CreateDebate


Debate Info

140
102

Rick Noriega (D)


John Cornyn (R)

Debate Score:242
Arguments:55
Total Votes:295
Ended:11/05/08
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 
Rick Noriega (D)
(30)
 
 
John Cornyn (R)
(25)

Debate Creator

CreateDebate(732) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Who should I vote for in the 2008 Texas Senate Race?


Rick Noriega (D)

Side Score: 140
Winning Side!
VS.


John Cornyn (R)

Side Score: 102
11 points

John Cornyn's tenure in the Senate has been one of total support for George Bush's agenda. He's considered a buddy and reliable ally for our tempestuous boy king and whatever Dick's whispering in his majesty's ear it's inevitable Cornyn will be along for the ride -- even when the rodeo is over.

Corny has proven himself to be part and parcel of the ruinous clique that's brought this country to the very brink of disaster. As it stands today he'll be a reliable buddy and ally for McCain or a thorn in Obama's side. Either way he's a impediment to progress... and a wasted vote

Side: John Cornyn
7 points

This article from today's Houston Chronicle details John Cornyn's political ambitions within the Senate. It paints a picture of a man who cares about his Party more than he cares about his constituency. Here's a line that really jumped out at me:

"Congressional Quarterly studies found Cornyn tied three fellow Republican senators for following the party line on Senate votes in 2006 and 2007. He ranked third among Senate Republicans in his support of President Bush in those years."

Some might find this a negative, some might not. I think this race is an interesting example of that question American voters often ask themselves: am I voting for the person or the party?

Side: Texas Senate Race
6 points

Naturally, immigration is an important topic for both Cornyn and Noriega to address in Texas. Noriega's stance is steady: the influx of immigrants, drug smuggling and human trafficking from Mexico to Texas must cease. How? By cracking down on businesses that hire illegal workers and replacing the incompetent "fence" with increased technology that relies on surveillance and increased man-power (18,000 border patrol guards) to keep the border secure. Not only is the influx of cheap labor causing people to scrap by living under minimum wage, but under Cornyn’s previous legislature, illegal immigrants were permitted to stay and work without applying for the guest-worker program as others must do. Employers then see no reason to pay them fairly because, officially, the workers don't exist. In essence, the problem is being fed from both ends.

Noriega doesn’t want immigrants to have to hide, trapped behind minimum wages and cheap labor bosses. His plan is to "release Washington gridlock" by implementing a rigorous but reasonable re-entry program for immigrants eligible for citizenship, and helping to regulate overflow by engaging Mexico in the immigrant organization.

Supporting Evidence: Rick Noriega Immigration reform (www.ricknoriega.com)
Side: Immigrants
5 points

Immigration does stand as one of the most pressing issues in this year's election at the national level and even more so for the 2008 Texas Senate race. Cornyn and Noriega each represent the ideological poles that have kept productive legislation on immigration reform in a literal stalemate on the Senate floor.

While the Cornyn campaign has countered Noriega's critique of the "fence" plan by referring to the "80 U.S. Senators - including Barack Obama" who support the idea, it is important to note that Rick Noriega has served as Lt. Colonel of the Texas National Guard and Laredo Border Sector Commander in Operation Jump Start. His firsthand experience, exposure, and knowledge of our borders and the obstacles posed to our security offer a valuabe and much-needed contribution to our legislative perspective on the issue of immigration reform.

Supporting Evidence: Noriega's Experience (securingamerica.com)
Side: Border Patrol Experience
hlafon(12) Disputed
7 points

Your top two statements don't actually have any relation to each other - Texas may have the most uninsured in the nation (not by much), but actually, they have the easiest access to healthcare. Secondly, while John Cornyn never voted for a Noriega's state prescription drug plan, he clearly supports federal medicare drug programs. Noriega's so-called health care "plans" are vague, impractical and darn near impossible - as pie-in-the-sky as his energy "plan."

Side:
John Cornyn (R)
iamdavidh(4856) Disputed
5 points

You may be right about pie-in-the-sky, but at least it is something different. And good access to healthcare is important, but doesn't do a whole lot of good if you can't pay for it. I think that an attempt at least should be made to insure more people. Being 50 out of 50 in number of people covered is a very bad stat, even if it's "not by much" as you say.

Side: Rick Noriega
5 points

In 2003, former PA Senator Rick Santorum became infamous for comparing gay marriage to "man on dog." Today, Santorum's gone, but John Cornyn – who is more concerned with men and box turtles – is still around.

So while this country faces a soaring deficit, a health care crisis, and two difficult wars, John Cornyn is concerning himself with the haunting specter of man-on-box-turtle.

Texans deserve a Senator who will help solve the real issues, not imaginary ones. John Cornyn voted with the Bush Administration 96% of the time. That's compounding our problems, not solving them.

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn Votes With Bush (capitolannex.com)
Side: Rick Noriega
5 points

Energy policy has become one of the more pivotal issues in the 2008 elections with more attention focused on the oil vs. alternative energy question that at any time since the Arab oil embargo of the early 1970s. Both Noriega and Cornyn are saying the politically correct things: take a comprehensive approach involving more exploration and drilling here at home while investing in alternative energy technologies. However, rhetoric is one thing and voting record another. Cornyn consistently has come out against measures designed to promote alternative energy technologies and instead clearly demonstrates his Big Oil bias in his Senate voting record. Would Noriega be better? The record speaks for itself; at least he couldn't be worse.

Supporting Evidence: John Cornyn Consistently Votes for Big Oil (ontheissues.org)
Side: Rick Noriega
7 points

Agreed. Noriega is a great favorite where I live (Austin and San Marcos), but even though I am a progressive, I have read his energy proposal and have a few problems with it.

