Who should I vote for in the 2008 New Hampshire Senate Race?
|
![]() |
|
|
Given that this year's election is a rematch between Shaheen and Sununu and that the validity of Sununu's "victory" in 2002 is questionable at best, Shaheen seems to be the stronger candidate in the New Hampshire Senate Race. Her support for middle class tax cuts, a stronger, more robust public education system, and her goal to lower the cost of health care are all major issues that have left the majority of New Hampshire citizens (if not quite a few Americans) skeptical of any Republican platform.
Supporting Evidence:
Phone Scandal
(en.wikipedia.org)
Posted 116 days ago | Tagged As: Shaheen for Senate
Government's only purpose is to protect our rights and liberties. It should not be responsible for what happens in the economy, health care, or education, which are better left in the hands of individuals. Otherwise, the taxes we pay are spent unwisely. Shaheen is unlikely to favor repealing the 16th amendment or abolishing the IRS or the Federal Reserve. Posted 116 days ago
A complete lack of government influence on the conditions of our health care, education, and economic systems will only increase the amount of families who can't afford health insurance, education (especially college), and will continue the investment practices that have driven so many corporations to increase profit margins overseas. While I can sympathize with (what I sense is) the libertarian streak of your arguments, I am also aware of the dangers that can result if the health and education of our youth and the conditions and security of our jobs is left completely within the hands of the private sector. Sununu may stand apart from the "Bush" Republicans on certain issues, but he has consistently stood beside decisions that have left thousands if not millions of children with no access to (at least some) health care and allowed them to persist in under-funded educational systems.
Supporting Evidence:
Sununu on Education
(www.stopsununu.com)
Posted 116 days ago | Tagged As: Sununu on Education
Shaheen is for taxes, she created the first NH property tax and proposed a sales tax. As for education in 2002 NH received a D rating from "Education Week"magazine . Also the High School drop out rate was 25% under her governance. Posted 109 days ago | Tagged As: Shaheen's Failures
There is exactly 0 pieces of evidence that Sununu had any knowledge of the phone jamming scandal. It was perpetrated by a few bad apples who ultimately got what they deserved. Trying to use this against Sununu simply reiterates that lack of arguments Shaheen supporters have when it come to talking about real issues. When it comes down to the issues, Sununu will stand toe-to-toe against Shaheen and cruch her. Posted 92 days ago | Tagged As: Phone Jamming Had No Effect on Race
To some extent I agree with you. Yes, the phone tapping scandal is a typical weapon used by New Hampshire Democrats to attack the Senate seat of John Sununu. Yet, I can't agree with the implication that unethical election practices (whether they determined the winner or not) in our democratic system are not to be considered "real" issues facing the voters of America. The fairness, efficiency, and integrity of how these elections are executed with ALL votes being considered is a paramount issue facing our political process in American in the 21st Century. Granted, Sununu has not yet proven and (I'll agree) was probably not ever involved in the phone scandal that has shadowed his last campaign against Shaheen, but the issue is still an issue and is a very "real" issue facing our political process. Posted 86 days ago | Tagged As: Voting Process an Issue
You may be right there. However, Sununu has to be aware of the fact that having a shadow like that in his past (even if he wasn't "directly" involved) still affects voters' perception as it will likely find its way into the campaign ads of Jeanne Shaheen. And, although its a sad state of affairs, a large percentage of how this country votes is based on perception rather than a critical analysis of the issues. I'm crossing my fingers and typing on this site every living day hoping that that fact changes this year, but I'm not naive to think that a Republican incumbent in this year's election, who has been through and through the Bush era, won't be harmed politically by a stain in his record such as a phone tapping scandal. The way to sift through the dross, as you said, is to get these folks under the same roof and hash out the real issues face-to-face. And it's our responsibility to tune in. So, October 21, 2008. We'll be tuning in...
Supporting Evidence:
Sununu Shaheen Debate
(www.derrynews.com)
Posted 85 days ago | Tagged As: Sununu Shaheen Debate
Senator John Sununu won a clear and "valid" victory over Jeanne Shaheen in the 2002 U.S. Senate race. Even though some Republican Party operatives made some 800 phone calls that jammed some Shaheen GOTV (get out the vote) phones in the Manchester area for two hours, Sununu still won the race by more than 20,000 votes. "Phone-gate" had little effect.
