CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
4

Jerry McNerney (D)


Dean Andal (R)

Debate Score:12
Arguments:8
Total Votes:12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 
Jerry McNerney (D)
(4)
 
 
Dean Andal (R)
(4)

Debate Creator

CreateDebate(732) pic



Who should I vote for in the 2008 California 11th District House of Representatives Race?


Jerry McNerney (D)

Side Score: 8
VS.


Dean Andal (R)

Side Score: 4
3 points

Incumbent McNerey is looking for middle ground in order to establish firm energy policies for the US over the next twenty years. Although he is not in favor of offshore drilling, McNerey does realize that Americans are going to need petroleum for some years yet until biofuels, wind and solar energies can be sufficiently established.

Obama has said that he will approve some off-shore drilling in order to buy some time for environmental research analysts and biofuel producers, and McNerey says that he supports that decision.

McNerey: "We're going to continue to need oil for a long time...there's offshore permits that are available...60% of our offshore oil not being accessed is already available for drilling in the Gulf of Mexico. So we want to go ahead and encourage the oil companies to drill off-shore in already available lands. I don't want to open up new lands because they're not needed."

Indeed, it seems when it comes to the issue of energy and domestic, what Congress needs is Representatives like McNerey who are willing to compromise but stick to their core values at the same time.

McNerey for oil compromise
Side: Jerry McNerney
2 points

Recently, while visiting a work force development summit set up by the Tri-Valley Business Council, Jerry McNerney reemphasized his commitment to renewable energy initiatives and the foundation of a good, accessibly education system.

“No matter how many jobs we create or how much money we spend, if we don’t get kids engaged, we’re going to lose them,” he told the gathering of workers, teachers, and community leaders.

While it is one thing to push for clean energy, it is paramount to our economic investment in renewable resources to begin laying the groundwork for a robust job market and cutting edge operations within the system. McNerney understands that providing excellent educational opportunities and resources to our children and our schools goes hand in hand with our efforts to discover alternative and renewable energy resources. He has called for more federal funding to back math and science education in the public school system and has put his support behind legislation that aims to lower the tuition costs of higher education .

Supporting Evidence: Energy and Education (www.bizjournals.com)
Side: Energy and Education
2 points

You know, I don't think anyone is too happy about the bail out, which McNerney voted for- but I also believe that it had to be done, in one form or other, and I think it was actually brave of McNerney to support it in both incarnations. In fact, if the GOP hadn't acted like a bunch of horses behinds, grandstanding in front of the cameras after the first attempt to pass the bail out, there would be $140 billion less in pork included in the deal. Thanks a lot, Republican members of the house. McNerney is a realist, a pragmatic politician with experience and vision, as shown by his approach to new energy. (see his post on Huffington Post below). I grew up in that area, and people that I know and have trusted all my life agree with me the McNerney is the man to vote for come November.

Supporting Evidence: McNerney blog on Huffington Post (www.huffingtonpost.com)
Side: Jerry McNerney
1 point

McNerney has substantially out raised his opponent to the tune of more than double. Both raise approximately 1/3 of their money from PACs

Supporting Evidence: fund raising (www.opensecrets.org)
Side: Jerry McNerney
1 point

Republican Congressional candidate, Dean Andal, is running his campaign on the bet that a smart, conservative, fiscally responsible message will appeal to voters who are both frustrated with the rise of unemployment and gas prices as the economy seems to be growing increasingly unstable.

Andal is promising to provide companies with tax cuts, rather than more taxes, to free up corporate finances to provide more and better jobs to the American people. As companies are given more financial freedoms, the more they will be willing to invest in new innovations and ventures that will create more jobs and offer the stimulation our economy seems to be lacking.

Supporting Evidence: Andal and Fiscal Responsibility (www.deanandal.com)
Side: Andal and Fiscal Responsibility
1 point

McNerney is an Obama supporter, but has indirectly supported Bush's neocon agenda by voting against beginning a withdrawal of our troops from Iraq in 90 days and in favor of the FISA amendments. He should also be taken to task for saying he would support preemptive war. Andal may not be much different in these respects, but voters are responsible to contact each of the candidates and let them know their opinions to make possible a change of mind.

Side:
Dean Andal (R)
1 point

Republican candidate Dean Andal has picked up the endorsement of BIPAC, Business Industry PAC this week

Side: Dean Andal
1 point

Congressman McNerney has supported both versions of the Wall Street bailout bill (see here and here). It's probably too late at this point for him and most of his fellow Democrats to convince voters that they are still trustworthy with their tax dollars when it's been feared all along that this measure would bring on another Great Depression as well as some finishing touches to Bush's overall agenda.

Side:
Dean Andal (R)