For one: his plan calls for 100% Texas renewable energy by 2019. This is incredibly optimistic. How exactly will he go about insuring that the state which is a "world leader" as he puts it, in energy producing 16% and consuming 12% of US resources, will suddenly turn dramatically around to green energy? How can this be done? Noriega cites many answers to the Texas renewable energy issue, primarily wind and biomass energy which is obviously not an issue in 266,807 sq. miles of flatlands and minor hills. Land isn't a problem of course, to Noriega and Cornyn, but what about environmental issues?

Noriega also calls for the budget to extend another $5 billion to transport energy from solar generator and windmills, which means putting wires across the landscape to carry current and the disruption of Texas wildlife. The plan does say some positive things, ie. cutting US expenditure on foreign oil and resources, and prohibiting off-shore drilling. Absolute positives and necessary, but these problems have taken decades if not centuries to stew. It is the 11th hour so to speak, and it's obvious actions must be taken.

Unfortunately, for the most part, the plan talks of destruction for production. For some reason, this just sounds half-baked...

Now, I'm a Texan and happy to be one, but I'm a progressive first. Doesn't it seem like the big picture is being somewhat ignored?

Supporting Evidence: Noriega's energy plan (www.ricknoriega.com)
Side: Rick Noriega
5 points

When it comes to health care, Texas has the highest number of uninsured employed adults in the US (26.6%). Obviously, amendments must be made to the current state (and federal) legislation to provide affordable medical coverage to Texans.

Noriega has voted to expand the Children's Health Insurance legislation, co-wrote legislation to provide $3 billion more in funding to the research center for Cancer Prevention and the Research Institute of Texas, and voted "yes" to legislation to give financial assistance to those Medicare and the disabled through prescription price reductions.

Supporting Evidence: Medicare bill (video.google.com)
Side: Health care
5 points

Texas needs new leadership and that is why voters should take a chance on Rick Noriega, a former Army veteran and experienced state legislature.

In contrast Senator John Cornyn's embrace of more and more drilling exemplifies the type of old thinking that is leading us into a rut. The future of oil drilling is a great idea 50 years ago, but now we are in an era of high gas prices and shrinking oil resources. Drilling may alleviate some effects. It cannot stop this worsening trend.

On the other hand, investing in a new energy economy will create new America jobs, lower energy costs in the long run, and free us from dependence on Middle Eastern Oil.

Cornyn is the old economy. It's time for him to go.

Side: Texas Senate Race
5 points

I'm with SmokingGun and others. I just emailed Cornyn & Hutchinson for trying to porkbarrel funding continuation of the renewable energy program. Republicans (which they are - not representatives of the best interest of the land and people of Texas or the USA) are stalemating funding of this bill unless measures for offshore drilling are included. I suggested they draft their own offshore drilling bill and try to pass it off as "good" for us, instead of sabotaging a worthwhile program in our best interest. You too can write Cornyn and the other Republican clone posing as a Texas Senator, Kay Bailey Hutchinson and let them know what you think. They know for every message that someone goes to the trouble to send, there are at least 2000 others who think the same. While you're at it, copy the message you send to them to your congressman insisting they lean on "our" senators.

Side: Rick Noriega
5 points

As a native Texan and current (grateful) resident of Austin, Texas, I am well aware of the massive hurdles that Rick Noriega has to leap over in order to have even the slightest chance of beating Republican candidate Cornyn for the Texas seat in the U. S. Senate.

Yet, I suppose that the one issue that weighs considerably on the minds of the majority of Texas voters is immigration and it will be interesting to see how much immigration policy becomes the resonating focal point of any (if not all) debates between these two candidates.

Noriega holds a significant ace-up-his-sleeve in this issue due to the fact that he serves an active role in border patrol as lieutenant colonel of the National Guard. Just last year he was involved in a six month patrol of the border along the Laredo sector (a hot bed of violence and drug smuggling to rival Miami in the 1970s) during which five tons of marijuana and nearly a half ton of harder drugs were confiscated.

Noriega's stance on immigration is smart, derived from years of experience, and anything but soft (a particular complaint of Texas conservatives against more liberal policies for immigration reform.)

Keep a close eye on Noriega and Cornyn on immigration in Texas. This could be the deciding issue for many Texas voters.

Supporting Evidence: Noriega and immigration (www.dallasnews.com)
Side: Noriega and immigration
5 points

Senator Cornyn went to UTEP to discuss his platform yesterday and was instead given a lesson by law enforcement at UTEP regarding arms trafficking across the US-Mexico border. The University recently put in a Border Control and Immigration Center on campus.

Caught unawares Cornyn publicly admitted that he was aware of the trafficking problem, but as it was, lacked enough information to be able to do anything about it. He did affirm the severity of the issue stating:

Cornyn:"I do know it is an ongoing concern of law enforcement officials in Mexico, and certainly the viciousness and violence of cartels is a something that is a little hard for people on this side to comprehend".

Shouldn't an admittedly large problem such as arms trafficking and cross-border cartels be an issue logged for immediate attention?

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn at UTEP (www.kfoxtv.com)
Side: New Border problems
5 points

According to Chron.com Democratic Senator Candidate and Congressman from Texas District 145 in Eastern Houston Rick Noriega laid out a comprehensive immigration reform plan, which, was very similar to the reforms last year proposed in the House.

''Without question we know as a matter of fact that Mr. Cornyn was an obstructionist on the last debate on comprehensive immigration reform,'' Noriega said. ''He hasn't done anything in six years to help reform immigration.'' While bashing Republican Senator Jim Cornyn, Mr. Noriega had given a couple of details to his project: 1) A path to citizenship and 2) The use of technology instead of a border fence.

In 1979 Mr. Noriega joined the United States military in wake of the Iranian Hostage Crisis and became a Lieutenant Colonel. Recently, he did serve in Afghanistan due to the September 11th attacks.

Of the last ten elections Mr. Noriega has been a part of, seven of them have been unopposed and therefore has received 100% of the vote. His last election that he ran against was in 2000 for the State House #145 in the General Election. The Congressman’s opponent was Republican Michael Bunch and successfully defeated him with a 72% to 28% victory.

