CreateDebate


Debate Info

103
79
USA Britain
Debate Score:182
Arguments:109
Total Votes:187
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 USA (60)
 
 Britain (46)

Debate Creator

GuitarGuy(6096) pic



Who has the more traditional English accent?

USA

Side Score: 103
VS.

Britain

Side Score: 79
4 points

It wasn't until the 19th century that non-rhotic speech became popular in England.

Supporting Evidence: US vs UK accents (www.mentalfloss.com)
Side: USA
3 points

Thank you for that article, it also shed some light on where the cockney accent or the British slums accent came from. Not to mention I didn't know anything in that factoid before reading it.

Side: USA
3 points

Pretty interesting, wasn't it? It kind of puts the whole "we speak proper English" argument coming from the Brits to rest.

Side: USA
1 point

Most British people don't have cockney accents.

Side: Britain
Micmacmoc(2260) Disputed
3 points

Matt Soniak, the author of that article on Mental Floss (a source renowned for reliability) is definitely not biased in any way. Obviously.

This is sarcasm if you having figured it out yet (American IQ is a lot lower on average - if you need me to explain what any of the words mean, just drop me a message).

Side: Britain
GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
2 points

Bill Bryson, who has lived in England most of his life, has an English wife and kids and is a chancellor of Durham University, wrote a book on the subject. Matt Soniak, wasn't the first to reveal this information.

If the article isn't reliable, then prove it wrong, rather than just saying it's wrong.

Side: USA
1 point

What the heck? Why would not pronouncing letters become fancy? Stupid Brits. I hope that thing is accurate.

Side: USA
1 point

Actually, you are mixing up cockney people with British people in general. Most people are not cockneys so this is irrelevant. The only one displaying stupidity is you with your generalizations.

Side: Britain
TheAshman(2299) Clarified
1 point

Probably for the same reason that White Middle Class Kids talk like black urban kids today "fashion" and the iodiocy of the people that follow it, you will note from the article that the same accent was adopted in parts of America as well making Americans equally as stupid as the Brits that adopted it

Side: USA
1 point

I have no idea. I always thought it was strange how they said that they pronounce words right, when they say their R's like A's, but we pronounce our R's and our A's. What's the point in having an R if you're going to make it sound like an A?

Side: USA

English came from England. .

Side: Britain
GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
5 points

But we maintained the accent.

Side: USA
7 points

English has developed into many dialects. Define accent. .

Side: Britain

Ya potato!

Side: Britain
Stickers(1037) Clarified
1 point

LOOK AT ME BOLLOCKS GOVNA !

Side: USA
ICANTSPELL12(5) Disputed
1 point

Really ? I though it was brought to that Island by Germany .

Side: USA

I highly doubt that people in the 1600's in Britain spoke with what is now a New York Texas or New Jersey accent.

Side: Britain
GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
5 points

That's the problem with Brits. They think every American sounds like they are from Texas and New York. We have fifty states! The majority of the US doesn't sound like that.

New York and the New England area adopted non-rhotic speech, just as you guys did in the early 19th century. The rest of the country, minus a few other states, maintained proper English, which is rhotic speech.

Dude, read the article!

Side: USA
5 points

You're correct, the spoke with an accent similar to that of someone from Boston or Northern New England.

Side: USA
3 points

This debate is complete bullshit. Obviously English people have the most English accent. The bizarre theory that the modern accent has evolved the most is a load of rubbish: if our language and spelling has changed less (become less of an abomination) then why wouldn't our accent?

There are variations of accents and dialects across all of Britain. To an English person American accents sound pretty much all the same, but no American person would be able to make the mistake the difference between the accent of the English 'bourgeoisie' and a Liverpudlian accent

Side: Britain

Agreed. It is good to see another patriotic Brit here. I was beginning to feel like a lonely standard bearer in defending us against the Americans around here.

Side: Britain
TheAshman(2299) Disputed
4 points

Dude you confuse patriotism with excessive nationalism, I'm patriotic I buy British but I'm not stupid, I can see the good in other countries and their cultures, I can see that there is more to American culture than obese McDonalds munching morons that believe everything that is printed in the National Enquirer and that there is more to Asia than Communism and Islam. Maybe if you opened your eyes and mind to the world you would see too that yes Britain is Great but the World has just as much to offer and and isn't the scary place full of terrorist's and potential immigrants that UKIP and the Daily Mail would have you believe.

Side: USA
GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
3 points

Do you agree with him because neither of you read the article? He doesn't have the faintest clue of what he is talking about. Just another example of British arrogance.

Side: USA
1 point

Dude, you don't even know. Axmeister is like the most nationalistic guy here (though he doesn't get on often, anymore). But he has started to tone it down, which is nice.

Side: Britain
1 point

Axmeister and I used to be quite the pair, but recently I haven't had a lot of time to come on here

Side: Britain
12characters(224) Clarified
1 point

Wouldn't a Patriotic Brit be Church of England?

Side: USA
DrawFour(2662) Disputed
1 point

As an american I disagree. The only two types of English accents I can differentiate are what I consider the typically British 'posh' accent, and the less refined Australian accent. Also as an American I can notice a very different sound coming from my mouth, born in the north, and the mouths of people born in the south.

Side: USA
Micmacmoc(2260) Disputed
2 points

I don't even know where to begin. People like you should be lined up and shot.

"The only two types of English accents I can differentiate are what I consider the typically British 'posh' accent, and the less refined Australian accent"

Well the clue for this one is in the name: "Australian" - Australia is a country on the other side of the world from England, and whilst they are a part of the commonwealth, they are a distinctly different country; saying that you can distinguish between the English accent and the Australian accent is no different from saying that you can differentiate between the American accent and Chinese.

The only American accents I can distinguish are those from "TEXAS!" and those from "'MERICA!"

Different English Accents
Side: Britain

Lel wut? No contest.

Side: Britain
3 points

All that says is we can't know which by historical evidence.

Side: Britain

If it wasn't for England,there wouldn't be no USA. We stole their Flag, we stole their justice system, and we stole their language.

English defended from England. Their accents are more appropriate. The USA is just an offspring of England.

Side: Britain
GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
3 points

So you don't think it's possible that we maintained the accent and they didn't? Because the article I posted says just that.

Side: USA
1 point

british are english. therefore.

Side: Britain
GuitarGuy(6096) Disputed
1 point

Americans were originally British... Therefore, our accent was originally British... But as the article says, we maintained the original accent, where as the Brits began adopting non-rhotic pronunciation in the early 19th century.

When I said English, I meant more along the lines of the language than the country of England.

Side: USA
mitgag(1652) Disputed
1 point

i thought the red Americans were the original inhabitants of America. and agreed that most of the American population today really of british origin.

but nayway, according to the debate, americans, in comparison to british, do not have better english.

Side: Britain