Debate Info

10
8
god science
Debate Score:18
Arguments:13
Total Votes:22
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 god (6)
 
 science (5)

Debate Creator

skabdwal121(7) pic



Who is almighty?? god or science

plz!! don't make nasty arguments abt that

god

Side Score: 10
VS.

science

Side Score: 8
4 points

This is what get's me annoyed on this site, atheists following the assumption that God and Science are equals battling it out to see who wins and since you cannot see God-Scieince wins. Which is a completly ridiculous interpretation.

Religion is not a science and science is not a religion, one cannot replace the other.

287 days ago | Side: god
OliverJDH(131) Disputed
1 point

Religion is not a science and science is not a religion, one cannot replace the other.

So long as religion claims to have truths about the real physical world and it's history i.e. that it was designed by a divine creator, or it is 10,000 years old, or there was once a great flood and two of each animal survived on an Ark manned by a 600 year old Noah - then the two are in conflict and one can replace the other.

If religion limits it's scope to morality and how society ought to be governed, while its claims should rightly be disputed, it is not science with which it contends.

287 days ago | Side: science
CraftyCarp
Disputed
1 point

Religionists love to claim 'proof' of God. The only way you can 'prove' something is through the scientific method. And even then almost nothing is ever absolutely proven. However when science lends weight to the idea that a particular religious claim is false, the religionists fall back on the Non-overlapping magisteria - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-overlapping_magisteria - argument.

You cannot have it both ways. Either you completely reject science when it seems to prove OR disprove religious claims or you accept findings whether they support 'god' or not.

287 days ago | Side: science

Assuming he exists, then God is. Science is just a methodology, it doesn't have any attributes of its own.

287 days ago | Side: god
1 point

Neither as far as I am concerned.

But hypothetically, if both certainly exist, a god would probably be "almighty". I'd be weary of omnipotence, but concede to a great deal of influence; much stronger than the methodology for determining natural laws.

287 days ago | Side: god
1 point

The only reason that people say "science" is because they don't believe in God. Science. Is. Not. Almighty.

Science can't draw, have a conversation with me or make me a sandwich. You can do those things scientifically, but SCIENCE isn't the one doing them.

If there is a God, and I believe that there is, then he is almighty. Or at least, there's a greater chance of God being almighty.

282 days ago | Side: god
Braden(1) Clarified
1 point

Also I don't know why it says I voted for science because I didn't.

282 days ago | Side: god
1 point

But we can't state science as almighty. ya science is very helping ia our daily life. bt it can't provide life to a dead body. science can't creat life but god can. so i refer god

as almighty..

278 days ago | Side: god
1 point

Well, Neither. I mean obviously science has an advantage; it is non fictional! But God is not all powerful, because he does not exist, and if he did, and he was all powerful, then there would not be as much suffering in the world. The thing that makes us more dominant than the other animals is our intellect, and from that we made science, and with out it, we would all be living in caves with out the knowledge of fire!

287 days ago | Side: science
Jungelson(1657) Clarified
1 point

Animals have Logic. To me, there are only two types of intelligence. Basic animal > If a tree is falling, move out of the way, hot things are bad, if there is a cliff don't walk of it. E.t.c. And Human Intelligence. I.e. If the stock falls, but ""% on no.3. And, 3x3 is 9, and, To drive a car, you must clutch first, and if you mix these two chemicals together, you get this product. E.t.c. We have vast amounts of 'Human Intelligence' and we have molded that in to our scientific research. Without it, we would be no different to shaven apes!

287 days ago | Side: god
2 points

If a tree is falling, move out of the way, hot things are bad, if there is a cliff don't walk of it.

Yeah. You forget one and they fall like dominoes.

I had a cup of coffee in my hands and, as usual, I forgot it was hot. To make it even worse, I didn't recall at all that I quit drinking that stuff years ago! That hurt quite a bit and put me off balance, didn't even notice the edge behind me. Right down next to a falling tree. I have no idea how I got up there in the first place, last thing I remember was having plans to go to a party... That was years ago, woke up wearing whitish-blue several months back.

I guess this goes under human intelligence.

287 days ago | Side: science
0 points

There is no proof god exists but science is solid and so in turn means that if there is no god then science reins supreme.

285 days ago | Side: science
Popular Debates: After seeing this video can you still respect a cop? In God we trust on American money, Is it Constitutional? Should I change wait-what-no to wait-what-really?



About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons



©2013 TidyLife, Inc. All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Debate Forum | Big shout-outs to The Bloggess and Andy Cohen.