Supporting Evidence: Houston News (www.chron.com)
Side:
Rick Noriega (D)
4 points

The Houston Chronicle on August 13 quoted an out-of-touch John Cornyn claiming that "Texas is a national model for improving access to health care because it limited lawsuits against doctors." The Chronicle noted ironically that Texas is the state with the highest share of population without health insurance.

Cornyn explained his questionable logic by saying that the passage of Proposition 12, limiting damage awards against doctors in malpractice cases, created greater access to quality health care in Texas because it attracted more doctors to the state. After the speech Cornyn did admit that he wasn't proud that 26% of the Texas population has no health insurance but continued to boast saying that he wanted to make the rest of the U.S. like Texas.

Cornyn, according to the Chronicle, was also one of only 18 senators who opposed the expansion the Children's Health Insurance Program.

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn Cites Texas as National Model for Health Care (www.chron.com)
Side: Health care
4 points

Cornyn has openly embraced McCain's plan to push Americans to buy into their own health insurance programs rather than opt for employer-provided coverage.

According to Noriega spokesperson, Martine Apodaca, the proposed $5000 tax cuts that McCain is promising will fail to adequately provide the amount necessary for Americans to shoulder the financial burden outside of the benefits most of them receive from their employers.

"Cornyn thinks forcing Texas families to fend for themselves in the individual insurance market is better than the employer based health care system. But people don't choose to be sick like they choose to buy a car or a pair of shoes. Under the Cornyn scheme, the majority of Texans would be paying higher taxes, paying more for less coverage and employers would lose incentives to offer health insurance to their employees."

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn McCain Plan (trailblazersblog.dallasnews.com)
Side: Cornyn McCain Plan
4 points

Noriega's plans for health care reform have, up until recently, been fine ethically, but logistically shady. He is now beginning to draw firmer outlines for his constituents, building a comprehensive list of problems and their matching fixers to give Texans new hope in terms of affordable health care.

Noriega's statement on health care:

"In Texas, over 20 percent of children are not covered by health insurance [the highest number in the country].

My health care plan reflects my long-time advocacy of expanding coverage to children. As a state representative, I helped increase coverage to more than 500,000 children, sponsored legislation that eliminated bureaucratic 90-day waiting lists, and led efforts to allow families to deduct child care costs while the state determined their eligibility status."

To answer this problem, Noriega wishes to introduce a sort of middle man , an "insurance connector" to link Texans with suitable insurance plans. Texans who make too much money to qualify for Medicare but too little to provide their families with ample coverage will be able to receive discounts relative to their pay and household number.

Supporting Evidence: Noriega's detailed speech on health care (www.ricknoriega.com)
Side: Comprehensive health care
3 points

Cornyn recently praised the Texas healthcare program (under Proposition 12) boasting that it should be the national model for how healthcare should be approached by the federal government. The basis of his claim was the fact that it had limited the lawsuits and malpractice suits against doctors and, therefore, more doctors had kept their jobs.

However, even Cornyn had to admit the inexcusable reality that up to 26% of Texas' population is without health insurance. Cornyn was also one of the 18 Senators out of 100 who voted against the expansion of the Children's Health Insurance Program last year.

With our current economic downturn and increasing unemployment rates, Texas needs a Senator who views the success of its healthcare system in both the terms of the job security of its doctors as well as the amount of people who have access to medical services.

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn's Healthcare Fallout (www.chron.com)
Side: Cornyn's Healthcare Fallout
3 points

Upon first appearances, between Rick Noriega and incumbent Texas Senator John Cornyn, my vote would go to Noriega. He is a Democrat, the political party position I commonly lean to. He would be new blood in Washington, something this reporter thinks needs to occur more often. And he is a veteran who served in Afghanistan after 9/11. However, when one looks at the issues, I am reluctant to say – though must, that his opponent, John Cornyn has a better understanding of and conviction toward important issues facing American’s today.

Blah, the above paragraph is how this reporter started this article: But it is taking a turn. Instead of the run of the mill article simply comparing and contrasting the issues widely accepted as those that are important to the American people and the politicians, this reporter is, for once, going to attempt to get to a deeper issue – that issue being that neither candidate is going to be good for this country – this country in its original ideal sense, preceded by the Enlightenment and its thinkers, and the Founding Fathers.

As a Republican, Mr. Cornyn states he is for little government, yet his voting record and conviction about pertinent issues illustrate otherwise. There are many examples, from government bailouts to National Security. As a Democrat, Rick Noriega claims to be ok with more government regulation. This is just one example today shared by each of the candidates of the ubiquity in our nation where both the politician’s and their constituent’s are naïve.

Mr. Noriega will not be discussed in conjunction to the issue of big government, because he does not claim otherwise. Mr. Cornyn is a different matter. He is a Republican. He supposedly stands for small government, yet his voting record, positions on matters and issues of import contradicts his purported conviction.

On his official website, Mr. Cornyn is presented, very effectively, to be a steward of bringing about governmental transparency. The problem is not that he is trying to bring about transparency in the government; the problem is complex in that government transparency has eroded exponentially since 9/11, continues to be eroded, and, despite the Senator’s flight of the imagination spin that he stands for change, such braggadocios legislation/agenda to-tailing will not return affairs of reality of our government to pre - 9/11 transparency.

The most blatant example of how the wool is being pulled over the American citizen’s eyes in the supposed governmental transparency movement is today seen with the Freedom of Information Act, (FOIA). Mr. Cornyn’s motions and support for the New Open FOIA Bill will not offset the obfuscating effects of New Executive Order 13,292, signed by President Bush Jr. on March 25, 3003 – Further Amendment to Executive Order 12958 (most recently amended by Mr. William Clinton, in 1995).

A blaring discomfiture with Executive Order 13,292 is that it is a reversal, so to speak, of governmental privilege in keeping secrets from the American Citizen which is now afforded to corporations.

