Who is the right girl for sonic the hedgehog
Ok... idk dont know y i did this..... answer it dammmit!
Princess Sally Acorn
Side Score: 6
|
 |
Amy Rose the hedgehog
Side Score: 13
|
|
|
|
|
2
points
Ummm... Really though XDD 1.) I could barley make out what you were saying, so I HOPE that I understood you correctly. Amy has actually proven to be very UNCLINGY after her initial responses to Sonic. Like in Sonci Adventure 2: She was obviously joking with the marriage thing as she let Sonic out even when he said 'No way'. In Sonic Adventure 1, she even protected Gamma from Sonic, and went on her own to defend birdy (Lily in Sonic X) In Sonic Unleashed especially: she was focuses more on helping to save the planet than just being with Sonic. So it's hardly fair to say Amy only 'bugs' Sonic. Sally doesn't have a perfect tract record either: she is actually A LOT more clingy and needy to Sonic in Archie than even Amy is in the same comic. For example: Even when they weren't dating and she saw Mina and Sonic hanging out together so much, she started to get very jealous and possessive. Amy on the other hand, despite Sally and Sonic actually DATING and almost getting MARRIED, she kept her distance from Sonic and respected them both. Also: Amy being so girly? Oh really?! AND Not as cool?! 1.) Amy runs around in a little red dress fighting bad-guys and having FUN. She is also rather violent XD. How is THAT girly? Sally on the other hand actually started focusing a lot on looks in realtivley recent comic issues XD 2.) How is a childish and fun girl with a GIANT HAMMER than can pop out of NOWHERE and replace itself multiple times, less cool than a common smart-girl-"tactical genius"-"beautiful princess"? <__< I find it hard to take THAT seriously XD Side: Amy Rose the hedgehog
1
point
|
2
points
1
point
0
points
Personally, my IDEAL is for Sonic to be single xD, BUT if I would have to pick one I would choose Amy based on how compatible their personalities are.[Depending on media as some media portray her differently out of the writer's own opinion of her character] On the basic levels of personality, I think that Sonic and Amy simply have a better chance of lasting. Sonic, after all, is all about freedom, adventure, and having fun, as well as protecting the people he cares about. He is rash, and short tempered, loyal, and he HATES oppression. He also dislikes tears. Amy Rose is also all about having fun, and having adventure. She is also about as short tempered as Sonic, and like her blue counterpart will go out of her way to protect those being tyrannized. However, Amy is more on the innocent and childish side, and is very spontaneous in her actions which makes her a big ball of fun. She is whimsical. She is also known to be insightful, supportive, kind and understanding when a person really needs it. Sonic is actually more likely to need someone's support than Amy is. [It is a common misconception that Amy is obsessive, but in actually there is evidence that she is actually not quite as clingy as she has appeared. Examples: Sonic Adventure 1, Shadow the Hedgehog, Sonic Universe, Sonic and The Black Knight.] Sally is considered logical, focused and organized. She prefers to plan ahead, take the lead, and compromise. She is passionate and brave, but can also be insecure and "Her personal emotions are sometimes less well-controlled, and under some extreme situations she's fallen into turmoil concerning her relationships with others, especially with her father, King Acorn, and Sonic."+ She has before fostered feelings of betrayal and jealousy, and she has had the tendency to rely much on the support of her friends (Sonic included) Both girls have proven they cold hold their own in battle, and both have proven to be good character in their own rights. However, in conclusion I believe that Sonic and Amy can work better together as Sonic is the type of character who needs freedom, and would completely dislike being smothered. Sonic wouldn't want a person who would always need him for emotional support. Unlike Sally, Amy is the type to support SOMEONE ELSE and rather than let herself feel down she uplifts herself and others. Sonic would also need a girl who would be fun as he could get bored very easily. Amy's spontaneous behavior AND their common needs for adventure and fun make a perfect situation for these two to always be able to have fun with each other in most situations. Amy has also shown that she is less likely to get jealous of another woman. In Archie itself, she actually kept her distance even though she would admit to loving him. However, Sally actually ended up holding a grudge even when she and Sonic weren't dating. Another thing that I like better about Sonamy is, how with these two they can interact with each other, and HINT at a relationship without even needing to make it official, which is good for ALL the fans: the ones who DO like the couple, and DON'T like the couple, as this give the fan the option of choosing instead of the pairing being forced in their face, unlike Sonally, where the couple is ALWAYS forced in the fan's face without giving the fan the chance to decide if they like it. As for the standing now in their relationships: I LIKE how Sonamy's relationship is so flexible, but I HATE how Sonally is so rigid. I at first was okay with Sonally in SATAM, but when they got to Archie I felt that they were trying to force everyone to like the couple by demonizing other rivals for Sonic's affections, and with the writer making story plots that make the couple "word of god". For example: Mobius ___ Years later, Sonic Issue #222, and others. I will say that SEGA has a good chemistry with the two, as they are hinted at but never made official: this actually makes the fan like it more by letting them CHOOSE it themselves. That is my Answer. Please note that I am NOT a general Sonamy fan: I PREFER another couple with Amy in it AND I prefer Sonci being single. However if the need aroused I WOULD choose Sonamy over Sonally. +From Mobius Encyclopedia: [http://archiesonic.wikia.com/wiki/ Side: Amy Rose the hedgehog
Amy may have kept her distance as Sonic dates other girls, but that didn't mean she wasn't jealous of Sonic and Sally's (or Fiona's) relationship. You can see hints of this during Sonic's birthday bash issue. None of this is very compelling. She has similar interests and personality traits, perhaps. But while that may give her reason to be around more than other girls, it doesn't explain what her personality is actually going to add to Sonic's life that he needs. She's spontaneous, but then again Sonic doesn't need Amy to have a spontaneous, on the go life. She may be able to go with the flow, but that doesn't really illustrate that she's adding to anything. I also do not like it when people try to brush aside Amy's major flaws just so that Sonic/Amy looks "perfect." Sonic Adventure 1 was dubbed. We have no idea what it was that Amy was communicating with Sonic. Sonic Universe is an entirely different verse from the games, and it's no point in trying to act as though both are of one storyline when convenient. Black Knight featured another character that took Amy's appearance. The only actual part Amy got was swinging her hammer at Sonic since he'd missed their "date." Not that I see how in character it'd be for Sonic to be leaping to the opportunity to date her. Side: Princess Sally Acorn
0
points
|