Supporting Evidence:
Phone-Jamming Did Not Change Outcome
(en.wikipedia.org)
Posted 109 days ago | Tagged As: Phone Jamming Had No Effect on Race
Whether or not the phone-jamming incident in the 2002 New Hampshire Senate race did or did not affect the outcome (which, as has been pointed out, it didn't,) the issue is the ethical standards to which we hold our democratic process and the government officials we vote for to insure its effeciency. I've searched for substantial evidence or a statement clarifying Sununu's or his campaign's response to or knowledge of the implementation of the phone jamming to no avail. If you could find something on Sununu's comments regarding the arrests of Tobin and McGee, please let me know. Posted 108 days ago | Tagged As: Sununu's Comments
That is a very heavy "If" in regards to Sununu's being convinced to vote in favor of beginning to withdraw our troops from Iraq. Granted, while Sununu's opposition to the Patriot Act and his support for clean energy are strong (and refreshing) stands by a Republican Senator, the impact of our continued involvement in Iraq is and will continue to have a dramatic impact on our economic ability to pursue clean energy and improve our current domestic economic crisis. Jeanne Shaheen supports the efforts towards Clean Energy and she is also against a prolonged U.S. military presence in Iraq.
Supporting Evidence:
Iraq Withdrawal
(www.jeanneshaheen.org)
Posted 116 days ago | Tagged As: Shaheen on Iraq
Shaheen was the national chairperson for John Kerry's presidential campaign in 2004. But Mr. Kerry voted to authorize the war and is now endorsing Obama, who despite his rhetoric has been supportive of the war by his votes to fund it. This just goes to show that most Democrats by practice are pro-war and have been for many years.
Supporting Evidence:
Shaheen's role in John Kerry's presidential campaign
(en.wikipedia.org)
Posted 116 days ago
Fair enough. However, a decision to vote for financial measures that insure the stability and safety of our troops currently in Iraq that is founded on a declared commitment to a planned withdrawal (and, therefore, an specified point of ending the increase of funding) is completely different than making the same decision with no clear commitment or agreement that our troops should or will ever be withdrawn from Iraq (and, thus, an open-ended extension of increasing our financial obligations there.) I won't argue that Democrats (or Shaheen) "by practice" aren't pro-war (I think it's irresponsible and dangerous to be completely "anti-war" in this day in age.) The issue is the wisdom of with whom, how, and why we should go to war and the Iraq War was a poor decision both economically and for our foreign relations (and Shaheen is aligned with a stronger emphasis on diplomacy rather than the aggressive, impulsive use of military force.)
Supporting Evidence:
(Obama on supporting Iraq funding)
(www.boston.com)
Posted 116 days ago | Tagged As: Iraq Funding
Both candidates in the tight U.S. Senate race in New Hampshire have ties to the Middle East. Incumbent Senator John E. Sununu has Lebanese and Palestinian heritage from his father's side, former three-term governor John H. Sununu, who was also White House Chief of Staff for President George H.W. Bush. Former Gov. Sununu was the only U.S. governor to oppose a resolution among governors to repeal an anti-Israeli United Nations resolution that "Zionism Equals Racism." He later reversed himself. Bill Shaheen, husband of former Gov. Jeanne Shaheen and a former U.S. Attorney for the District of New Hampshire, also has Lebanese heritage and family ties to the Middle East. A former state chairman for the campaigns of Jimmy Carter, Al Gore, and Hillary Clinton, Mr. Shaheen has expressed interest in being part of a negotiating team to bring peace to the Middle East if Democrats win the White House. The scandal involving the jamming of Shaheen 2002 Seante Campaign's phone lines in the Manchester area continues to damage the New Hampshire Republican Party (see link). Caught playing dirty on Election Day 2002, the state GOP lost two Congressinal seats in the 2004 election and two men went to federal prison. The ironic point about the phone jamming of Shaheen's get-out-the-vote effort is that Sununu won that election by 20,000 votes, while the two-hours of phone jamming prevented 800 phone calls. Sununu still would have won by more than 19,000 votes. Voters still angry over this illegal behavior, both Repulican and Democrat, may give Shaheen the edge in this rematch, even though there is no evidence that Sununu was involved.