Executive Order 13,292’s most challenged addendum is the reclassification of classified information on "infrastructure,” renumbered in Section 1.4(g), which affords classification of corporate information deemed valuable for National Security. When one tries to find out what is classified as “critical” information, the ambiguity afforded corporations is palpable.

Critical Infrastructure is defined by 1016(e) 107-56 42 USC 5195c(e), as being virtual or physical property “so vital to the United States that the incapacity or destruction of such systems and assets would have a debilitating impact on security, national economic security, national public health or safety, or any combination of those matters.”

It is disturbing that the definition of “Critical Infrastructure” is so vague. It is startling that the definition is so redundant and circular. In plain English, the definition of Critical Infrastructure is something (anything) privately held which is exempted from FIOA for National Security purposes because it is so important to our National Security. The New Open FOIA Bill speaks nothing about the chipping away of information the American Citizen may access with juvenile logic and language that “X” “Y”, and “Z” is justifiably secret because it is secret. Where is the accountability, the transparency, behind this thinking? The Founding Fathers are turning over in their graves.

Side: Transparency FOIA Executive Order
3 points

It seems, according to the Rasmussen Report from September 29th, that Rick Noriega has pulled within 10 percentage points to Sen John Cornyn (R) as we head into the last month before the November 4th election.

The Democratic hopeful trails by 7 points, 43 to Cornyn's 50, and many of the political analysts in the state of Texas are starting to murmur about the possibility of a Republican Senate seat being occupied by a Democrat. It's been over a decade since Bob Krueger (D) sat in the Senate and Noriega's campaign may just have enough steam to heat up the state's Democratic base to send him to Washington, D.C.

Supporting Evidence: A New Hope (www.pollster.com)
Side: Noriega Democratic Hope
2 points

Rick Noriega (D) spelled out his education plan to a crowd gathered in front of an elementary school in east Austin.

He is proposing to push congress to lock in the tuition fee for students during their first year and carrying that fee through their four years rather than leaving the rate open to increase every year.

He is also calling for a restructuring of the No Child Left Behind Act that will shift its emphasis away from student testing. In addition, he supports an increase of funding towards Headstart and other pre-school programs as well as federal grant and loan programs at the college level.

Cornyn's rebuttal questioned the total cost of Noriega's education plan (which the Democratic challenger failed to clarify) and attacked the idea that the federal government knows how to educate our children more than parents or teachers.

Supporting Evidence: Noriega Education (www.dallasnews.com)
Side: Noriega Education
2 points

The Texas coast was ravaged by Hurricane Ike this past weekend and Rick Noriega (D) was in Killeen, Texas on Saturday at the American Legion putting his service as the lieutenant colonel of the National Guard at the forefront of his message in order to remind his voters that he knows the feeling "to have to look into the eyes of a wife and their children's eyes when they come to me and say, 'Please don't take my daddy again."

He continued, "Those are things that my incumbent will never understand, and we need someone in D.C. that understands those kind of issues. I think that having voted with the president and the administration over 96 percent of the time means that your not representing Texans – your representing Washington. And Texans need a Texas senator, not a Washington senator."

Although Sen. Cornyn was invited to the event, he was not able to attend and sent Marine Lt. Col. Scott Shepherd to represent him at the gathering and tout the Senator's support of the Military Voting Protection Act, the G.I. Bill, and transportation spending bills.

Nonetheless, you can't put a price to the value of seeing a politician in his uniform and it's a real smart, noteworthy move (as this is politics) for Noriega to put his service on the front-burner of his campaign, especially on the heels of the RNC and the numerous biopics we all watched about John McCain. In a Texas election, there is a high regard for our armed forces by the winning majority vote in this state and his status and experience in the National Guard is a strong suit for Noriega's chanced in November.

Supporting Evidence: Killeen Event (www.kdhnews.com)
Side: Killeen Event
2 points

The Texas coast is still reeling after the devastation brought on by Hurricane Ike this past weekend. In the midst of assessing the damages, estimating the costs, and beginning the long process of reconstruction, both Senate candidates, Rick Noriega (D) and John Cornyn (R), scrambled to halt any further campaign advertisements from being broadcast this week for fear of being accused of exploiting the disaster for political gain.

Cornyn, though he tried to cancel his first campaign ad from being released, was unable to do so and it aired on Tuesday in Dallas, Amarillo, and Austin.

Noriega's campaign was quick to pounce on the incumbent Republican as Holly Shulman, a spokeswoman for Noriega, stated, "I'm a little surprised that they chose to run an ad when 3 million people still don't have power."

Cornyn's campaign responded by pointing out the fact that on Saturday Noriega was stumping in Killeen while Houston was being pummeled by Ike.

This bickering battle seems to push politics over the real concerns facing the Texas coastline. Rather than actively and effectively addressing our state's citizen's concerns, the two campaigns are arguing about commercials and where the other guy was while the storm destroyed thousands of homes, businesses, and property.

Nonetheless, it is worth noting here, for the voter's sake, that Noriega reported the next day (Sunday, September 14th) to Austin's Camp Mabry to assist the volunteer relief efforts for evacuees.

Supporting Evidence: Hurricane Ike Commercial Meltdown (www.dallasnews.com)
Side: Hurricane Ike Commercial Meltdown
BigIron(477) Disputed
2 points

After the sketchy delay in campaign advertisements (see post above) caused by Hurricane Ike, John Cornyn (R) has amped up his television presence over 16 television markets, cable systems, and on 16 newspaper websites across the state according to MyWestTexas.com.

One of the ads, entitled "Palo Duro", features the Republican Senator before a backdrop of the beautiful Palo Duro Canyon in the Panhandle region and boasts Cornyn's "lifetime of conservative values" and "common sense".

Another ad, entitles "Help", touches on the devastation of Hurricane Ike and urges Texans to do whatever they can to help in the relief efforts.

