dont you think we can spare a bit of that military money? Wont people rebel of they dont het the chance at social security?

Side: Military
Quocalimar(6470) Disputed
1 point

Of course we can spare it, but as an opinion we shouldn't. It's not like putting more in is a better option, but at least keep it at what it's at, let the military stay at it's level, as opposed so social security that's already being abused at the level it's at.

My reasoning is this:

If military spending decreases, if anything happens, we are just that slight bit less unprepared, which could be the deciding factor in that event.

If social security and medicare is cut, the people who abuse it will either win over, and the whole thing will reform to better protect against them, or the people who abuse won't have a place to dig a cubby hole and will no longer be able to abuse.

Side: Social Security and Medicare

They need to cut both, I'm only on this side because Social Security and Medicare are larger than the military budget.

Side: Social Security and Medicare

Cutting either would have to be a fairly long-term proposition.

Side: Social Security and Medicare

Well of course you can't just cut everything at once, it would have to be phased out.

Side: Social Security and Medicare