CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
2

Tim Walz (D)


Brian Davis (R)

Debate Score:4
Arguments:4
Total Votes:4
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 
Tim Walz (D)
(2)
 
 
Brian Davis (R)
(2)

Debate Creator

CreateDebate(732) pic



Who should I vote for in the 2008 Minnesota 1st District House of Representatives Race?


Tim Walz (D)

Side Score: 2
VS.


Brian Davis (R)

Side Score: 2
1 point

In an effort to bridge the partisan divide in the House, Tim Walz (D), along with 20 other congressmen and women (equally divided between Republicans and Democrats,) joined together to form the Bipartisan House Energy Working Group to directly address possible short-term, mid-term, and long-term solutions to America's energy crisis and dependence on foreign oil.

The group drafted the National Conservation, Environment and Energy Independence Act, which operates in three parts:

1. "America must produce more of our oil and gas at home because we can’t keep buying it from countries that all too often do not have America’s best interests at heart."

2. "We must promote new alternative and renewable sources of energy, which requires a dedicated funding stream for research and development."

3. "We need to expand our domestic energy production in an environmentally smart way so our energy and economic future is sustainable."

The bill supports lifting the ban on offshore drilling and tapping into the petroleum reserves along the Outer Continental Shelf. By drilling offshore no less than 25 miles off compliant states' coastlines, Walz argues, we as a nation can begin to untie ourselves from foreign sources, provide ourselves the financial freedoms to pursue alternative and renewable energy resources, and invest in the research and technologies to utilize them.

Supporting Evidence: National Conservation Environment and Energy Act (walz.house.gov)
Side: National Conservation Environment and E
1 point

True to his plan for US economic revival which refused any golden parachutes for Wall Street and rejected any plan for bailout, Walz voted against the revised proposal for a Wall Street bailout last week. He insists that the bill, which received scrutiny from the beginning for not providing taxpayers with sufficient coverage in exchange for their $700 billion, is still not secure for the American middle-class.

Walz says he refuses to support a bill that sends billions of dollars abroad to foreign banks to cover mistakes made by financial investors and provides little chance of homeowners getting mortgage relief. Strip away all of the little add-ons from the Senate, says Walz, and you have the same piece of legislation.

Walz: “I’m disappointed that instead the Senate sent this bill back to the House with $100 billion in unpaid for additional spending that will be added directly to the national debt. Further, it saddens me that I must vote against this bailout which includes provisions that I’ve long supported such as the Wellstone Mental Health Parity Act and the renewable energy tax incentives. Now that this bill has gone through, we must begin investigating why this crisis happened and what must be done to make sure this never happens again.”

Supporting Evidence: Walz rejects bailout again (www.timwalz.org)
Side: Tim Walz
1 point

Not much is known about the Republican Congress Candidate for Montana’s 1st District Brian Davis except the fact that he is well-educated. Mr. Davis has a MD, University of Illinois

Ph.D., Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1990

Masters, Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1984

BS, Nuclear Engineering, University of Illinois in Champaign-Urbana, 1982.

It was hard to search on Google his campaign website however; if you research on Vote Smart you can immediately find his campaign.

Continuing on, Mr. Davis seems to be a breath of fresh air especially with his educational background but researching more you find that the Republican Candidate is more of the same, “We should work to support the democratically elected governments of Iraq and Afghanistan for as long as we can and as long as these governments support our presence,” and “I believe we must be open to addressing and adapting our strategy in the current conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan.”

Mr. Davis has supposed Conservative values but has, according to his Conservative Value webpage, little understanding of the United States Constitution, “we need to protect the institution of marriage. The union between one man and one woman is a fundamental building block of our society.” Why not leave it up to the states?

Nevertheless, I would like to hear more from Mr. Brian Davis.

Davis March
Side: Brian Davis
1 point

When Brian Davis won his primary it was with a strong margin, as the video below discuss.

Brian Davis HQ
Side: Brian Davis