In the meantime, Noriega (D) has yet to relaunch his own ad campaign as he is still in active duty as lieutenant colonel of the Texas National Guard.

Cornyn released a letter both to his supporters and the press stating that he would not "run a negative ad against Noriega if Noriega's campaign would do the same," as reported by MyWestTexas.com.

The proposal comes as a relief as families and businesses are beginning the process of picking up the pieces after the flooding, destruction, and power outages wrought upon the coast by the hurricane. Many families are still living with friends, family, and in shelters across the state (particularly in Austin, TX) and a hostile election race, at this point, would seem sorely out of taste and plain disrespectful to the Texas voters.

Supporting Evidence: Keep it Positive (www.mywesttexas.com)
Side: Ads back on
2 points

Noriega (D) and Sen. Cornyn (R) spoke out today on the failure of Bush's $700 billion bailout of Wall Street to pass the House.

Noriega argued that, while the bipartisan compromise made this weekend was "a good start" in the right direction, he wants to see the bill implement tighter regulations and extend more assistance to American homeowners.

Cornyn, who has been active in the investigative efforts against the allegedly illegal practices of the mortgage giants (such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac,) is calling for more protection of taxpayers than what was proposed in the bill.

Both Noriega and Cornyn opposed the $700 billion bailout.

Regardless, the incumbent Republican Senator and his Democratic rival are scraping to use the economic crisis as a point of divergence between their two platforms. Noriega's people are criticizing Cornyn's investigation of Wall Street as too late of a response to a problem that has been festering for some time and are trying to discredit his efforts as politically motivated. Even more, they have pointed out that Cornyn himself has accepted substantial contributions from financial service companies in the past.

In response, Cornyn's campaign has asked Noriega why he doesn't extend the same criticism he's launched against Cornyn's financial past to Democratic senators who have received just as much if not more financial contributions from the same companies as the Texas Senator.

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn Noriega On the Failed Bailout (www.dallasnews.com)
Side: Cornyn Noriega on the Failed Bailout
2 points

In his latest press release, Democratic Senate candidate Rick Noriega allows Cornyn's own record in relation to President George W. Bush to point out the Republican Senator's inconsistency and hopefully sway undecided voters who may be frustrated by Cornyn's obvious political pandering.

The release includes a Cornyn quote from his 2002 Senate campaign:

"Texans want a senator who is willing and proud to work with our great president, George W. Bush."

This quote is then set alongside a more recent Cornyn quote to the Editorial Board of the Dallas Morning News:

"I have a lot of friends in the Bush administration. The problem is they've been pretty tone deaf trying to explain what they're doing. ... A lot of people have tuned them out."

Personally, I think the quotes carry little effect in accomplishing what Noriega seems to be wanting them to, but when coupled with Cornyn's voting record they make a clear point of the Republican's faults.

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn and Bush (www.ricknoriega.com)
Side: Cornyn and Bush
1 point

Rick Noriega (D) took a step up on the stump today to criticize Cornyn's vote in favor of the bailout bill that passed the Senate late Wednesday night and awaits a decision in the House.

Noriega argued that "Texans should not support a bailout that has insufficient protections for the taxpayers, doesn’t go far enough in reining in out of control executive salaries, has little relief for people in real distress, and doesn’t heal the systemic rot that led to this crisis in the first place."

"The lack of prudence and unfettered wheeling and dealing that allowed abusive and reckless loans, shoddy investments, poorly understood financial instruments, and market excess would still be in place after this bill passed. It’s like spending $700 billion to clean up a flood in your house without fixing the leak in the roof."

Noriega's appeal is targeted towards tighter regulations and more government oversight as a priority over the financial commitment of $700 billion that will allegedly push the economy back into motion. While Cornyn may agree with the need for some regulations (as most Republicans will at this point) his emphasis leans towards the idea that the more regulations the less able our markets will be able to work themselves out of the crisis themselves.

Supporting Evidence: Noriega against the bailout (www.marshallnewsmessenger.com)
Side: Noriega against the bailout
7 points

It may be more reasonable to ask “What are they voting for?”. Let’s keep in mind that in a sense when voting for Cornyn or Noriega what we are doing is voting for someone else to speak for us. I mean we all know that the some 23M people of Texas are split down the middle in how we look at the War, Social Programs, and the Economy. Right? No? Well then it might be a little more important to ask what they have a history of voting for over who you should be voting for.

Check out: http://www.votesmart.org/voting_category.php?can_id=15375 Cornyn may not sit in the middle of how I would vote given his opportunities but hey…. Close enough huh.

Side: Texas Senate Race
6 points

Who you vote for depends on the issues each nominee stands for. The differences in the views of the candidates could not be greater than in this race, and you can always tell where John Cornyn stands. He has proven himself a strong leader who has adhered strongly to his values in his campaign speeches and during his years in office. He has shown a strong commitment to our troops: He backed a provision to a veteran benefit plan recently signed by George Bush to allow vets to transfer education benefits to their spouse or children, and he recently introduced a bill to congress aimed at making absentee ballots from troops overseas count. He votes for long-term changes, not quick fixes. He wants to secure Iraq before removing troops, and the democrats in the senate recently blocked a bill he introduced in May to provide greater access to health care coverage and higher reimbursement rates for doctors who treat medicare patients. He also believes in offshore drilling to defray high fuel costs while we seek alternative energy sources, rather than remaining at the mercy of markets and undependable, foreign sources. His record shows that he consistently works for legislation that benefits Americans and improves their lives through longer-term solutions.

Side:
John Cornyn (R)
AgingSurfer(11) Disputed
4 points

I question John Cornyn's support of veterans and support of our troops.

