CreateDebate


Debate Info

11
8
Anti Pro
Debate Score:19
Arguments:16
Total Votes:22
Ended:10/06/17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Anti (8)
 
 Pro (8)

Debate Creator

Jssssse(14) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Is white privilege a myth?

Is white privilege a myth?

Anti

Side Score: 11
Winning Side!
VS.

Pro

Side Score: 8
3 points

Injustice does not solve injustice. Blaming someone for something that happened to your grandfather, when they weren't alive nor a party to the act will not solve the problem. Some people are still affected by Jim Crow -- if your parents grew up in this time, of course, they couldn't acquire wealth like whites could have -- but that doesn't stop you from making something of yourself now. We can't choose where we start in life, but we can sure as hell decide exactly where we want to go.

Side: Anti

I wouldn't say it's a 100% complete myth because there are more Whites than any ethnic group in America. But is there a systematic block that keeps minorities from success and happiness? No. If there was, Asians wouldn't be thriving like it's nobody's business. Is there a white privilege that resembles the one that the left describes? Not at all. Much of the Hispanic and African American plight is cultural. The culture of victimhood keeps getting passed down. The minorities that choose to make it do make it.

Side: Anti
Jssssse(14) Disputed
1 point

More whites in America doesn't equal white privilege. Inequity doesn't mean inequality. Why don't we just call it individual acts of discrimination? It seems more fitting.

White privilege suggests racism on an institutional level; because I'm white, I'm entitled to things people of colour aren't -- which just isn't true.

I'd love for you to unpack the idea that white privilege isn't completely a myth.

Side: Pro
bozwallocks(44) Disputed
1 point

If you think its a complete myth, how do you explain the institutional differences in the way different races are treated? For example, policing and healthcare. If you say its a complete myth then this implies that the blame lies entirely with the minorities.

Side: Anti
1 point

There's no way white privilege is a myth. There are huge differences in the way whites are treated vs other ethnicities. Even comparing whites to asians or hispanics you can see the huge difference in the way they're treated. the difference between how african american's and whites are treated is greater

Side: Pro