Supporting Evidence:
Phone-Gate Helps Shaheen
(en.wikipedia.org)
Posted 115 days ago | Tagged As: Honest and Fair Campaigns Matter
On Monday of this week (August 11th), both Shaheen and Sununu released statements in support of tax incentives for energy developers and users of clean energy in hopes that these breaks will help to invigorate our economy and eventually lower gas and oil prices. Although both of the candidates are very closely aligned in regards to clean energy policies and initiatives, Sununu is strongly in favor of lifting the ban on offshore drilling while Shaheen claims that the oil companies need to continue drilling on the lands they have already leased. She opposes the congressional trend of resorting to the oil industries to determine effective legislation on energy policies and is firmly committed to investing more in efforts to develop alternative and renewable resources apart from oil. A commitment to unchaining our economic dependence on the oil industry will provide long-term opportunities and benefits to our economic stability and progress, our national security, and the preservation of the environment.
Supporting Evidence:
Tax Incentives
(www.boston.com)
Posted 100 days ago | Tagged As: Tax Incentives
In a rematch from 2002, former Democratic Governor Jeanne Shaheen again challenges Republican John E. Sununu to represent New Hampshire in the United States Senate. Sununu, the youngest U.S. Senator at age 44, is a close ally of the Republican nominee for president, Senator John McCain. Polling has consistently shown Shaheen in the lead, with the current Rasmussen poll showing a tightening race, 51% to 45% for Sununu. Shaheen supported removing Saddam Hussein from power. This was no different than the Republican platform before the war started. Even if Hussein had been a real threat, the Iraqi people should have been allowed to take care of him themselves. Bush illegally intervened and broke his promise of no nation-building. What we need in office is someone who will stand up for what is right to do scientifically. Sununu could have overturned the vote for President Bush's veto of embryonic stem cell research, but accepted the Presidents decision instead. This country frequently has an abundance of money, life, and know how, and losing 7 years of ingenuity in any one scientific field is a travesty. We should be moving forward on many planes, and be discovering new technologies to utilize. Shaheen has come out to say she will.
Supporting Evidence:
Shaheen outlines plan for scientific leadership
(www.boston.com)
Posted 116 days ago | Tagged As: Shaheen on Science
Jeanne Shaheen has had the experience of working as an Governor. Does the experience within the executive branch translate into success in a bipartisian matter. She claims to have developed a biparitisian energy policy. With the Senator not expected to reach a 60 vote majority for either party will she prove able to partner in bipartisian solution to problems Posted 116 days ago
Sen. Sununu's Campaign manager has admitted to receiving illicit funds for their running in the election, but has only agreed to donate a portion of it to charity. Former Governor Shaheen has called for the entirety of the illicit contributions to be returned to the correct people or donated. I tend to agree with her.
Supporting Evidence:
Article from the unionleader.com
(www.unionleader.com)
Posted 116 days ago | Tagged As: Illicit Campaign Funds
Governor's typically make better Presidential bids than Senators. If Shaheen can do a cleaner job than Sunnunu and exercise better fiscal judgement about things like, the war -you are looking at a very close race. The two are virtually the same on many issues. While Sunnunu grabbed his chance to call for Alberto Gonzalez's resignation, he can't quite get Abramoff's stink off. Scandal has nipped at Sunnunu's heels during his current tour in the U.S. senate. While Sunnunu's stance on civil liberties has been on the progressive side -I think Shaheen should have a shot at representing what she knows is on New Hampshire's radar. Civil liberties is considered a given for the Live Free or Die State. Posted 106 days ago | Tagged As: Sununu's Senate Experience
Shaheen is most definitely a progressive when it comes to federal programs and medical research. She openly supports a new policy in Washington for stem cell research and hopes that New Hampshire will benefit from new medical breakthroughs in progressive science. She is unabashedly and passionately for a positive turnabout in the medical community to assist cancer patients without much hope in an area where money and time has been long diverted in the name of morality and religious ethics. Shaheen: "These lines of research could hold the key to cures for diabetes, Parkinson's, spinal cord injuries – they could impact the lives of families like ours all across the country. We have already lost seven years in the development of potential treatments and cures – we can't afford to lose any more time. But we're not going to see a change in stem cell research policy until we change Senators. "
Supporting Evidence:
Shaheen supports cancer research
(www.jeanneshaheen.org)
Posted 95 days ago | Tagged As: Stem cell
|