As a Vietnam-era veteran, I feel uncomfortable when I'm asked to vote for yet another Republican candidate for high office who avoided military service during the Vietnam War. In addition, as a beneficiary of the GI Bill, I question Cornyn's commitment to supporting the troops and backing veterans' benefits. He did refuse to sign Senator Jim Webb’s “Post-9/11 Veterans Educational Assistance Act of 2007”. This is a bill that establishes a program of educational assistance for veterans of Post 9/11 wars by amending the Gi Bill to give up to 3 years of assistance to veterans seeking to get an education and training. Why vote against legislation to give education benefits to veterans of post 9/11 wars? On the one hand in this campaign, we have Rick Noriega, a veteran of Afghanistan, whose commitment to the defense of this country is a part of public record and on the other hand an arm chair warrior whose only connection to the military is that his father was a WWII veteran. Give me the boots-on-the-ground experience over the politics and empty rhetoric any day.

Supporting Evidence: John Cornyn Votes Against Expanding Education Benefits for Vets (halfempth.blogspot.com)
Side: Rick Noriega
5 points

Although he is criticized for his close ties to the Bush Administration and his high ranking among major oil corporations, John Cornyn visited the Capital Area Food Bank of Texas yesterday and announced that he was supporting the Charitable Mileage Deduction Equity Act (S. 3421). This bill, if passed, will increase tax relief to non-profit organizations and volunteers to better ensure the relief, resources, and the assistance they provide to those in need.

Supporting Evidence: Tax Relief for Non Profits (www.news8austin.com)
Side:
John Cornyn (R)
4 points

You can vote for whoever you like, John Cornyn is still going to win.

Unlike other states, it isn't a bad thing to be a Republican in Texas. Cornyn has as conservative a record as one can have, never breaking from the party lines.

The truth is, no one has ever heard of Rick Noriega and there hasn't even been a poll done in the Texas Senatorial race in two months.

At the end of the day, it says a lot about Texas politics when the guy winning is the guy putting out this campaign ad:

Big John's Campaign Ad
Side: John Cornyn
vinv(4) Disputed
3 points

Actually, there was a poll on the Texas senate race released on July 30. There were also two polls out in the second half of June. Click the link, and scroll down to where the polling graphic says "TX."

Granted, most polls (save one possible outlier) show Cornyn with roughly a 10-point lead. He's clearly the favorite. But it's not quite a foregone conclusion, as the seat could go Democrat if Obama wins big in November or Cornyn makes a "macaca"-like mistake.

Supporting Evidence: Senate Polling Update, 8/5 (www.fivethirtyeight.com)
Side: Texas Senate Race
4 points

Once again we set ourselves up with a question of "Who should I vote for..." but fear not timid little voter the mass media will be there to assist your every feeble step... Let's be realistic folks, money is king and by all comparisons John Cornyn has the money and we can all go ahead and pen this in as fact. While lacking in funds Noriega does have a large number of supporters who have no history of huge voting turnouts but somehow hold a great history of inking up the street polls as the Hispanic population, fed by immigration, is much larger than the numbers of Hispanics who are eligible to vote. All signs point to Cornyn.

Side: Texas Senate Race
4 points

This is TX, one of the reddest states. If you're not voting Repub, they shoot you for trespassing. They don't try to kill you, just remind you that you bleed red, not blue.

;)

Side: Red State
4 points

John Cornyn recently voted for a bill proposing off-shore drilling in lieu of ethanol research to help curb immediate discomfort in the food and fuel market. He says that such acts are necessary to help ease Americans into an economic lull and buy more time for congress to look into other possibilities. Many Texans, eager for a quick fix, are applauding Cornyn's environmentally unsound, but pragmatic tactics.

Cornyn tries to ease the squeeze in the food and fuel market
Side: Drilling off coast
3 points

On many issues that could prove important, Noriega is more of an unknown. There's yet to be any information as to where he stands on the death penalty, carrying guns, three-strike laws, social security, free trade, the armed forces, or taxes. While Cornyn has not been so great as a public servant, he at least has a more visible track record so Texans can pressure him to start voting in their best interests, not in those of Washington.

Supporting Evidence: Noriega's known stances (www.ontheissues.org)
Side:
John Cornyn (R)
3 points

Senator Cornyn visited El Paso August 19th to meet with local Homeland Security officials and attend a fund raiser organized by Karl Rove, according to the El Paso Times. El Paso is also the location of the Tigua Indian's Speaking Rock Casino that Cornyn sued to shut down as Texas Attorney General, and Senate opponent Rick Noreiga has mentioned Cornyn's actions as part of the Abramov Scandal. Cornyn leads Noreiga 9 to 1 in fund-raisng, and it takes large amounts of money to advertise in Texas's 20 media markets, according to the burntorangereport.com. According to news reports most voters can name Cornyn but not Noreiga.

Statesman Cornyn VS Soldier Noreiga
Side: Cornyn Leads In Money And Influence
3 points

Energy is becoming a big issue in this race, especially with John Cornyn touting his support for the off-shore drilling bill to the folks back home.

Cornyn has one of the more far-right views on the issue, supporting drilling in the continental shelves of the Atlantic and Pacific oceans, the Alaskan National Wildlife Refuge and more of the Rocky Mountain West while quickly dismissing the notion of moderate Democrats and Republicans to raise taxes on energy companies in exchange for more drilling areas.

Supporting Evidence: Big John Touts Off-Shore Drilling (www.star-telegram.com)
Side: Drilling off coast
3 points

As far as polls can show, given the average of all the disjointed reports, it seems that Cornyn has about a 10 point lead over Rick Noriega.

Nonetheless, some other interesting results regarding the Texas voter breakdown according to the Austin Chronicle (I know, this is the Austin Chronicle...):

"The UT poll says 67% of Texans think the nation is on the wrong track and 81% believe the U.S. is worse off than a year ago. (...) In the state that foisted George W. Bush upon the world, a slim majority (50.1%) now have a negative impression of the president, and although 39% identify themselves as conservative and only 20% say they are liberal, 42% say they more or less considered themselves Democrats, compared with 38% who swayed Republican."

