CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
15
Let them upvote, me gusta Stop the up- and downvoting
Debate Score:17
Arguments:14
Total Votes:17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Let them upvote, me gusta (2)
 
 Stop the up- and downvoting (7)

Debate Creator

shoutoutloud(4303) pic



Who is upvoting?

Not too long ago there were extreme downvote trolls - now it seems like we've got some upvote trolls. Odd kind of troll but it is still annoying!

Let them upvote, me gusta

Side Score: 2
VS.

Stop the up- and downvoting

Side Score: 15
1 point

Interesting... I was talking about the possibility of up vote trolls a couple of days ago. I wonder.

Side: Let them upvote, me gusta
1 point

i'm beginning to doubt whether its sarcastic or not. i hope it isn't. either way, it does make me happy. xD

Side: Let them upvote, me gusta
4 points

No worries, I never Upvote.... Yeah, I'm a bitch like that.

Side: Stop the up- and downvoting
3 points

No worries, I never Upvote.... Yeah, I'm a bitch like that.

Side: Stop the up- and downvoting
2 points

Now I just look like a point who're. FML

Side: Stop the up- and downvoting

hahahhahhahahaha :D

Side: Stop the up- and downvoting
3 points

Voting on this site is pretty much worthless.

The system is just an example of ad populumn. So many instances of people stating "I agree" get upvotes, not a very good argument now is it?

The system is prone to abuse as well. Certain members have mass accounts and spam votes both ways to try to sway the numbers. Either they put value on ad populumn measures for the validity of their ideas or they just enjoy a bit of trolling.

Admitedly I have down voted people for using fallacious arguments. I have also upvoted arguments that were well constructed. I assume this was the intention of the system however without any type of justification needed to actually cast the vote the system fails.

Due to these issues I put no value in the stats the system tracks. For instance the "efficiency" number can be greatly skewed by the number of controversial subjects one debates.

Side: Stop the up- and downvoting
Nebeling(1117) Clarified
1 point

I don't think it's worthless. Getting 5+ upvotes probably means that the argument was relevant and true. But if you mean to say that the votes don't have any ultimate authority, then you are obviously right.

Side: Let them upvote, me gusta
J-Roc77(70) Clarified
1 point

Getting upvotes can mean what you imply but there are many instances it does not. JC and his multiple accounts for instance, or the well intentioned Srom just agreeing because he likes the conclusion.

Side: Let them upvote, me gusta
1 point

I wonder if you included the 'me gusta' part to infer it was me :P It isn't me. I used to do it to counteract what the troll was doing.

Side: Stop the up- and downvoting
shoutoutloud(4303) Clarified
1 point

No, why should I infer you're the one who is upvoting?

Besides, I got like .. 5 upvotes on a totally random comment I made, you can't upvote more than one time :)

But are you like .. spanish or do you say me gusta a lot?

Side: Let them upvote, me gusta
Atrag(5666) Clarified
1 point

Fair enough.

I live in Spain.

Side: Let them upvote, me gusta

I thought the whole concept was pretty simple. If you agree with a person and like their argument you vote up and if you disagree with perhaps irreverent or insufficient information you down vote. Why would you abuse that system for entertainment? Do you honestly have nothing better to do?

Side: Stop the up- and downvoting