CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
5
I am I am not
Debate Score:11
Arguments:8
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 I am (6)
 
 I am not (3)

Debate Creator

Peace_Maker(11) pic



Who are mentally here?

Well who is on this earth in person and in mental state? If you think killing millions of people is OK than you are not. But if you think abortion is OK you are also not here. If you think killing anyone for any reason is OK, you are not here mentally. So that rules out a ton of people.

I am

Side Score: 6
VS.

I am not

Side Score: 5
1 point

I would say there are MANY mental states. Some say I am in one, some say another. I am definitely mentally here .... one way or another. ;-)

Side: I am
1 point

Well no this is merely your opinion nothing more , what exactly do you mean ' mentally here ' ?

Side: I am

What is this 'mentally' stuff, though?

If I can kill a suicide bomber such that others are not harmed, and no other scenario ends nearly as well, then I'd consider a reluctance to getting your hands dirty the worst choice.

But you think that it is being mentally absent here, which I've no idea, whether can mean here something at all.

Side: I am
1 point

If you think killing anyone for any reason is OK, you are not here mentally

I believe this to be an untrue statement. If someone breaks in my home and threatens my family, I have every right to eliminate the threat and maintain that I am "mentally here".

Side: I am
1 point

I am pro choice, mate.

But since I be typing this and you're bloody reading it, that means I am here mentally.

So I guess you're daft for saying otherwise, eh?

Cheers!

Side: I am
1 point

There are very few instances where I could comfortably say that I'm ok with killing, or if not ok than I see the reason. As others have pointed out, if someone breaks into my house and they try to come at my family even after I've warned them, I will kill them. I don't care about them stealing stuff but if they try to hurt my children they will be hurting or dying on the floor and I will 100% be mentally cognizant of my actions.

Side: I am
1 point

Well by your definition of not being here I suppose I am for I do believe in killing people for the right and very specific reasons. per say

-someone I care about-A- is about 20 feet from me to me left, diagonal me, straight in front of A is a man with a knife yelling he will kill A while he runs tword A. Now I have a gun what do I do? certainly I would shoot and kill the man before he can bring any harm to -A-

Side: I am not
1 point

Not me, I'm trying to get laid........................................................................................

Side: I am not