Take the number crunch for what it is - as energy concerns and the price at the pump continue to take a top spot on voters' priorities, I suspect Cornyn to start taking a larger lead in the polls as the fall approaches based on a majority approval of offshore drilling (which he supports) and his hard line on illegal immigration (another hot button here in the Lone Star State.)

Supporting Evidence: Some Interesting Numbers (www.austinchronicle.com)
Side: Some Interesting Numbers
3 points

In an article published in the Houston Chronicle on August 24th, 2008, the paper had written quite an extensive analysis of Republican Texas Senator John Cornyn.

Senator Cornyn realized the problems and had several solutions but they were not any different from what other officials and leaders have proposed in the past. In the Chronicle Mr. Cornyn stated some of the problems:

“Predictably, patients paid a high price as well. Expectant mothers had difficulty scheduling appointments with an obstetrician-gynecologist and those in rural Texas communities often had to drive long distances to meet with an experienced physician…” and went further, “To be clear, the number of Texans without health insurance is unacceptably high. In fact, it's shameful. According to the Institute of Medicine, the uninsured are less than half as likely as persons with insurance to receive necessary health care, particularly preventive care.”

The Texas Senator is trying to talk about the differences between Health Care Access versus Coverage and does so quite effectively in the article.

Near the end of the article the Senator discusses free-markets and the economy and explains that a lack of free-market competition is the cause of the problems United States citizens face, “Lack of information and competition helps to explain why the same health insurance policy costs $8,334 in North Dakota but $10,312 in South Dakota. If consumers in South Dakota could buy that North Dakota policy, prices for health insurance would go down. Why can't they?”

According to Rasmussen GOP Senator John Cornyn is “well ahead” of Democratic legislator Rick Noriega with a lead of 48% to 37%.

Supporting Evidence: Rasmussen Poll (www.johncornyn.com)
Side:
John Cornyn (R)
3 points

Fresh off the RNC hype around Gov. Palin, John Cornyn has sought to latch onto her approval with the Republicans here in Texas by praising McCain's Vice President choice in an effort to raise more money.

From a release by Dolly Gonzalez, the Cornyn finance director:

"In an instant, Sarah Palin exposed the giant cracks in the foundation of Barack Obama and all Democrats this cycle.

Senator Cornyn's opponent has spent more than a year twisting and contorting the Senator's true record in the hopes that enough Texans will fall for it this November."

This Saturday, Cornyn addressed the Texas Federation of Republican Women in Salado to continue to tap into the Republican upswing following Palin's Vice Presidential acceptance speech.

Supporting Evidence: Riding the Palin Wave (trailblazersblog.dallasnews.com)
Side: Riding the Palin Wave
3 points

Endorsements from both John Kerry and Wesley Clark are sure to prove a liability for Noriega in more ways than one. Other than Kerry failing to deliver a victory for his party in the last presidential election, Clark had endorsed Bilderberg attendees Senator Clinton and Governor Sebelius for president and vice president, respectively.

Side:
John Cornyn (R)
2 points

Cornyn Pledges Growth by Economic and Energy Means

On Wednesday, Sen. John Cornyn went to Victoria to met with Victoria business leaders. Cornyn promises that the economy will grow if the federal government lowered taxes. Cornyn stated,

"The city is poised for significant growth. I met with many of Victoria’s business and community leaders today and assured them I will continue to do my part on the federal level to lower taxes and spur further economic growth.”

Cornyn went on to argue that a new nuclear power plant would also stimulate the economy while at the same time put America one step further towards energy independence.

“I support Exelon’s proposed nuclear power project in Victoria, which has the potential to create local jobs, generate revenue for the community, and yield significant amounts of clean energy."

Nuclear energy has been lauded for its relative efficiency and criticized for its safety risks.

Supporting Evidence: Press Release (cornyn.senate.gov)
Side: Economy
2 points

Cornyn: Commits to Doing More to Help Ike Victims

It has been almost a month since Hurricance Ike swept across the Houston vacinity and Cornyn cites that many people have returned home and many businesses have reopened. On Tuesday, Cornyn pledged to do more,

"I sent a letter with Sen. Hutchison to FEMA Administrator Paulison, calling on him to expedite the delivery of critically needed temporary housing units for Texans who remain displaced. We also reiterated the need to honor Governor Perry’s request for a 60-day extension of the 100 percent reimbursement for debris removal."

Though pleased with present relief initiatives, Cornyn urged that more must be done,

"While we’ve had success in securing a significant amount of funding and tax relief measures that will directly help hurricane victims recover, I’m still pushing for additional relief, especially in regards to temporary housing and clean-up reimbursements. ”

Supporting Evidence: Press Release (cornyn.senate.gov)
Side: Hurricane Ike Commercial Meltdown
2 points

Cornyn Critical of the Release of Chinese Muslims from Guantanamo

“The district court’s decision is outrageous and irresponsible," reacted Cornyn after the release of 17 Uighurs held at Guantanamo. Indignant, he argued that the federal judiciary lacked compentence in matters of diplomacy and national security.

Basing his stance on President Bush, Cornyn argues that the prisoners received military training from the Taliban in Afghanistan. It has yet to be determined, however, whether the Chinese nationals have committed any crimes or what specific threats they pose to national security.

Supporting Evidence: Press Release (cornyn.senate.gov)
Side: Guantanamo
1 point

Senator serves his constituents very well as a forceful and articulate voice for Texas values on the Armed Services and Judiciary and Budget committees. He believes in low taxes and limited government—the government that governs least, governs best. He believes in the power of individuals, and does not treat people as members of groups. He believes that providing a strong national defense is the first duty of the federal government. As a Texan, he is a proud supporter of President Bush’s judicial nominees—including the successful appointments of Chief Justice John Roberts and Associate Justice Samuel Alito to the U.S. Supreme Court; he continues to work tirelessly on behalf of Texas military personnel, veterans and their families; he has played a leading role in securing our nation’s borders, while working to bring about broader reforms of our broken immigration system; and he stands as a dedicated defender of free markets, traditional values and individual liberty.

Side: John Cornyn
omnidave(96) Disputed
3 points

Texas has the highest number of uninsured adults in the U.S., yet Senator Cornyn believes that the rest of America should follow Texas's example. He appears to believe that creating a pro-business environment despite public concerns about health care is the way to go. One of 18 senators to recently oppose the national expansion of health care for children, Cornyn also has been rated the number three Bush supporter in the U.S. Senate for his near automatic support of Administration policies.

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn Happy With Current Health System (www.chron.com)
Side: Strong Bush Supporter
1 point

Texas Sen. John Cornyn (R) is looking to get his hands dirty by rehashing a 2006 record that suggested that Fannie Mae had overstated their earnings in order to increase bonuses and payouts at the executive level.

Cornyn's probing comes just weeks after the government bailout of both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and he has sent a letter to Attorney General Michael Mukasey requesting further investigation.

Cornyn's angle against the bailout wants to fairly address the "serious concerns whether a well-documented culture of corporate executive corruption at these organizations contributed to the mortgage giants' collapse."

While the initial 2006 findings reported by the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight resulted in a $400 million fine against Fannie Mae, Cornyn is pushing his chips in that perhaps a continuation of such "illegal activities" by the mortgage giants are what eventually "led to the institutions' failure."

Cornyn's initiative is something to be noted as the government's bailout of both Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae recently has become a hot-button issue for many of the fiscally conservative voters. It's safe to say that Cornyn is against the hand-outs and bail-outs these companies received at Bush's request, he is not against the government's role in keeping such organizations on a tight leash to prevent such illegal activities or practices from unfairly taking advantage of the American consumer.

Fannie Mae has yet to comment on Cornyn's investigation.

Supporting Evidence: Dirty Hands (www.chron.com)
Side: Dirty Hands
1 point

Cornyn's most recent campaign move pointed a cautionary finger at this Democratic rival, Rick Noriega, and warned established and potential Republican donors of how dangerous another 60 or so Democrats in the Senate will be (the stated goal, more or less, of the Democratic Party in November.)

Cornyn asked for more donations and further support from his base via an email from his financial director, Dolly Gonzalez, which said, ""We need to keep the gas on for the next 40 days to make sure our opponents' dreams of a filibuster Senate don't become a reality."

Cornyn is hoping to preserve his seat in the Senate with the argument that his Republican platform is essential to the survival of bipartisan legislation on Capital Hill. According to his campaign communications director, Kevin McLaughlin, "It would be bad enough if Barack and Biden get elected, but imagine if they had 'rubber-stamp Rick' there too; there will be no stopping them from shoving their liberal agenda down our throats."

Supporting Evidence: The Survival of Bipartisanship (trailblazersblog.dallasnews.com)
Side: The Survival of Bipartisanship
1 point

Cornyn Supports Bailout

Cornyn explains that he voted for the bailout bill because he believes that despite the "irresponsible" behavior on Wall Street, government inaction is not an option. According to the incumbent, small businesses would suffer due to the inability to borrow money. After the vote he stated,

“But right now, we cannot allow taxpayers, families and small businesses in Texas to pay the steep price of inaction. A widespread financial collapse will have a domino effect throughout our State. It might begin on Wall Street but it will ultimately hit Texas families and small businesses the hardest. This is not a theory or hyperbole or a scare tactic. It is a fact.

“If credit markets freeze, local banks will be unable to provide loans for small businesses, which are the backbone of our economy. I’ve heard from small business owners across Texas in recent days and already credit is disappearing while interest rates are rising. As small business budgets tighten, paychecks for workers will be in jeopardy, and families across Texas may be unable to pay their bills, send their kids to college or even put food on the table. We cannot allow this to happen. "

Further, he believes the bill enacts more oversight, transparency, taxpayer protection, and limiting executive compensation.

Supporting Evidence: Supports Bailout (cornyn.senate.gov)
Side: Bailout
1 point

John Cornyn (R) cast his vote in favor of the modified bailout measure on Wednesday but shot a rare critical remark against the President and his administration.

In his latest ad (aired today, Thursday), Cornyn argued, "It shouldn’t have happened. Washington only got to work when the answer was too late and too expensive.”

Cornyn has been involved with congressional efforts to keep the financial markets accountable and is currently working with the federal investigations into Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Lehman Brothers.

His frustration with the administration continued, "I also regret that the administration mishandled early communications on this plan, seeming to focus on a bailout of finance industry firms instead of concentrating on the need to protect the interests of Main Street.”

“It is difficult to consider approving any proposal after this uneven performance."

In other somewhat relevant news, the Texas Senator was also proud to announce today that he had received endorsements from "35 local elected officials and law enforcement leaders from traditionally Democratic border areas", according to the Dallas Morning News.

Supporting Evidence: More Bailout Talk and Endorsements (www.dallasnews.com)
Side: More Bailout Talk and Endorsements
1 point

Sen. John Cornyn (R) announced last Friday that his campaign had raised up to $1.9 million in the third quarter of 2008 and has a total of $7.2 million ready in the account to carry his campaign through the last month of the race.

Cornyn's campaign manager, Rob Jesmer, described the deeper meaning that lies behind the financial contributions:

"Fundraising is about more than dollars and cents and the ability to run television ads. It is also a measure of enthusiasm and support for a candidate. Sen. Cornyn considers himself very fortunate to have a lot of both, especially from Texans."

Both Cornyn and his Democratic challenger, Rick Noriega, reported substantial financial gains in this last quarter, yet the Republican holds a much heavier purse at this point over Noriega's campaign account just over $2 million.

Supporting Evidence: Cornyn's Purse (www.dallasnews.com)
Side: Cornyn's Purse